Dog Trainer Clashes With Father-In-Law Over Training Methods

In the ever-evolving world of dog training, methodologies and philosophies can vary as widely as the breeds themselves. This variance becomes particularly pronounced when traditional approaches collide with modern, specialized training techniques.

When you know a lot about training dogs, especially those trained for special jobs like police work, it can get tricky when family members think they know better. This is a story from a dog trainer who excels at her job and has a trained German Shepherd for personal protection.

However, her father-in-law, who prefers Labs and adheres to old training methods, keeps trying to give her advice on how to train her dog. He doesn't understand that the training methods she employs are specific and effective.

He often suggests that she should use simpler, one-word commands and questions the necessity of commands in German. He even attempts to teach her dog different commands than those she has trained it to follow.

On top of that, he doesn't grasp that protection dogs, like hers, are trained to be calm and controlled, not aggressive. OP has tried explaining her methods politely, hoping to avoid hurting her father-in-law's feelings, as he doesn't take criticism well.

But she has reached a point where she wonders if being direct and telling him to stop is the only way forward.

OP is a dog trainer with experience in various breeds, including police and military dogs.

OP has a GSD trained for personal protection, her husband has Labs, and her father-in-law currently has a Black Lab.

Each time OP's in-laws visit, her father-in-law insists on giving training advice for her dog.

The Importance of Training and Consistency

The effectiveness of dog training is a critical factor in ensuring a harmonious home environment. Research indicates that consistent training not only improves a dog's behavior but also enhances the relationship between the dog and its owner.

In this case, the father-in-law's training methods may be causing friction due to differing philosophies on pet care, highlighting the need for a unified approach to dog training.

He tries to teach his dog commands, but he lacks patience.

OP's FIL always insists that using a two-word command to make the dog enter her crate is confusing and that shouting one word is faster.

OP has faced criticism regarding protection dogs being aggressive, but they are trained to control their force.

Behavioral psychology emphasizes that dogs, like humans, thrive on routine and structure. Studies show that dogs trained with positive reinforcement exhibit less anxiety and more predictable behavior, which can significantly reduce stress for all family members.

This situation underscores the importance of aligning training methods to ensure consistent expectations for the dog, thereby promoting peaceful coexistence.

OP's FIL has traditional views on disciplining a dog, which clash with OP's more rational and polite approach.

Dog training is OP's profession.

Reddit

OP should tell him that she has her own way of working with the dog.

Reddit

Navigating Family Dynamics

Family dynamics can be complex, especially when differing opinions on pet care come into play. Research in family psychology suggests that unresolved conflicts can lead to resentment and tension among family members.

In this scenario, both the dog trainer and the father-in-law may benefit from discussing their views openly to find common ground, promoting a healthier family dynamic.

This seems like sexism.

Reddit

He's being difficult and acting as if he's in charge of training the dogs.

Reddit

OP should let him know he is not welcome until he can respect her and her methods.

Reddit

To address these conflicts, the couple might consider mediating a discussion between the dog trainer and the father-in-law. This approach allows both parties to express their perspectives and work towards a compromise that respects their differing training philosophies.

Encouraging open dialogue can lead to better understanding and collaboration in training methods, ultimately benefiting the dog and the family.

He's underestimating his dogs.

Reddit

OP needs to tell him to stop mansplaining and respect her expertise in dog training.

Reddit

When someone comes to her house, she should make it clear that it's her house and her rules, especially regarding her dog.

Reddit

The Role of Communication in Conflict Resolution

Effective communication is essential in resolving conflicts, particularly within family settings. Research indicates that families who engage in open discussions about disagreements tend to experience less tension and more resolution.

In this case, the couple should facilitate a conversation that allows both the dog trainer and the father-in-law to voice their concerns and preferences, leading to a more cohesive training strategy.

OP is a professional dog trainer; she knows how to train her German Shepherd for protection. This situation feels unfair because her father-in-law doesn't understand her expertise. He's not respecting her skills, and it's frustrating.

She should let him know that he can't interfere with her dog's training unless he respects her and her methods. She needs to stand up for herself and her knowledge in dog training, just as anyone should stand up for their expertise.

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the importance of aligning training methods within family dynamics. Open communication between family members can lead to a better understanding of differing perspectives and foster collaboration.

Ultimately, this approach can enhance the relationship between family members and their pets.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Understanding the dynamics of training and family relationships is crucial for fostering harmony in a household. Research supports the idea that open communication and collaboration can significantly improve relationships among family members who share responsibilities for pets.

By addressing underlying conflicts and aligning training strategies, families can create a more supportive environment for both pets and people.