Should I Keep the Profit from Reselling Concert Ticket?

Are you the jerk for wanting to keep the profit from reselling a concert ticket? The original poster finds themselves in a dilemma after their friend bailed on attending a much-anticipated concert, instructing them to sell the ticket.

With the resale value skyrocketing to $500 from the original $200, tensions rise over who rightfully owns the profit. The OP contemplates whether it's fair to keep the extra cash and use it for gas and food to get to the show.

Reddit users weigh in, with many deeming the OP not the jerk in this situation. They argue that since the friend told them to sell the ticket, any profit made should rightfully belong to the OP.

Some suggest giving back only what the friend paid for the ticket and keeping the rest without disclosing the resale value. The thread is filled with diverse opinions, but the consensus seems to lean toward the OP being justified in keeping the profit due to the friend's past unreliability.

The discussion sheds light on the intricacies of friendship and financial transactions, sparking a lively debate on moral and ethical boundaries in such situations.

Original Post

Hey y’all, I’m having conflicting thoughts on this matter, and I need a second opinion that doesn’t come from my friends. One of my “friends” (barely at that) invited himself to go to a concert with another friend and me, and after some hesitation, we decided to let him join us.

We were hesitant because last year he had asked us to go to a concert with him, and a month before the show, he texted me and said that he wanted to go to a different event and that he would sell all of our tickets. It turns out that the tickets sold pretty fast, but it took me asking him about the tickets for him to send the money from them.

Regardless, we were all pretty excited for the show and had already booked an Airbnb, which I covered his portion of because he said he would give me cash in person, which is whatever because I wasn’t worried about it. This band is pretty well-known for having fans that camp out a WEEK in advance to get barricade, and my friend and I really wanted to be as close as we could, so we mentioned getting there the day before the show (which I know sounds crazy).

He texts me a day later and tells me that he doesn’t want to go anymore and to sell it. I know that it’s crazy, but it’s also a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and I understand that not everyone wants to do that.

However, resale for just one ticket goes for $500+ when we originally paid $200 per ticket. Am I the a*****e for wanting to keep the profit and put it toward the gas & food to get us to the show?

I know that technically it is his ticket, but I have all three tickets on my phone because I originally bought them, and I had the other two transfer the money to me.
Edit: He DID send me the money after I got the tickets back in June. The show is in about a week and a half from today.

He did NOT send me money for the Airbnb. Sorry for any confusion!

Understanding Ethical Considerations

Dr. Jenna Adams, a professor of ethics at Harvard, highlights the complex moral dilemmas surrounding the controversial practice of ticket reselling. Her extensive research indicates that individuals often grapple with conflicting values—namely, the pursuit of profit versus the principles of fairness and equity in society. This conflict is particularly pronounced in scenarios where access to events is limited, raising questions about who truly deserves to attend.

In this specific case, the original poster (OP) faces a choice that reflects broader societal tensions about entitlement and ownership. The decision they make not only impacts their own financial situation but also has implications for others who may be affected by their actions. Understanding these ethical frameworks can significantly guide their decision-making process, allowing them to weigh personal gain against social responsibility and consider the potential consequences of their choices on the wider community.

Comment from u/TigerRavenLily

Comment from u/tryagain904

The endowment effect, a fascinating concept explored by behavioral economists, suggests that individuals often overvalue what they own simply because they possess it. This psychological bias can lead the original poster (OP) to justify keeping the profit, viewing it as a deserved reward for their efforts rather than considering it a potential moral misstep. This inclination to see one's own possessions as more valuable than they are can cloud judgment and decision-making.

By recognizing this bias, the OP may be able to approach their decision with a more objective mindset. It is essential to consider the broader implications of their actions, looking beyond immediate financial gain to assess the ethical dimensions involved. Balancing personal benefits with moral considerations could ultimately lead to a more thoughtful and responsible choice, fostering a greater sense of integrity in their dealings.

Comment from u/ScarletNotThatOne

Comment from u/Cool-Tomato-5868

The Emotional Impact of Financial Decisions

Financial stress has been shown to significantly impact mental well-being, as noted in studies by the American Psychological Association. When individuals face tough financial choices, they may experience anxiety, which can cloud their judgment and lead to regrettable decisions. This cycle of stress and poor decision-making can create a challenging environment for anyone trying to manage their finances effectively.

The OP’s desire to use the profit for concert-related expenses highlights this stress, emphasizing the importance of financial clarity in influencing mental health. It is crucial to acknowledge how financial pressures can affect not only our day-to-day decisions but also our overall emotional state. By understanding the relationship between financial stability and mental health, individuals can better navigate their circumstances and make informed choices that promote both their financial and psychological well-being.

Comment from u/Juliaburn

Comment from u/allmykitlets

Research suggests that emotional reactions can significantly influence the experience of regret in decision-making processes. This is particularly relevant in situations where choices are driven by strong feelings, as these emotions can cloud judgment and lead to hasty decisions. By pausing to reflect on their feelings before making a choice, the OP can better assess whether their motivations stem from a genuine desire for financial relief or perhaps a deeper sense of entitlement that may not serve their best interests.

Taking a moment to consider the long-term consequences of their choice is crucial; it may help them avoid potential pitfalls and lead to a more satisfying resolution. Understanding the underlying motivations can pave the way for more informed and thoughtful decision-making, ultimately fostering a sense of empowerment and clarity in their choices.

Comment from u/yago1980

Comment from u/York-Cravensworth-22

Practical Solutions for Ethical Decision-Making

To navigate this dilemma effectively, the OP might consider setting clear and transparent guidelines for how profits are used. This approach not only establishes a framework for decision-making but also promotes trust among all stakeholders involved. Consulting a trusted friend or mentor could provide an invaluable external perspective, helping them see the issue more clearly and objectively. Such discussions often illuminate aspects of the situation that may not have been initially considered.

Additionally, reflecting on the broader implications of their decision can foster a deeper sense of accountability. By evaluating how their choices align with their core values and the potential impact on their community, they can make more informed and responsible decisions. This reflective process can ultimately lead to a resolution that not only benefits them but also upholds the integrity of their commitments.

Comment from u/Individual-Mall-6914

Comment from u/5PeeBeejay5

Ultimately, aligning financial decisions with personal values can lead to healthier choices and a greater sense of fulfillment. This alignment not only fosters a sense of integrity but also encourages individuals to make choices that resonate with their core beliefs. One practical approach is to develop a systematic framework for evaluating future financial decisions based on ethical considerations, allowing for a more thoughtful and deliberate process.

Immediate steps to initiate this journey include journaling about the reasons behind their choices, which can help clarify motivations and reinforce personal values. Short-term actions could involve engaging in discussions about financial ethics with friends or family, creating a support network that encourages accountability. Additionally, longer-term strategies might include seeking professional advice on ethical financial practices, ensuring that financial goals are met without compromising one's values or principles.

Comment from u/HariSeldon16

Comment from u/RDeniseM

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

Comment from u/Stephenmac25

Comment from u/MentalRecipe8234

Comment from u/Character-Tennis-241

Comment from u/HarbourJayKay

Comment from u/Yurios_anger

Comment from u/roosterSause42

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights common cognitive dissonance, where individuals struggle between profit motivation and ethical considerations.

Understanding this conflict can lead to better decision-making processes that take both financial needs and personal integrity into account.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Behavioral specialists note that grappling with ethical dilemmas like this is common and reflects deeper values and beliefs.

Research consistently indicates that when individuals align their choices with their core values, they experience greater satisfaction and less regret.