I Slept With My Girlfriend's Mom - A Secret That Threatens To Unravel Everything

Some secrets do not stay buried, they crawl into your calendar and show up at Thanksgiving. That is exactly what happened to OP, after a “no big deal” hookup turned into a full-blown family nightmare.

Two years ago, when he was 19, he started seeing a woman in her 40s, who looked way younger and invited him out repeatedly. Then he met his current girlfriend’s family, and the punchline hit him in the face, her mom was the woman from his past, and her parents are still married after 20 years.

Now he is stuck pretending everything is fine, because her mom told him to keep quiet, and Thanksgiving dinner is on the table with the people he already ruined.

Original Post

So let me first just say, I’m not the one in the wrong for this, but I have to say it somewhere. It’s eating me alive.

Two years ago, when I was 19, I met this woman while I was working as a personal trainer. She was in her 40s and looked like a 25-year-old.

She took an interest in me and invited me out a number of times, and we had sex a few times. After one of our meet-ups, she said it was wrong for someone of her age to be with me because I was too young and changed gyms.

My girlfriend and I have been together for just under a year. She’s amazing, and I love her so much.

Two months ago, I met her family for the first time, and it was a shock. She took me to the house where I had hooked up with a woman, and I felt like I was being pranked.

Before I saw her mom, it hit me. I have a type, and they both fit that type, so it makes sense. I’ve been hooking up with a single mom, and I’m now with her daughter.

Then her mom and dad popped out, and we both almost sh*t ourselves. I met her parents; they’ve been married for 20 years. I realized I had been a married woman’s boy toy, and I feel incredibly ashamed.

Later that week, her mom found my number and told me that I can never speak of what happened. She said that my girlfriend will hate me forever because I’ll be the one who broke up her parents.

So now I’m stuck keeping this secret. She invited me to spend Thanksgiving with her family, and since my family is 1,000 miles away and I already told her I don’t plan on going home, I don’t really have an excuse to not go.

So now I’m going to have to sit there at a table and enjoy Thanksgiving dinner with the woman I had an affair with, her husband, and her daughter, whom I am now in love with. I’m f*cked.

The Emotional Consequences of Secrets

Keeping secrets can have profound emotional consequences, often leading to feelings of guilt and anxiety.

Comment from u/Massive_Safe_3220

Comment from u/Dee_2592

That first “prank” feeling vanished fast when OP realized the woman he slept with was literally his girlfriend’s mom, same house, same story.

When secrets are revealed, the impact can be devastating. Studies published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships show that disclosure can lead to feelings of betrayal among those affected, altering the nature of existing relationships.

Understanding the potential fallout from secrets can provide insight into the emotional turmoil experienced by individuals in these situations.

Comment from u/Dogmeattt666

Comment from u/[deleted]

Revelations can create significant shifts in relationship dynamics, often leading to feelings of mistrust and confusion. rebuilding trust requires consistent effort and open communication.

Engaging in honest discussions about feelings and motivations is essential for healing and moving forward.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/mikuzgrl

Then the parents walked in, and OP went from shocked to ashamed, because he wasn’t just dating a single mom, he was a married woman’s boy toy.

This also hits a similar nerve to the WIBTA case where someone paid rent late, stressing a landlord’s mortgage.

In the aftermath of a revelation, seeking support from trusted friends or therapists can be beneficial.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/ShepardessofTears

Her mom tracked him down and basically issued a threat with a smile, don’t tell anyone, or OP becomes the reason the parents “break up.”

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

Comment from u/CadenceQuandry

Comment from u/I_wood_rather_be

Comment from u/Jakes1967

Comment from u/bluemoonicecream22

Comment from u/ThatKidTaylor

Comment from u/joloks

Comment from u/DeanoBambino90

And now OP is facing the worst kind of awkward, sitting at the Thanksgiving table with her mom, her husband, and the daughter he actually loves.

The fallout from this secret relationship is likely to be profound, extending beyond mere embarrassment to deeply affect the mental health of all involved. The age difference and the betrayal of trust introduce layers of complexity that could strain not only the romantic relationship but also familial bonds. The importance of open communication cannot be overstated in such a scenario, as it is essential for rebuilding trust after such a revelation.

Moreover, nurturing supportive connections among friends and family will be vital for emotional recovery. This situation serves as a poignant reminder of how secrets can disrupt lives and the necessity of transparency in personal relationships.

The only thing worse than keeping the secret is smiling through it while her family asks how OP’s doing.

Want another brutal “family first” blowup? Read why one person refused to sell an inherited home after parents threatened to cut support: AITA for keeping inherited home against parents’ wishes.