Adele's Hit Faces Global Ban After Shocking Plagiarism Lawsuit

Accusations of plagiarism in the music industry are uncommon, often leading to heated legal battles. These disputes can arise when similarities between songs are perceived as too striking to be a coincidence, leading to claims that one artist has copied another’s work.

One such case has recently made headlines, involving the internationally acclaimed British singer Adele. The dispute centers around her song "Million Years Ago," from her 2015 album 25, and a Brazilian samba track called "Mulheres" by composer Toninho Geraes.

Geraes claims that Adele's song plagiarizes his 1995 hit, popularized by Brazilian singer Martinho da Vila. Toninho Geraes, a respected figure in Brazilian music, alleges that Adele's acoustic track, which features only a guitar, mirrors the melody of his song "Mulheres."

The composer’s lawyer, Fredimio Trotta, emphasized that "Mulheres" is a significant work in Brazilian music and has influenced numerous international hits. Geraes believes that Adele's song, in particular, shares enough similarities with his track to constitute plagiarism.

As part of the lawsuit, he is seeking songwriting credit for the hit, compensation for lost royalties, and $160,000 in moral damages. The Brazilian composer had been quiet for some time before making his claims public in 2021.

He expressed that his goal was not to create a public spectacle but to seek fair compensation for his song's influence on the global music scene. Geraes also made it clear that his aim was not to harm Adele personally but to ensure that his contributions to music were recognized and properly credited.

He said, “If there is justice, I should be compensated for what this song has already generated in dividends.”

Adele's "Million Years Ago" is facing accusations of plagiarism.

On December 13, 2024, the case took a significant turn when Judge Victor Torres issued an injunction in Rio de Janeiro's sixth commercial court. The ruling ordered major record labels Sony and Universal, representing Adele, to remove "Million Years Ago" from streaming platforms worldwide.

The injunction also prohibits the use, reproduction, editing, distribution, or commercialization of the song by any means, whether physical, digital, or through streaming. The companies involved were warned that failure to comply with the order would result in an $8,000 fine, although the labels can appeal the decision.

Getty Images

This legal action is part of a broader movement in the music industry where artists and composers are increasingly vigilant about the use of their work. Trotta, Geraes' lawyer, expressed that the ruling sends a strong message to international producers and artists who might consider using Brazilian music for their own gain.

He hopes that the decision will make others think twice before borrowing elements of Brazilian culture without proper acknowledgment. His firm also ensures that radio stations, TV broadcasters, and streaming platforms are aware of the court's ruling.

Navigating Plagiarism in Music

In the realm of music, accusations of plagiarism can be particularly damaging. Billboard notes that these disputes often hinge on the complexity of copyright law and the subjective nature of musical interpretation.

Dr. Lawrence Lessig, a law professor and copyright expert, explains that understanding the legal frameworks surrounding music can help artists navigate these treacherous waters. He emphasizes that artists should document their creative processes, as this can serve as a protective measure against future claims.

Furthermore, engaging in collaborative efforts with legal advisors can provide clarity on the intricacies of copyright laws, ensuring that artists remain compliant while still expressing their creativity.

This isn't the first time the song has faced accusations of plagiarism.

Interestingly, "Million Years Ago" had previously faced accusations of plagiarism shortly after its release. Fans of Turkish singer Ahmet Kaya claimed that Adele's song shared similarities with Kaya's 1985 track "Acilara Tutunmak" (Clinging to Pain).

Despite the claims, Kaya’s widow suggested that Adele had unlikely copied the song, as the two artists did not share a close connection. Nonetheless, the accusations highlight how artists often face scrutiny regarding the originality of their work, especially when songs share common elements or styles.

Getty Images

The case between Geraes and Adele illustrates how tricky copyright issues can be in the music world. Some people believe it's normal for songs to sound similar, especially when they come from the same cultural roots, while others think artists should be compensated fairly for their work.

In this case, Geraes isn’t just asking for money; he wants recognition for his contribution to music that has inspired artists worldwide. Adele hasn't publicly commented on the legal situation, and her team hasn’t addressed the court's decision.

Whether Geraes will win the case is still uncertain, but it could have a significant impact on how international artists handle music from different cultures.

Plagiarism claims can serve as a wake-up call for artists to examine their creative inspirations closely. Music industry expert, Tim Ingham, highlights the importance of fostering originality while acknowledging influences.

Building a robust creative process that includes diverse influences can help mitigate risks. Ingham suggests that artists explore unique soundscapes and collaborate with other musicians to ensure freshness in their work. Establishing a culture of creativity that values individual expression may reduce the likelihood of facing such legal challenges in the future.

Solutions & Coping Strategies

The current plagiarism lawsuit against Adele highlights the delicate balance between inspiration and imitation in the music industry. Acknowledging artistic influences while cultivating a unique sound is vital for artists to avoid legal pitfalls. As Dr. Lessig emphasizes, clear documentation and collaboration with legal experts can provide a safety net for musicians.

Ultimately, the industry must adapt to these challenges by fostering a culture of originality and support, allowing artists to thrive while respecting the intellectual property of others. This approach not only enhances creativity but also protects artists from potential disputes.