AITA For Asking My Partner To Rehome His New Puppy

Are you the one who's in the wrong for asking your partner to rehome the new puppy? The story unfolds with a 26-year-old female who recently purchased her first home.

Her partner of three years moved in with her, and she already has a Pomeranian Chihuahua that she's had for five years. With a long commute to work and her partner seeking full-time employment, she suggested getting a new pet to keep her dog company.

Her partner agreed, but under the condition that he could choose and raise the new dog to form a close bond like she has with her dog. They ended up adopting a beagle puppy from a shelter.

However, things took a turn when the partner sent the puppy to a "doggy boot camp" for training, where they recommended using a shock collar. The puppy returned untrained, and the partner didn't invest time in properly caring for her.

The original poster struggled to bond with the high-energy puppy and confronted her partner about rehoming her to a retired couple who had experience with beagles. The thread delves into whether the original poster is at fault for wanting to rehome the puppy and highlights the partner's lack of responsibility and commitment to training and caring for the dog.

Opinions vary, with some emphasizing the importance of responsible pet ownership and considering the well-being of the animal above all else. The discussion raises questions about compatibility, communication, and accountability in relationships, especially when it comes to shared responsibilities like pet care.

Original Post

I, 26(f), recently bought my first home. My partner of three years lives with me.

I’ve had my dog for five years, since she was a puppy, and I’ve trained her. She’s a Pomeranian Chihuahua.

Since I have an hour commute to work and my partner has been looking for a full-time job (he’s currently part-time), I asked him if we could get a new pet to keep Boo (my dog) from being lonely. He only agreed IF he got to choose and raise the new dog as his own, as he wanted a close bond like the one I have with my dog.

I agreed! I hoped everyone could have a close companion, and since he never grew up with a close pet, I thought this would be his chance.

The puppy was cute, and we got her at a shelter since he just fell in love with her picture. She is maybe a five-month-old beagle.

His passion and excitement made me hopeful. We adopted her, and I warned him that the first few weeks would be rough due to potty training.

She’s a puppy, though, so he should expect accidents. Two days later, I come home, and she’s gone.

He took her to a “doggy boot camp” to be trained by a professional. He reassured me it was his dog, his decision, and his money.

When she returned, she was not potty trained and could barely contain her excitement on walks. They only taught her not to bark… then recommended a shock collar that they used in their facility.

Okay, here’s where I might be the a*****e. I never really bonded with her.

Her energy and excitement were too much for me. I knew she was a puppy, so I thought I’d try to train her, but I couldn’t help but resent my partner for not taking the time to train her himself.

He wouldn’t take her on walks. When she pooped (and I’m talking about completely destroying her kennel despite constant outside time), it added to my stress and resentment.

When he would just leave her outside for hours, I couldn’t help but feel more resentment! She was either trapped in a kennel, outside in the yard, or in my house with me by myself trying to train her and cleaning up her accidents.

I didn’t sign up for a puppy, nor did I imagine getting a bigger dog. I brought it up to a coworker, and she had retired parents who previously had a beagle that they loved and cared for until old age, who’d also love a puppy. I thought it was fate.

I brought it up to him and asked him to think about what’s best for the dog. And if he truly wanted to care for her, then great!

We wouldn’t have to rehome her. He took some time to think, then said to rehome her, but I need to know that he’s only saying yes because he knows I just want to get rid of her, and he never wants another pet again for the rest of our lives because of this, and I should’ve given him more grace for his first pet.

Then he compared it to a made-up scenario of him getting rid of Boo. It turned into a heated argument.

But what do you guys think? Am I an a*****e for this?

The Emotional Toll of Pet Ownership

Pet ownership can evoke a wide range of emotions, often reflecting deeper relational dynamics between partners.

Research from the American Psychological Association highlights that disagreements over pet care often stem from differing levels of commitment and attachment styles.

In this case, the desire to rehome the puppy may indicate underlying issues in the partner's relationship dynamics, particularly around responsibility and mutual support.

Comment from u/wolf_genie

Comment from u/mesarasa

Attachment theory suggests that individuals who prioritize their needs above those of their pets may struggle with empathy and emotional connection.

Studies show that securely attached individuals tend to be more responsive to the needs of others, including pets, while avoidant individuals may distance themselves from emotional responsibilities.

This can create tension in relationships where one partner is more invested in pet care than the other.

Comment from u/JustAnotherOlive

Comment from u/midcen-mod1018

Practical Solutions for Navigating Pet Care Disputes

To address conflicts regarding pet care, couples can benefit from open discussions about their feelings and expectations.

Setting clear responsibilities and timelines for training can help create a shared sense of accountability.

Additionally, couples therapy may provide a safe space to explore underlying issues, fostering better communication and understanding.

Comment from u/maeryclarity

Comment from u/LonelyOwl68

Research on shared responsibilities in relationships shows that couples who engage in collaborative problem-solving are more likely to experience satisfaction.

When partners openly discuss their expectations regarding pet care, they can work together to create a plan that reflects both of their needs and capacities.

This collaborative approach can enhance emotional intimacy, as it requires vulnerability and trust.

Comment from u/lisainalifetime

Comment from u/reluctantseal

The Ethics of Rehoming Pets

Rehoming a pet can be a complex ethical decision, often involving feelings of guilt and anxiety.

Psychologists emphasize the importance of considering the pet's welfare alongside personal circumstances.

Research indicates that pets can sense their owners' emotional states, and a stable home environment is crucial for their well-being.

Comment from u/R4eth

Comment from u/BeeFree66

This situation underscores the importance of assessing relationship dynamics before making drastic decisions like rehoming a pet.

Studies show that pets often serve as emotional support, and their presence can significantly affect mental health outcomes.

A discussion about the implications of rehoming could lead to more informed and compassionate decisions.

Comment from u/PerspectiveWhore3879

Comment from u/Nomeismytomb

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/Lilly323

Comment from u/RobertTheWorldMaker

Comment from u/Professional-Scar628

Comment from u/MochiPryncess

Comment from u/Comprehensive_End751

Comment from u/EntertainmentDry3790

Comment from u/Purple_Material_9644

Comment from u/Disneylover-4837

Psychological Analysis

This scenario highlights the intricate balance between personal responsibilities and shared commitments in relationships. When one partner feels overwhelmed, it can lead to feelings of resentment, which may manifest as a desire to rehome a pet. It's crucial for couples to engage in honest conversations that clarify expectations and foster mutual support.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, navigating the complexities of pet ownership within a relationship requires open communication and empathy.

Understanding each partner's emotional investment and responsibilities can enhance relational satisfaction and help prevent conflicts.

Ultimately, approaching these discussions with care can lead to a supportive environment for both partners and their pet.