Should I Stop My Best Friend from Dating Our Mutual Crush? | Relationship Advice Dilemma

A 28-year-old woman is stuck in the worst kind of love triangle, the one where nobody is technically doing anything wrong, but everyone is asking her for an opinion anyway. Her best friend and a mutual guy both confessed feelings, and now the friend group has turned into a live-action group chat she cannot mute.

Here’s the mess: her best friend, 27, is unsure they match long-term, but she trusts OP’s judgment like it’s law. Meanwhile, the mutual friend, 29, is all-in and wants to take things to the next level, and he also leans on OP for relationship guidance. So OP can either steer her best friend away to prevent a potential heartbreak, or stay out and risk being seen as the person who killed a real chance at happiness.

And the scariest part is that both sides sound believable, which is exactly why OP is asking Reddit if she would be the asshole for trying to stop it.

Original Post

So I'm (28F), and recently my best friend (27F) and a mutual friend (29M) both separately confided in me about having feelings for each other. They had gone on a few dates and things seemed to be going well.

However, my best friend opened up to me about her doubts regarding their compatibility due to differing long-term goals. On the other hand, our mutual friend shared how much he liked her and wanted to take the relationship to the next level.

For background, my best friend trusts my judgment a lot, and she often seeks advice from me on various matters. She values my opinions and insights and relies on me to provide unbiased perspectives.

Similarly, our mutual friend respects my views and often turns to me for relationship advice. The dilemma arises because I can see both sides of the situation.

On one hand, my best friend is unsure about the relationship's sustainability, and I don't want her to commit to something that might not work out in the long run. On the other hand, our mutual friend is genuinely interested in her and sees a potential future together.

I feel torn between loyalty to my best friend and wanting to support our mutual friend's chance at happiness. If I were to intervene and advise my best friend against pursuing the relationship further, it might prevent a potential heartbreak down the line.

However, it could also be seen as meddling in their personal lives and denying them the opportunity to explore their connection. So, Reddit, WIBTA if I took a stand and tried to stop my best friend from dating our mutual crush after they sought my advice?

I honestly don't know if I'm wrong here and really need outside perspective.

The Complicated Nature of Crushes

This situation dives deep into the murky waters of unspoken feelings and friendships. The Reddit user is faced with a dilemma that many can relate to: how do you prioritize a close friendship while also grappling with your own emotions? The fact that both her best friend and the mutual crush have confided in her complicates matters even further. It’s not just a matter of preference; it’s a conflict of loyalty and self-interest.

The tension arises from wanting to protect the friendship while also fearing that intervening could lead to hurt feelings. In a world where romantic interests often collide with friendships, this nuanced scenario strikes a chord with many readers who have faced similar crossroads.

Comment from u/reddituser987654

Comment from u/throwawayuser_24601

Comment from u/coffee_addict_88

That’s when OP realizes her best friend’s doubts and the mutual friend’s excitement are both landing on her doorstep at the same time.</p>

Why This Request Crossed a Line

The Reddit user’s request for advice raises eyebrows because it suggests a desire to control the narrative of their friends’ relationship. When it comes to matters of the heart, it’s a slippery slope to think you can dictate who should date whom. The mutual crush, too, seems to be caught in this web of uncertainty, making it harder to discern whether his feelings are genuine or merely a reflection of the friend group dynamics.

By considering intervening, the user risks damaging both her friendship and any potential romance. This highlights a common tension in friendships: the need to assert one’s feelings without overstepping boundaries. Who ultimately has the right to decide who dates whom in this tangled triangle?

Comment from u/books_and_coffee

Comment from u/musiclover22

Comment from u/curious_cat_7890

If OP pushes back after being the “unbiased” one, it could turn her into the villain in her best friend’s story.</p>

It’s a close match to the WIBTA post where OP tried to talk her best friend out of dating her ex-boyfriend.

Community Reactions Reveal Deeper Issues

The Reddit community's reactions to this dilemma showcase a spectrum of perspectives. Some users argue that the best friend shouldn’t pursue the crush if there's a chance it could hurt their friendship, while others contend that feelings can't be controlled and intervening could backfire. The very act of seeking external advice reveals a level of insecurity about her own feelings and the strength of her friendship.

This debate emphasizes how personal conflicts often reflect broader societal expectations about loyalty and romance. It's fascinating to see how the community wrestles with these concepts, illustrating that while love can be a beautiful thing, it often comes wrapped in complicated layers of friendship and obligation.

Comment from u/the_cookie_monster

Comment from u/dog_person_55

Comment from u/beachlover_333

But if she stays quiet while they keep dating, she’s basically watching for the heartbreak she already suspects might be coming.</p>

This story encapsulates the uncertainty that often plagues young adult relationships. The friend’s hesitance about the long-term potential with the mutual crush adds another layer to this already complicated scenario. Not only is the user worried about her friendship, but she’s also grappling with the potential fallout of a romantic relationship that may not even last.

Such dilemmas are common in the dating landscape, where feelings can shift rapidly. The uncertainty of the best friend’s feelings for the mutual crush highlights the fragility of romantic interests, especially when they intersect with established friendships. It serves as a reminder that in love and friendship, nothing is ever straightforward.

Comment from u/pizza_is_life_99

Now OP has to decide whether loyalty means protecting her best friend from a mismatch, or letting the mutual crush try anyway.</p>

What's your opinion on this situation? Join the conversation!.

Where Things Stand

This story raises important questions about loyalty, love, and the difficult choices we face when emotions are involved. It challenges us to think about where our priorities lie and how we navigate the complex web of friendships and romantic interests. Have you ever found yourself in a similar situation? How did you handle it, and what would you advise the Reddit user to do?

What It Comes Down To

The Reddit user's dilemma highlights the often murky waters of friendship and romantic interest.

Either way, OP might lose the friendship she’s trying to save.

Still stuck between “my feelings” and “my friend,” read how one Redditor handled dating their ex. Would you stop your friend from dating your ex?