Creative Person Doesn't Want to Support Friend's AI Music Career, Believes It Is Cheating

As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly ingrained in the lives of millions, it is making astounding breakthroughs. Even in the music industry, AI is making waves.

By facilitating the rapid creation of songs, customizing suggestions, and improving production procedures, artificial intelligence is radically transforming the music business. We have an AI-inspired story today, and the OP just had to bring it to the AITA subreddit community.

The OP has a friend who enjoys making music. She writes her own music and lyrics and plays them on a guitar. The OP says her friend has always been decent at both but never exceptional.

Then comes the AI music tool, which the OP's friend discovered and began using. You only need to provide it with prompts and lyrics, and it will generate whatever genre and style you like with AI-generated instruments and vocals.

Although some AI-generated musicians are already becoming well-known on streaming services, human emotion and subtle creativity continue to be crucial differences. Even though AI tools can produce music in response to text cues and even imitate well-known musicians, the OP feels it takes away from the creative process and "craftsmanship" of making music.

So you can imagine the OP's response when her friend wanted her to support her "music career." The OP's friend is so enamored with the songs she's created using AI that she's started a campaign for them.

Find out more as you scroll down to get the full story.

And the OP writes:

Reddit

OP's friend has always been decent at both but never exceptional.

Reddit

OP feels it takes away from the creative process and "craftsmanship."

Reddit

Dr. Michael S. Scott, a music industry consultant, argues that while AI can enhance creativity, it should not replace the human touch in music creation. He emphasizes that artistry stems from personal experiences and emotions, which AI cannot replicate.

Scott states, "The soul of music is derived from the human experience; AI lacks the emotional depth that defines true artistry." This perspective emphasizes that the craftsmanship of music involves more than just technical skills—it requires a connection to the human experience, something AI is not equipped to produce.

Conclusion

As the music industry continues to evolve with AI, the importance of maintaining a balance between innovation and human creativity cannot be overstated. Experts emphasize that embracing AI as a tool rather than viewing it as a competitor can unlock new creative potentials.

By integrating AI thoughtfully into the creative process, artists can enhance their craft while preserving the emotional depth that defines true artistry. The future of music will likely thrive on collaboration between human creators and AI technology, fostering a rich tapestry of innovation and expression.

She's published an album on Spotify and advertises it on Instagram.

Reddit

OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the a**hole:

I have refused to promote my friend's music because I disagree with the creative process. That might make me an a**hole friend.

And the comments roll in...

Reddit

She created nothing.

Reddit

Balancing Technology and Artistry

As AI tools become increasingly prevalent in music production, industry experts suggest that artists should view these technologies as collaborators rather than competitors. Tony Robbins, a renowned life coach, advises creatives to embrace innovation while maintaining their unique voice.

He notes, "Utilizing AI can free up time for artists to focus on their core creative work, allowing them to explore new ideas and directions." This balanced approach could enhance creativity rather than stifle it, ensuring the essence of artistry is preserved.

The AI-generated music.

Reddit

It's not her music career.

Reddit

"Do not support AI."

Reddit

Dr. Carol Dweck, a psychologist known for her work on mindset, highlights that the fear of AI overshadowing human creativity may stem from a fixed mindset. Instead of viewing AI as a threat, she encourages a growth mindset, which embraces learning and adaptation.

Dweck states, "When artists see AI as a tool for growth rather than a competitor, they can unlock new creative potentials and evolve their craft." This shift in perspective could foster a more collaborative environment between human creators and AI technology.

A friend that is a failed hack.

Reddit

Using plagiarized slop.

Reddit

It doesn't really matter.

Reddit

Enhancing Human Creativity

To address concerns about AI in music, experts recommend practical strategies for musicians. Dr. Robert Marzano, an education researcher, suggests artists focus on skill enhancement through AI tools, such as utilizing AI for music production while maintaining personal input in composition.

He explains that blending technology with traditional techniques can open new avenues for creativity, allowing musicians to experiment and innovate while retaining their artistic integrity.

The OP doesn't need to be a cheerleader.

Reddit

Art AI should be shunned.

Reddit

The computer wrote the lyrics.

Reddit

Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond, an education expert, points out that AI can serve as a teaching tool for aspiring musicians. By analyzing compositions and providing feedback, AI can help nurture talent in ways that traditional methods may not.

She notes, "AI can aid in understanding musical theory and structure, making learning more accessible." This could democratize music education, allowing more individuals to explore their creativity without the barriers of traditional learning environments.

She is not a musician.

Reddit

AI music is surprisingly good.

Reddit

Using AI erodes talent.

Reddit

The Future of Music and AI

The music industry is at a crossroads, and understanding the implications of AI on creativity is crucial. Suze Orman, a financial advisor, believes that artists must also consider the business side of their craft in the age of AI.

She states, "Understanding how to leverage AI for marketing and distribution can enhance an artist's reach, ultimately allowing them to thrive financially while exploring their creative passions." This dual focus on artistry and business acumen will be vital for future success.

"AI is killing our environment."

Reddit

The OP's not a bad friend.

Reddit

She's a lyricist at best.

Reddit

Industry insiders note that AI's role in music creation can lead to ethical discussions about authorship and originality. Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist, suggests that these conversations are essential for defining the future landscape of creativity.

She explains, "Establishing guidelines for AI's involvement in music creation will help maintain the integrity of artistic expression, ensuring that human creativity remains at the forefront." This ongoing dialogue is crucial for navigating the complexities introduced by AI technologies.

The OP should be applauded.

Reddit

Realistically, and depending on how competent the program is, some Redditors believe that if OP's friend ever takes off, people will find out that she’s using AI. This will, at a minimum, be embarrassing and, at worst, career-ending.

Still, some people actually enjoy AI music, but the OP has every right not to support her friend since she doesn't like what she's doing. The OP was declared not the AH, and you can drop your own verdict in the comments section below.

Expert Opinion

The OP's resistance to supporting her friend's AI-generated music highlights the deep connection many people feel between creativity and personal identity. For her, music isn't just about the end product; it's about the emotional journey and craftsmanship involved, which she sees as compromised by AI. This reflects a broader psychological struggle many face when technology disrupts traditional artistic expressions, triggering feelings of authenticity and value in creative endeavors.

As we look ahead, the relationship between human creativity and AI in music will be crucial for shaping the industry’s future. Experts like Dr. Robert Marzano and Tony Robbins advocate for a proactive approach, encouraging musicians to leverage AI tools to enhance their creative processes rather than fearing them. This collaborative spirit can lead to groundbreaking artistic expressions that honor the unique human experience at the heart of music.

Ultimately, fostering open discussions about ethics and creativity will help navigate the challenges posed by AI, ensuring a vibrant future for artists and audiences alike.