Should I Introduce My Best Friend to My Crush Despite My Secret Feelings?

A 27-year-old woman tried to be “selfless” by setting up her best friend with the person she can’t stop thinking about, and it gets messy fast. Not because her crush is some random stranger, but because the crush is also the exact person her best friend just confessed they’re into.

Here’s the setup: OP (27F) and her best friend (26F) have been close for years, the kind of friendship where secrets are basically currency. Then OP’s crush, a 28NB person, shows up in both of their love lives at the same time. Her best friend is outgoing and vocal, while OP is reserved and shy, and now OP is sitting on feelings she hasn’t admitted out loud.

And the worst part, she hasn’t told her best friend about the plan yet, which means one “perfect match” could blow up everything they’ve built.

Original Post

So I'm (27F) and I've been friends with my best friend (26F) for years. We share everything - our secrets, our dreams, and unfortunately, a crush.

Here's the deal: I've had a massive crush on this incredible person (28NB) for months now, but I've never had the courage to make a move. Recently, my best friend confessed to me that they're also developing feelings for this same person.

We were shocked to realize we're crushing on the same individual. The twist?

My best friend is more vocal and outgoing, while I'm more reserved and shy. They told me how much they like this person and how they wish they could go on a date with them.

After some thought, I had a wild idea. What if I set them up with my crush?

It sounds crazy, I know. But in my mind, if my crush ends up dating my best friend and they're happy together, at least I played a part in making that happen.

It would hurt to see them together, but I also want the best for both of them. I haven't told my best friend about this plan yet, and I can't shake the feeling that it might backfire.

But at the same time, I feel like it could be the ultimate selfless act. So, would I be the a*****e for setting up my best friend with the person I secretly like, even if it means sacrificing my own feelings?

This Redditor's predicament encapsulates a common yet thorny issue: how do you balance friendship with unrequited love? By considering setting up her best friend with her crush, she's risking not just her feelings but the dynamic of their entire friendship. The fact that they both have feelings for the same person creates a palpable tension that could lead to jealousy or resentment on either side.

Moreover, this situation highlights the often unspoken rules of romantic interest among friends. When the stakes are high, as they are here, loyalty can become a double-edged sword, leaving everyone involved feeling vulnerable. It's no wonder this story resonates; many can relate to the fear of losing both a crush and a close friend in one fell swoop.

Comment from u/pizza_lover86

Comment from u/coffeebean_123

Comment from u/beachbum77

OP’s whole idea starts the moment her best friend tells her they also like the 28NB person, right after OP admits she’s been crushing for months.

The tension really kicks in because OP wants to play matchmaker, even though it means her best friend could walk into the same arms she’s been quietly hoping for.

This also echoes the question of whether you’re a villain or hero when you set up your friend and crush, even while secretly feeling for one of them, in Should I Play Cupid for My Friend and Crush?.

The Community's Divided Opinions

The Reddit community's varied responses to this dilemma showcase the complexity of human emotions and relationships. Some users might champion the idea of transparency, urging the OP to be upfront with her feelings before playing matchmaker. Others may argue that pursuing her crush is selfish and could jeopardize a long-standing friendship.

What’s particularly intriguing is how this situation plays out against societal norms that often pit friendship and romantic interests against each other. Many commenters likely saw their own experiences reflected in this OP's struggle, leading to passionate debates about loyalty, honesty, and the ethics of dating within friend circles. In the end, the OP isn't just seeking advice; she’s inviting a conversation about the messy intersections of love and friendship.

Comment from u/sunset_dreamer

Comment from u/gamer_galaxy

When OP pictures her crush dating her best friend and “being happy,” the friendship math starts to feel like a trade she might regret.

Now OP has to decide whether keeping the setup a secret protects the friendship, or guarantees the backfire when feelings collide for both 26F and 27F.

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

This situation raises critical questions about the nature of friendship and the boundaries we set when romance gets involved. Can you truly put a friend’s happiness above your own feelings? How would you handle a similar situation? Would you act on your feelings, or prioritize your friend's happiness?

The Bigger Picture

The Redditor in this love triangle finds herself grappling with a tough choice between her feelings and her friendship. Her idea to set up her best friend with her crush reveals a desire to prioritize her friend's happiness, even if it means suppressing her own emotions. This selfless act, however, could backfire, creating tension and potential resentment. It's a classic case of loyalty versus desire, and the stakes couldn't be higher for both women as they navigate these complex feelings.

If OP “sets them up,” she might just end up losing the crush and the best friend in one move.

Before you introduce your best friend to your crush, read about helping her date him.