Should I Force My Daughter To Go On A Family Vacation

Are you wondering if you would be the jerk in a situation where you're contemplating making your daughter come on a vacation? Here's the scoop: a family with two daughters aged 13 and 16, along with a 12-year-old son, is planning a 7-day Disney cruise this December.

It's a special trip they take every 5 years. When the older daughter learned about the vacation and the cost—$910 per person for the cruise—she expressed concerns about the price, unlike her younger siblings, who were excited.

She even suggested excluding herself from the trip to save money, feeling guilty about the expense. The mother found her daughter's reaction surprising, as the cost wasn't supposed to be her worry.

The daughter's reluctance prompted a heated discussion where the mother insisted she join for family bonding, while the husband suggested leaving her behind if she didn't want to go. Reddit users weighed in, with some expressing concern about the daughter's money worries, hinting at potential underlying issues, while others debated whether forcing her to go on the trip despite her reservations would be fair.

The thread is filled with diverse perspectives and advice, urging thoughtful consideration and open communication to navigate the situation effectively.

Original Post

WIBTA if I made my daughter come on a vacation? We have two daughters, 13F and 16F, and one son, 12M.

We decided to go on a 7-day Disney cruise for vacation this December. We usually take one big vacation every 5 years, and this is one of them.

My youngest two were very happy when they found out we were going on a Disney cruise and started jumping for joy. When I told my older daughter, she was happy immediately but then quickly asked me how much the trip cost.

She has always been someone who cares about how much things cost and would refuse to buy items if she felt they were too expensive. I never knew where she got this trait from, considering we aren't poor by any means.

I showed her the ticket we planned to buy, and she was a bit mortified. The ticket would cost her and her siblings $910 each, while it would cost us slightly more.

She became a bit terrified and asked, "This whole thing seems way too expensive; isn't there anything cheaper?" Her reaction shocked me; I didn't expect her to think about the price. I told her it wasn't her problem and that she didn't need to worry.

Then a day later, she told me to just exclude her and take her other two siblings to save money. She said she didn't feel right spending so much on something she wasn't sure she'd even enjoy.

She said, "I'll feel too guilty; I already spend a lot of your money, and we'll spend even more for snacks and activities, so just leave me." I was not understanding why she cared this much about money and kept asking her.

She said it was just too expensive for her and that five people might require two rooms, which would be even more expensive, while four people would be fine with one. I told her that I wasn't letting her miss an important family trip just because she thinks it "costs too much."

I think it'll be a good chance for her to bond with her siblings; I also don't think the money is her problem. She got upset and said that I should just enjoy the trip without her.

My husband is saying it's better if we leave her and that she might not have fun anyway. WIBTA?

The Psychological Impact of Family Expectations

Family vacations often come with a set of expectations that can create significant pressure on family members. Research suggests that unmet expectations can lead to disappointment and frustration, adversely affecting family dynamics. A study published in the Journal of Family Psychology found that open communication regarding expectations can enhance family satisfaction during shared experiences.

Understanding the psychological implications of these expectations can help family members navigate their feelings more effectively, fostering a more enjoyable environment.

Comment from u/Turbulent_Ebb5669

Comment from u/Nervous-Tea-7074

Furthermore, the pressure to conform to family traditions can sometimes overshadow individual needs and preferences. Research in family systems theory emphasizes the importance of balancing individual autonomy with family cohesion. This balance is crucial for maintaining emotional well-being within family dynamics.

Encouraging family members to express their feelings about traditions can promote a more inclusive atmosphere where everyone's voice is heard.

Comment from u/LimeInternational856

Comment from u/CatJarmansPants

Navigating Conflicting Desires in Family Settings

When family members have differing opinions about vacations, it can create tension and frustration. Psychologists note that such conflicts often arise from a lack of understanding of each other's perspectives. Engaging in active listening and empathy can help families navigate these differences more effectively.

Research suggests that families who practice empathy and open communication tend to have stronger bonds and more satisfying relationships.

Comment from u/Lazy-General332

Comment from u/hidethesunscreen

Additionally, utilizing conflict resolution strategies can be instrumental in addressing disagreements about family vacations. Techniques such as compromise and collaborative planning can help reconcile differing desires, leading to a more cohesive family experience.

Research indicates that involving all family members in the decision-making process can enhance satisfaction and foster a sense of shared ownership over family experiences.

Comment from u/Traveling-Techie

Comment from u/Inahayes1

Practical Steps for Achieving Consensus

To achieve consensus about family vacations, it may be helpful to hold family meetings where everyone can express their preferences and desires. Creating a collaborative planning environment can facilitate open communication and reduce tension.

Additionally, establishing a family decision-making process that incorporates everyone's input can foster a sense of unity and cooperation, ensuring that all voices are valued.

Comment from u/ParkingIce6514

Comment from u/Duckie1986

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

Comment from u/Zorbie

Comment from u/Designer_Voice99

Comment from u/h0t_c0c0_316

Comment from u/Careless_Welder_4048

Comment from u/Fit_General7058

Comment from u/MsPooka

Comment from u/Maximum-Ear1745

Comment from u/hashtagidontknow

Comment from u/Possible-Courage3771

Comment from u/montauk6

Psychological Analysis

This situation illustrates the complexities of family dynamics, particularly when it comes to shared experiences like vacations. The interplay of differing expectations can create significant tension, highlighting the need for open communication and empathy.

Encouraging family members to express their feelings and preferences can foster understanding and lead to a more harmonious decision-making process.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, navigating family dynamics during vacation planning requires empathy, open communication, and a willingness to compromise. Research indicates that families who engage in collaborative planning and conflict resolution strategies tend to experience higher levels of satisfaction and connection.

By prioritizing each family member's needs and fostering a supportive environment, families can create enjoyable and memorable experiences together.