Should I Set Up My Crush with My Best Friends Sibling? AITA?

A 28-year-old man refused to set up his best friend’s sibling with his own complicated crush, and now he’s stuck asking if that makes him the asshole. The whole thing sounds simple on paper: friend wants matchmaking, friend says no, end of story. Except it’s not.

Sarah and the OP have been close for years, so when Sarah’s sibling Alex (27NB) says they’re interested in dating Jess (25F), Sarah naturally looks to the OP. But Jess and the OP have history, and both of them agreed to keep things platonic. The OP worries that bringing Jess into a new dating situation could stir up drama and wreck not just the crush arrangement, but the friendship itself.

Now he has to live with Sarah’s disappointment and wonder if he protected himself or blew up a chance for everyone to be happy.

Original Post

I (28M) have been friends with Sarah (26F) for years, and we've always been close. Recently, her sibling Alex (27NB) expressed interest in dating my crush, Jess (25F).

Now, here's the twist - Jess and I have had a complicated dating history, and we've both agreed to keep things platonic. When Sarah asked me to set up Alex and Jess, I felt conflicted.

On one hand, I want Sarah's sibling to be happy, but on the other, involving Jess could lead to unnecessary drama and jeopardize our friendship. I decided to be honest with Sarah and told her I couldn't help set up Alex with Jess due to our past.

She seemed understanding but disappointed. Now, I'm left wondering if I made the right choice.

So, AITA?

This story dives into the murky waters of friendship and dating history, which can be a minefield. The OP has a romantic past with Jess, and that complicates Sarah's request to set them up with Alex. It’s a classic case of loyalty versus personal feelings, and anyone who's been in a similar situation knows how intense that conflict can feel.

By refusing to set up Alex with Jess, the OP is protecting their own emotional space, but it also risks damaging their friendship with Sarah. The tension here is palpable; it’s not just about matchmaking but about navigating past relationships and the loyalty that friendships demand.

Comment from u/pizzalover_99

Comment from u/unicorn_rider42

Comment from u/gamer_girl79

Sarah and the OP’s “we’ve always been close” vibe is exactly why her request to set up Alex and Jess hits so hard.

The Friend vs. Sibling Dilemma

A key point in this discussion is the sibling dynamic.

Comment from u/coffee_addict23

Comment from u/sunset_watcher

Comment from u/moonlight_dancer

The moment the OP remembers that Jess and he already tried to keep things platonic, the matchmaking request turns into a potential disaster.

Like the OP torn between dating their friend’s crush, when loyalty to Sarah’s circle got complicated.

Community Reactions: A Divided Opinion

The Reddit community's reactions to this post show just how divided people can be on matters of love and loyalty. Some commenters support the OP's decision to set boundaries, suggesting that it's crucial to protect one’s emotional well-being, especially when past feelings are involved.

Others argue that the OP should set aside personal history for the sake of friendship, which reflects a common belief that loyalty should triumph over individual feelings. This split highlights how subjective relationship dynamics can be, as everyone brings their own experiences and perspectives to the table.

Comment from u/musiclover_17

Comment from u/bookworm_88

Comment from u/star_gazer101

Sarah seemed to understand when he said no, but her disappointment suggests this wasn’t just a casual “maybe later” conversation.

Why Setting Up Friends is Risky Business

This whole scenario serves as a reminder of how risky matchmaking can be. Even when intentions are good, like Sarah's desire to help her brother, the emotional stakes can get high. The OP's refusal isn't just about saying no; it’s about recognizing that some romantic connections are too complicated to mix with friendship.

Comment from u/thriving_artist

With Alex interested in Jess and the OP stuck between loyalty and old feelings, the Reddit comments are basically split down the middle.

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Why This Story Matters

This situation really highlights the emotional complexities that arise when friendships and romantic interests overlap. The OP's struggle shows how challenging it can be to balance loyalty to friends with personal feelings and past experiences. As readers, we can all relate to these kinds of dilemmas in our own lives. So, what would you do in this scenario? Would you prioritize your friendship or your feelings?

In this scenario, the user finds himself caught between competing loyalties to his best friend Sarah and his own emotional history with Jess. His refusal to set up Alex with Jess reflects a desire to protect his own boundaries and avoid reopening old wounds, which is a rational choice given their complicated past. Sarah's disappointment shows that while she wants to prioritize her brother's happiness, she may not fully grasp the emotional intricacies involved, highlighting the delicate balance between friendship and romantic entanglements. This situation underscores how easily matchmaking can complicate existing relationships, often leading to unintended consequences.

He might have saved his friendship from drama, or he might have cost Sarah and Alex a real shot at happiness.

Before you pick sides, read what happened when OP refused to set up their friend with their crush.