Andrew Garfield Open To Returning As Spider-Man, But Only Under One Condition

Andrew Garfield, the beloved actor who brought The Amazing Spider-Man to life in 2012 and its sequel in 2014, has thrilled fans with the possibility of reprising his iconic role—but only if the story meets his standards.

In an exclusive interview with PEOPLE, the 41-year-old actor opened up about his journey as Peter Parker and his thoughts on returning to the Spider-Verse.

Garfield most recently swung back into action in the 2021 mega-hit Spider-Man: No Way Home, where he joined forces with fellow web-slingers Tobey Maguire and Tom Holland. This unexpected comeback reignited a fan frenzy, leaving many hopeful for more from Garfield’s version of the hero.

But despite the hype, Garfield insists he won’t jump back into the Spidey suit unless the project feels genuinely fresh and meaningful. His reflections on No Way Home reveal that he’s selective about his choices, wanting to ensure that any future projects of his live up to the character’s rich legacy.

“It has to be worthwhile,” he said, emphasizing that he would only return if the concept brings something new and exciting to Spider-Man’s story. Garfield’s openness to revisiting the role—under the right conditions—has left fans eagerly speculating about the future of the Spider-Verse.

What Would Bring Andrew Garfield Back to the Role?

Garfield explained that it would take a “great idea, a great concept” to bring him back to the Spider-Verse. “Something surprising and odd, and fun—something that’s joyful. It has to be worthwhile,” he shared.

Jaimie Trueblood/©Columbia Pictures/Courtesy Everett Collection; Daniele Venturelli/Getty

For Garfield, the last outing in No Way Home was a special moment, and he wants to make sure any future projects involving his Spider-Man maintain that magic.

“We had such a great time on that last one that you want to just go, ‘Okay. Leave it. It was great. It worked,’” he added, emphasizing that he doesn’t want to revisit the role unless it feels “additive” to the character’s story.

Jaimie Trueblood/©Columbia Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection

A Joyful Return for the Right Reasons

Reflecting on Spider-Man: No Way Home, Garfield expressed his appreciation for the film’s creative risks and how it allowed his version of Spider-Man to experience a powerful redemption arc.

In the film, his character saves MJ (played by Zendaya), offering closure to his own tragic story involving Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone). “I’m proud and happy that I got to be a part of that,” he said. Garfield stressed that while he’s open to returning, it would only be if the concept feels fresh and unique. “If there’s something that can be concocted that feels additive to the canon, then for sure,” he noted.

Jon Kopaloff/Getty

The Importance of Narrative Integrity

Andrew Garfield's insistence on a compelling story reflects a broader trend in the film industry, where narrative integrity is crucial for character-driven films. Jason Bloom, a renowned film producer, emphasizes that a strong script can elevate not only the actor's performance but also the entire cinematic experience. His work on various successful franchises showcases how well-crafted narratives resonate deeply with audiences, creating lasting emotional impacts.

Garfield’s condition for returning as Spider-Man highlights a growing expectation among actors to engage with meaningful, well-rounded storytelling. This trend could encourage filmmakers to prioritize quality writing as a foundation for future superhero films.

Experts agree that character development is a key aspect of successful cinematic storytelling. Dr. John Truby, a leading narrative consultant, argues that characters need to evolve meaningfully throughout their journeys, which keeps audiences invested in their arcs. His approach suggests that when actors like Garfield demand quality narratives, they’re advocating for richer experiences that benefit both the viewer and the film’s legacy.

Moreover, filmmakers could enhance their projects by actively seeking feedback from actors during the script development process, ensuring that the characters' evolution aligns with the actors’ insights. This collaboration could lead to more authentic portrayals that resonate with audiences.

A Love for Spider-Man That Never Fades

Garfield reiterated his love for the character, emphasizing that any return would be about bringing joy to audiences. “I love that character, and it brings joy. If part of what I bring is joy, then I’m joyful in return.” His deep appreciation for the role shows his commitment to delivering a meaningful performance rather than just reappearing for the sake of nostalgia.

A24

Garfield’s enthusiasm for the character’s potential is clear—he’s not ruling out another swing through the city, but he’s waiting for the right story to make it worthwhile.

Garfield’s dedication to bringing authenticity and joy to the Spider-Man legacy proves that if he does make a return, it’ll be a moment fans won’t want to miss.

Psychological Insights & Implications

As Andrew Garfield contemplates his return to the Spider-Man franchise, it's clear that the intersection of storytelling and character development remains vital. The insights from industry experts like Jason Bloom and Dr. John Truby highlight the importance of crafting narratives that engage both actors and audiences alike.

By prioritizing strong scripts and character arcs, filmmakers can create a richer cinematic experience that not only honors the legacy of beloved characters but also draws in new fans. Ultimately, the future of superhero films may hinge on their commitment to storytelling excellence.