New Menendez Show Brings Popularity Back To Milli Vanilli
The Menendez Netflix show has gained significant popularity, which has extended to a well-known singing duo as well.
It turns out you can “cancel” a pop duo, and the internet still finds a way to bring them roaring back. After the Menendez Brothers Netflix series hit, a younger crowd started streaming Milli Vanilli like they had just discovered a brand-new band, not a pair of singers trapped in one of the most infamous music scams ever.
The complicated part is that this resurgence is tied to the show’s most emotional moments, not just random nostalgia. “Blame It On The Rain” spikes fast, and it is not even subtle where it lands, because Lyle and Erik are literally singing along after they buy their shotguns. Then “Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” gets its own spotlight, showing up at Jose and Kitty’s memorial and again during the final episode after their second trial.
So yeah, the music is back, but it’s back inside a story that makes every note feel loaded.
A younger generation has been rediscovering the talent of Milli Vanilli following the Menendez Brothers Netflix show.
There has been a considerable spike in listeners of their music after the show debuted. According to Billboard, “Blame It On The Rain” actually saw a 68% increase in the number of streams within just four days after the release of the Netflix show.
This is an incredible figure, considering the duo was originally canceled and many people didn’t listen to them or show their support after their “scam” was revealed. This song was the title of one of the episodes, and it was the song that Lyle and Erik sang along to after buying their shotguns.

After the television show’s debut, there was also an increase in streams of other songs
“Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” experienced a 258% increase in streams between September 20 and September 23, according to Billboard as well. The song is about heartbreak and is arguably a breakout hit from the series, featured in two of the most important scenes.
First, it’s used at a memorial service for Jose and Kitty, where Lyle plays the song to conclude his speech about Kitty. It’s also played in the final episode when the boys receive their life sentences upon their second trial.
One of the singers, Rob, isn’t alive to see their work gain more traction in this new series, but Fab, however, has been able to witness it, and he seems quite proud of it on his social media.
Billboard says “Blame It On The Rain” jumped 68% in streams within four days, and that’s the moment the whole Milli Vanilli comeback stopped being a vibe and started being data.
And just when you think it’s only about one song, “Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” rockets up 258% between September 20 and September 23, because the series keeps using it for the biggest punches.
There is a lot that emerged from this Menendez brothers series on Netflix, and many people seemed to enjoy the television show. Despite the controversy surrounding Milli Vanilli, they remain an iconic duo, and there’s a reason that the directors and producers chose their songs for these specific scenes in the show.
They definitely added to the drama and increased the popularity of the singing duo.
This kind of comeback energy feels like celebrities who went from broke to famous.
The scenes matter, too, since Lyle plays “Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” to close his speech at Kitty’s memorial, then it shows up again when Erik and Lyle get life sentences on their second trial.
Cultural Resurgence and Nostalgia
The recent popularity of the Menendez brothers' story has sparked renewed interest in associated cultural artifacts, including music from the '80s and '90s.
This approach fosters a more discerning audience that can navigate complex stories with a critical lens, thus promoting healthier media consumption habits.
Ultimately, learning to analyze media critically can help prevent the glorification of negative behaviors in popular culture.
Even Rob not being here to see it land harder is part of the emotional weight, while Fab posts about the renewed attention like he cannot believe it’s happening again.
The Menendez Netflix show effectively highlights how true crime narratives intertwined with nostalgia can stir significant emotional reactions, prompting audiences to revisit iconic moments in cultural history. As viewers delve into the complex saga of the Menendez brothers, they are reminded of the societal fascination with crime and its repercussions on family dynamics.
This series encourages a critical examination of media portrayals, inviting viewers to reflect not only on the horrifying events but also on their own emotional investments. Engaging with such narratives mindfully allows audiences to reconnect with past cultural artifacts while cultivating a more nuanced understanding of sensationalized stories.
The Menendez show didn’t just revive Milli Vanilli, it weaponized their songs for the most brutal scenes imaginable.
And if you love stories hidden in plain sight, check out movies where every dish becomes the real plot twist.