AITA for Asking My Wife to Leave After She Punched My Mom?

In a Reddit thread that has stirred up a heated debate, a user shared a troubling story about their wife punching their mother after a series of escalating conflicts. The post begins with the user detailing the strained relationships between their wife, mother, and other family members following the birth of their first child.

The tension reaches a breaking point during a family dinner when the user's mother deliberately provokes their wife by giving away her meal and making hurtful comments. The situation quickly escalates when the mother slaps the wife's stomach, leading the wife to punch her in self-defense.

The user then describes the aftermath, revealing that they asked their wife to leave in the heat of the moment, seeking space to process the events. However, the wife interprets this as abandonment and serves the user with divorce papers.

Despite clarifying their support for the wife and blocking the mother from their life, the user is left feeling lost and unsure of how to proceed. As the thread unfolds, comments flood in, with many condemning the user for their actions and siding with the wife.

Users criticize the user for not standing up to their mother sooner and for kicking out their wife and newborn baby instead of taking a stand against the abusive behavior. The comments reflect a unanimous sentiment that the user's handling of the situation has irreparably damaged their marriage and family dynamics.

Original Post

My situation went from bad to worse in a matter of a week, and I don't know where else to turn. I need to know if I was wrong.

Possibly a validation thing because life is f*****g dumb right now. My wife and I have been together for eight years, and she just gave birth to our first (and last) baby two months ago.

Up until my wife got pregnant, my mom loved her. I'm not sure what is wrong with my mom or why the switch happened, but after my wife got pregnant, my mom started being very clingy to me and began avoiding my wife at all costs.

She told everyone she wasn't excited about the pregnancy, etc. I threatened to go no contact with her when my wife was about seven months along, and after that, she snapped out of it for the most part and stopped being so ignorant.

The comments 100% stopped, at least. Though she was still clinging to me.

Now, a week ago, my mom, my sister, my sister's husband, and my sister's daughter (12) came over for dinner. I prepared the meal.

Before my wife could eat anything, our daughter got fussy, so my wife excused herself to go feed the baby and get her down to sleep. I thought I had prepared enough, but apparently not, because my niece was still "starving" (she's 5'5" and 190 lbs; I haven't seen her in a year, and she was not that size then, so I didn't exactly portion in an extra three helpings for a child—so it's on me).

I apologized and told her that I hadn't made any more and offered her crackers as I was putting my wife's portion in the fridge. After that, I just went outside with my sister's husband to smoke a cigarette and shoot the breeze.

I didn't think anything of it. But then I heard yelling from inside.

When I walked in, my wife and my mom were screaming at each other. Apparently, my mom (who saw me put my wife's food away) gave my niece my wife's portion of food.

As I was walking inside, I heard my mom say, "Looks like you can afford to skip a meal," and she slapped my wife's stomach. Right as I got ready to step in (literally fast walking toward them yelling, "Enough!"), my wife wound back and punched my mother square in the face, dropping her.

The whole house went silent outside of my mom crying and holding her face. I told everyone to "get the f**k out."

Immediately, everyone left, and my wife just turned toward the counter and leaned with her hands on the counter and face down, eyes closed. I looked at my wife and said, "You too, leave, now." She said, "Really?" She's crying at this point.

I said a clipped, "Yup." She packed up herself and the baby and left.

I texted her that night and said I just needed space. I needed to decompress and come to terms with what just happened.

She didn't respond. For the next five days, I texted and called, and I got nothing.

She showed up here today (so eight days later) and handed me divorce paperwork and my baby, saying, "Here, you have a bit to hang out with her while I pack. Where I'm breastfeeding, we can work out a visitation schedule that is either at your place or my mother's until she will take a bottle." I told her that's not what I want.

I don't want to separate. I just needed time to process her punching my mother in the face.

She said, "You needing time to process gave me time to process the fact that I refuse to be in this situation any longer. I defended myself.

I initially felt bad and remorseful, but you making me leave when I needed you made me see more clearly. I'm done.

I'm sorry for what I did, but there's no fixing this." She refused to speak to me at all the rest of the time that she was here. My house feels so empty, and I don't know what to do.

AITA for making her leave after she punched my mom? I just needed some f*****g space.

ETA: For the record, I am "team wife." My mom deserved it, wholeheartedly, and I've blocked her completely from my life.

I literally just needed time to process what happened. My wife is a lot of things; violent is not one of them.

So this came completely out of left field and would not have happened without her being provoked. After it all happened, my mom sent me a text saying, "See!

I told you she was crazy! That fat b***h doesn't belong in \*\*our\*\* life." I'm willing to bet she purposely tried to set my wife off.

So no, I'm on my wife's side 100%. I truly just needed to process what happened, and my wife took it as me giving up on her, not defending her and throwing her and our baby out (which did essentially happen because I knew she had to take the baby with her when I kicked her out).

ETA: The reason "why": My dad was stupidly abusive. I was beaten.

My sisters and brother were beaten. My mom was put in the hospital multiple times.

It took years for police to enforce restraining orders, and he finally died in 2013. Violence scares the f**k out of me.

I clam up and get anxious around violence of any kind now. My wife knows this, and she too grew up with a violent dad (stepdad), and she gets just as anxious and panicky around violence.

Her punching my mom in the face triggered an anxious response, and I needed her gone in that moment. I needed it far away from me.

I don't know why I didn't just leave. I could have.

But in that moment, I just let my emotions and fear run the whole f*****g circus and told everyone to get out, her included. My mom did slap her first...

I guess for some reason I was seeing my wife's punch as being worse than the slap. It wasn't a hard slap, but my wife did kind of wince, looking back on it now.

She was fine following, but my mom was bleeding. She split her eyebrow open in good shape.

I don't know. Thanks for the responses.

I'm the AH. I'm going to try to go kiss ass now.

Understanding Family Conflict

Family dynamics are often fraught with tension, especially during emotionally charged situations. Research from the American Psychological Association indicates that conflicts can trigger deep-seated emotional responses, leading to physical altercations in extreme cases.

In this scenario, the wife’s violent reaction may stem from an inability to manage her emotions effectively. Studies in emotional regulation suggest that individuals who struggle with anger often lack effective coping skills to express their feelings appropriately.

Comment from u/NickelPickle2018

Comment from u/Bonnm42

Moreover, social psychology highlights the role of stressors in escalating familial conflicts. When individuals perceive threats to their relationships or values, their fight-or-flight response can activate, sometimes resulting in aggression.

Understanding these triggers can provide insight into why certain family members react violently, illustrating the importance of emotional intelligence in conflict resolution.

Comment from u/ProfessionSanity

Comment from u/a-_rose

The Impact of External Stressors

External stressors, such as financial pressures or work-related stress, can exacerbate conflicts within families. Research published in the Journal of Family Psychology indicates that increased stress levels correlate with a higher likelihood of conflict escalation.

In this case, if the wife was already under significant stress, her reaction to the situation might not solely reflect her feelings towards the mother-in-law but also her overall emotional state.

Comment from u/Careless-Ability-748

Comment from u/Hour-Ad-1193

Addressing such conflicts requires effective communication strategies. Experts recommend using 'I' statements to express feelings without placing blame, which can help de-escalate situations before they reach a boiling point.

For instance, saying, 'I feel overwhelmed when conflicts arise' instead of 'You always make things worse' can foster a more constructive dialogue.

Comment from u/celticmusebooks

Comment from u/biteme717

Seeking Mediation and Support

In circumstances where family tensions run high, seeking external help can provide a neutral ground for resolving disputes. Family therapy can be beneficial in teaching members how to communicate effectively and understand each other's perspectives.

Studies show that families who engage in therapy often report improved communication and a reduction in hostility, fostering healthier relationships overall.

Comment from u/Trailsya

Comment from u/neanderbeast

Ultimately, it’s essential to recognize that violent reactions often indicate deeper emotional struggles. By addressing underlying issues and improving emotional regulation, families can work towards healthier conflict resolution strategies.

In this case, both partners may benefit from counseling to explore their responses to conflict and develop skills to mitigate future misunderstandings.

Comment from u/DarkmatterBlack

Comment from u/[deleted]

What's your opinion on this situation? Join the conversation!.

Comment from u/Deep-Lingonberry4568

Comment from u/MammothHistorical559

Comment from u/Haunting-blade

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/Ha1rBall

Comment from u/Ismone

Comment from u/[deleted]

Psychological Analysis

This incident represents a common scenario where stress and unresolved emotional issues culminate in conflict. The wife's reaction suggests a deeper emotional struggle that may warrant exploration in a supportive setting.

Encouraging open communication and seeking professional guidance can help both partners navigate their feelings and enhance their relationship dynamics.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Understanding the psychology behind family conflicts can provide clarity in navigating these challenging situations. Research indicates that emotional regulation and effective communication are crucial for resolving disputes.

According to family psychology studies, fostering a supportive environment where all members feel heard can significantly reduce conflicts and promote healthier relationships.