Should I Let My Brother Bring His Dog Over? AITA for Setting Boundaries?

AITA for not allowing my brother to bring his dog over anymore after it damaged my furniture, leading to tension between us?

Damjan

Published in Interesting
26 Dec 2025

Should I Let My Brother Bring His Dog Over? AITA for Setting Boundaries?

In a world where pets are often regarded as family members, navigating the complexities of relationships can become particularly challenging when boundaries are crossed. One Reddit user found themselves in a challenging situation after their brother frequently brought his dog over, leading to a series of unfortunate events that left their furniture damaged and their living space in disarray.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

What started as a casual arrangement quickly spiraled into a dispute over responsibility and respect for personal property. The original poster, feeling overwhelmed by the chaos, decided to put their foot down and told their brother that his dog was no longer welcome in their home.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

This decision has since strained their relationship, leaving them wondering if they were in the wrong for prioritizing their space over family ties. As the discussion unfolds, commenters weigh in on the nuances of pet ownership and the responsibilities that come with it.

From training advice to financial accountability, the thread highlights the differing opinions on how to handle such a delicate situation. As you dive into the comments, consider the variety of perspectives on pet etiquette and family dynamics.

What are your thoughts on setting boundaries when it comes to visiting pets? How do you balance your love for animals with the need to protect your personal space?

Join the conversation and share your insights!

Original Post

My brother loves his dog and brings him everywhere, including my apartment. At first, I didn’t mind, but the last few visits have been a nightmare.

His dog chewed up the corner of my couch, scratched my coffee table, and even left a mess on my rug. I paid a lot for my furniture, and it’s sad to watch it get ruined.

When I told my brother I don’t want the dog in my place anymore, my brother doesn't seem fine with it, and told me that dog does that every time. After all this happened my brother and i didn't talked that much and never visits me again.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

AITA for saying my brother can't bring his dog to my house anymore?