Utah Woman Pleads Guilty to Husband’s Murder as Chilling Internet Searches Come to Light
The case has shocked many due to the involvement of Kathryn’s close family members.
A Utah woman who admitted to plotting and carrying out the murder of her estranged husband is now facing sentencing after disturbing details about the case—including her internet history—have come to light.
Kathryn Restelli, 37, has pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and felony discharge of a firearm in connection with the July 2024 killing of her husband, Matthew Restelli. The case has shocked many due to both the calculated nature of the act and the involvement of Kathryn’s close family members.
According to prosecutors, Kathryn left California after separating from Matthew and relocated to her mother’s home in American Fork, Utah, with her children. There, investigators say she conspired with her mother, Tracy Grist, and brother, Kevin Ellis, to lure Matthew into a trap under the false pretense of reconciliation.
Prosecutors allege Kathryn invited Matthew to help pack up belongings, creating a scenario that would allow the family to claim he entered uninvited. While she went upstairs, her mother and brother waited. When Matthew entered, Ellis reportedly fired multiple rounds, killing him. A knife was then planted on his body in an attempt to fabricate a self-defense narrative.
American Fork Police Officer Joseph Nordin testified that their story quickly unraveled.
“Matthew Restelli is left-handed, and he's holding [the knife] in his right hand. Along with that, during the autopsy, a bullet wound was found in his right wrist … the same hand he's holding the knife with,” he stated.
Kathryn and Her Family Reportedly Conspired to Kill Her Estranged Husband
kathrynsamantha/FacebookAdding to the grim picture were Kathryn’s internet searches, which included researching past homicide cases and, bizarrely, “what attracts mountain lions to humans.” Prosecutors believe these searches reflect the depth of premeditation involved. Her mother reportedly searched gun laws and recent shootings in the days leading up to the crime.
Matthew was killed shortly after entering the Utah home. The case has drawn significant attention online, with many questioning how such an elaborate plan could involve multiple family members.
Understanding the Psychology of Premeditated Crime
Perpetrators of premeditated crimes, such as Kathryn Restelli, exhibit certain psychological traits that can lead them to plan and execute their actions. According to a study by Buss and Duntley, individuals involved in premeditated violent acts often demonstrate higher levels of Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy—traits collectively known as the Dark Triad. In Kathryn's case, her meticulous planning might suggest a higher level of Machiavellianism, characterized by manipulation and a lack of morality.
Matthew Was Shot After He Entered the Home in Utah
Law&Crime/YouTubeKathryn is scheduled to be sentenced on September 9. Her mother and brother are facing charges of first-degree murder, conspiracy, obstruction of justice, and domestic violence in the presence of children. Kevin Ellis also faces firearm and drug-related charges. Their joint trial is expected to begin in January.
Involving family members in criminal activities, as seen in Kathryn's case, is indicative of a certain psychological profile. According to Dr. Ramani Durvasula, a clinical psychologist, "Individuals who manipulate their family members often do so out of a distorted sense of loyalty, believing they are protecting their loved ones." This manipulation can exploit the emotional bonds within families, leading to destructive outcomes. Dr. Durvasula emphasizes that such behavior is often rooted in complex psychological issues that require professional intervention.
The Role of Technology in Crime
Kathryn's use of the internet to plan her crime points to the growing role of technology in criminal behavior. Dr. Barry Schwartz, a renowned choice researcher, emphasizes that "the internet provides unprecedented access to information, which can sometimes lead individuals down dark paths." He notes that while technology can facilitate premeditated crime by offering anonymity and resources, it ultimately does not absolve individuals of their moral responsibilities. For further insights on the intersection of technology and behavior, you can visit his website at barryschwartz.org.
Analysis & Alternative Approaches
Overall, this case provides a troubling glimpse into the psychology of premeditated crime. Kathryn Restelli's actions, from her calculated planning to the involvement of her family members, speak volumes about her psychological state. As Dr. Susan David, an emotional agility expert, notes, "Understanding the emotional drivers behind such actions is crucial for prevention and intervention." This case emphasizes the need for continued study into the psychological underpinnings of criminal activities, particularly how modern technology can facilitate such acts. For more insights, visit Dr. Susan David's website.
