Should I Give Dating Advice to a Friend Who Has Feelings for Me?
AITA for refusing to give dating advice to a close friend with a crush on me? Emotions are tangled as I prioritize my relationship while respecting her feelings.
A 29-year-old woman refused to turn her best friendship into a dating plan, and it blew up in her face. Sarah, 28, has been in her life since college, the kind of friend you tell everything to, the kind you assume will always be safe.
Then Sarah confessed she’s got feelings, and the timing could not be worse. OP is dating Alex, 30, for a year and things are going great, so when Sarah asked for help figuring out how to confess or pursue her, OP tried to be gentle. But Sarah heard “no” as “you led me on,” got distant, and now the friendship is strained.
Here’s the full story of who is actually being selfish, and who just wants their life to stay peaceful.
Original Post
So I'm (29F), and I've been friends with 'Sarah' (28F) since college. We've always had a close friendship, sharing everything with each other.
Recently, Sarah confessed that she has developed feelings for me beyond friendship. The catch is, I've never seen her in a romantic light.
For background, I've been dating 'Alex' (30M) for the past year, and things are going great between us. Sarah found out about my relationship with Alex, and that's when she admitted her feelings for me.
She asked for advice on how to handle her emotions and whether she should confess to me. I care about Sarah a lot, but I just don't see a romantic relationship with her.
I want to support her, but giving her advice on how to pursue me feels wrong, especially when I'm happily committed to Alex. I tried to gently tell her that I value our friendship but can't provide guidance on romantic feelings towards me.
Sarah got upset, saying I was being selfish for not helping her navigate her emotions. She accused me of leading her on by being such a close friend without reciprocating her feelings.
Now, she's distant and our friendship is strained. As much as I want to be there for Sarah, I also have to prioritize my own relationship and feelings.
So AITA?
The Complexity of Friendship and Love
This situation highlights the intricate dance between friendship and romantic feelings. The OP’s dilemma with Sarah isn’t just about refusing to offer dating advice; it’s about navigating the emotional fallout of unreciprocated feelings within a close relationship. Sarah's confession puts the OP in a tough spot where she must balance her loyalty to her friend with her commitment to her boyfriend, Alex, creating a conflict that many can relate to.
This scenario resonates with readers because it taps into that universal fear of losing a friend over romantic complications. It raises the question of whether the OP should prioritize Sarah's feelings over her own relationship, challenging the conventional wisdom about supporting friends at all costs.
Comment from u/mystic_unicorn99
Comment from u/coffee_addict87
Comment from u/ocean_breeze23
That college-best-friend closeness is what makes Sarah’s confession hit so hard, because it doesn’t come out of nowhere, it comes out of years of “everything.”
Once Alex is brought into the picture, the whole thing turns into a mess of loyalty, because OP can’t exactly coach Sarah toward her own boyfriend situation.
Similar to the AITA poster who kept her crush secret after a best-friends breakup, despite hidden feelings for her ex.
Similar to the AITA poster who hid her crush after her best friend’s breakup, for her ex.
Why This Request Crossed a Line
The request for dating advice from Sarah is particularly problematic because it places the OP in a position where she must potentially validate feelings that she doesn’t reciprocate. By seeking guidance, Sarah is not only expressing her feelings but also implicitly asking the OP to engage with those emotions, which could complicate their friendship further. It’s a grey area that many can find themselves in, where one person’s vulnerability can become another’s burden.
The community reaction reflects this discomfort, with some feeling that Sarah’s request is selfish, while others sympathize with her emotional turmoil. This divide shows just how nuanced these relationships can be, as each person weighs the importance of friendship against the risk of emotional fallout.
Comment from u/sky_watcher17
Comment from u/songbird_melody
The moment OP tells Sarah she can’t provide romantic guidance, Sarah flips it into an accusation, claiming she was led on by the very friendship she relied on.
Now that Sarah is distant after the “selfish” fight, OP is stuck wondering if keeping the friendship intact is even possible anymore.
We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.
Why This Story Matters
This story serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between friendship and romantic feelings.
The Bigger Picture
This situation really underscores the tricky dynamics of friendship when romantic feelings come into play.
OP might not be the villain, but the friendship is definitely paying the price.
Wait until you see why this best friend still gave dating advice, despite knowing strong feelings.
Thought that was wild? Check out what this AITA poster did when her best friend confessed feelings.
