AITA for leaving with my newborn to my mom's place after my husband and his mom didn't save me dinner?

In a recent Reddit post, a 34-year-old woman shared her story of feeling neglected by her husband and mother-in-law after giving birth to her son. Despite her efforts to care for her newborn and handle household responsibilities, her husband's mother moved in to "help" but seemed more focused on socializing and disrupting the household.

The situation escalated when the woman, who was busy breastfeeding her son, discovered that there was no food saved for her for dinner, leading to a heated argument with her husband and mother-in-law. The post sparked a discussion on Reddit, with many users empathizing with the woman's frustration and feeling that she was not at fault in the situation.

Some commenters criticized the husband for not supporting his wife and prioritizing his mother over her needs. Suggestions ranged from setting boundaries with the mother-in-law to considering separation or divorce.

The thread highlighted the complexities of family dynamics, postpartum challenges, and the importance of communication and support in relationships. It raised questions about boundaries, mutual respect, and the role of extended family in a couple's life.

Original Post

I'm a 34-year-old woman. I had a baby boy six weeks ago.

My husband's mom moved into our living room right after. She keeps inviting friends over and messing up the house.

I didn't say anything because I was afraid my husband would get mad.

He said his mom was here to help, so I just ignored her and looked after my baby.

I do all the baby stuff: feeding, changing diapers, and cleaning him.

I sleep very little, so my husband's mom isn't really helping with the baby.

But I thought, "At least she's cooking for us." One night, I was in the bedroom nursing my son. I knew I was late for dinner.

However, I thought they had saved food for me. When I finished feeding my son, I came out.

My husband and his mom were watching TV. I asked about dinner.

My husband said it was "maybe" in the kitchen. As I walked to the kitchen, his mom said loudly that she didn't save me any food.

I was shocked. I asked her why.

She said, "I didn't see you at the table, so I thought you weren't hungry." I got mad and yelled that I was feeding our son.

Of course, I was hungry. I was starving!

She shrugged and said it wasn't her fault I didn't "show up for dinner."

She knew I was with my son and hadn't eaten in hours. My husband told me not to yell at his mom.

I said he saw this happen and didn't think about me being hungry. He got mad.

He asked me what I wanted him to do. I said, "Maybe save some food for me?" His mom defended him.

She said it was selfish of me to yell at him for eating his dinner after a long day at work. We argued.

I packed a bag for me and my son. I called my brother to take me to my mom's house.

My husband got mad and said I was being childish.

I said I couldn't deal with his mom anymore. He said I should be ashamed for talking like that about his mom.

She paused her life to help me. My brother came, and I left.

We picked up some food on the way, and I ate a lot.

My husband kept calling. He last texted that I was "crazy" and that I should come back.

But I told him I missed my mom. I like her clean house and healthy food.

I want to stay for a while. Now he's mad.

He told his family that I'm keeping his son from him, all because of the "food" issue.

**Edit: Some people think I'm keeping my husband from his son. He can see him anytime.

But he doesn't want to be in the same room with my mom. I don't know how long I'll stay here.

But I'm happy. My family is taking good care of me.

My husband can visit his son at my mom's house, but he won't.

He's too proud.** **Another thing to clarify: My husband is a cop. That's what I meant by "work."

Sorry if that was confusing.** **Edit: I felt bad for him. I sent pictures of our son sleeping.

He sent a long text. He said I was rubbing it in his face.

He even called me a bad word. I was trying to be nice.

I'll get more of my stuff tomorrow. I need more time to think about everything.** **Edit: He just sent me a picture of him and his mom cooking dinner.

He said they were not including me this time. I don't even know what to say.

I'm angry. I'll get more of our things tomorrow.

I'll stay at my mom's house longer.** **Edit: He sent another text. He'll come over if my mom leaves her house for two hours.

He wants to see his son and "talk." I won't make my mom leave her own house.

That's crazy. I'll see how it goes in the morning.**

The Power of Perceived Support

The feelings of neglect expressed by the woman can be understood through the lens of perceived social support. According to Dr. Terri Orbuch, a relationship researcher and author, "Social support is vital for emotional well-being, particularly during significant life changes such as becoming a parent." This insight underscores the importance of encouragement and assistance from one's social circle for new mothers.

When new mothers feel unsupported, it can exacerbate feelings of isolation and anxiety, which are already heightened during the postpartum period. Dr. Orbuch further notes, "A lack of a robust support system can lead to a cycle of neglect and mental health challenges, distancing mothers from their loved ones." Understanding these dynamics is essential for addressing the emotional challenges faced by new mothers and ensuring they receive the care they need during this critical time.

Comment from u/yeznag

Comment from u/mdthomas

From a behavioral perspective, the husband and mother-in-law's actions could be seen as unintentional neglect. Research by Harvard Health indicates that in family dynamics, individuals may not recognize the needs of others, especially when adjusting to new roles. This phenomenon often occurs when family members become so engrossed in their own transitions that they inadvertently overlook the emotional and physical needs of those around them.

This lack of awareness can lead to unintentional emotional distress for the mother, who is navigating the challenges of new motherhood while seeking support. The pressures of adapting to this new phase can be overwhelming, and without proper acknowledgment from her family, her feelings of isolation and neglect may intensify.

It's crucial for family members to communicate openly and actively engage with one another's experiences, fostering an environment of empathy that can mitigate these feelings of neglect.

Comment from u/BoomButton

Comment from u/Denverdogmama

The Impact of Negligent Behavior

Postpartum women are particularly vulnerable to feelings of neglect and its psychological consequences. According to Dr. Ramani Durvasula, a clinical psychologist, "The emotional distress experienced during the postpartum period can lead to significant issues, including postpartum depression, which can affect a mother’s ability to bond with her newborn." This condition can have long-lasting effects on both the mother’s well-being and her relationship with her child.

It is crucial for family members and friends to be attentive and responsive to the needs of new mothers to prevent these negative outcomes. As noted by Dr. Pepper Schwartz, a sociologist and relationship expert, "Support from loved ones is essential during the postpartum period; it can significantly enhance a mother’s emotional health and her connection with her child." By fostering an environment of understanding and compassion, we can help mitigate the risks associated with postpartum challenges and ensure that mothers feel valued and cared for during this transformative stage of their lives.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/moonmama95

Effective communication could be a key solution to this issue. According to Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship therapist, "When we create a safe space for open dialogue, we allow ourselves to be vulnerable and authentic, which is essential for healthy relationships." By fostering an environment where all parties feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and emotions, misunderstandings can be minimized and relationships can be strengthened.

Encouraging a dialogue where the woman can express her feelings without fear of judgment may help her husband and mother-in-law understand her needs better. This approach not only promotes empathy but also allows for a deeper connection between family members, paving the way for collaborative problem-solving. Dr. Solomon also notes, "Empathy is the bridge that connects us to others, especially in family dynamics."

Moreover, establishing ground rules for these discussions can further enhance the effectiveness of communication. By ensuring that everyone listens actively and speaks honestly, families can navigate their challenges more effectively and create a supportive atmosphere that nurtures love and understanding. As Dr. Solomon emphasizes, "Clear communication is the foundation of any strong relationship."

Comment from u/Sea-Ad9057

Comment from u/Jennergirl

The Importance of Communication

To prevent similar issues in the future, families should consider establishing clear expectations and communication practices that foster a healthy environment. Open dialogues about individual needs and feelings are crucial; therefore, immediate steps include discussing these topics openly today. Scheduling regular check-ins can be an effective way to address feelings, clarify expectations, and ensure everyone feels heard and valued.

In the short term, family members can attend a workshop on effective communication within one to two weeks. Such workshops often provide valuable tools and techniques that can significantly enhance interactions among family members. Meanwhile, longer-term strategies might involve engaging in family therapy, which can promote deeper understanding and support over the next few months. This ongoing commitment to improving communication will not only help resolve current issues but also strengthen familial bonds for the future.

Comment from u/ed_lv

Comment from u/tatasz

Lastly, the husband's role in mediating the situation is vital. His ability to understand and validate his wife's feelings can significantly alleviate her stress during challenging times. Research shows that when partners actively listen and acknowledge each other's emotions, it fosters a supportive atmosphere conducive to emotional recovery. This validation not only reassures the wife but also strengthens their bond as a couple, allowing them to navigate the complexities of parenthood together.

By proactively engaging in supportive behaviors, such as offering help with household tasks or simply being present to listen, he can help establish a nurturing environment that benefits both the mother and the newborn. Such involvement is crucial, as it not only supports the wife's mental health but also creates a sense of teamwork, reinforcing their relationship during this transformative phase of life. Ultimately, his active participation is key to ensuring a harmonious family dynamic.

Comment from u/Suitable-Cod-1381

Comment from u/CakeEatingRabbit

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/HotelLow7065

Comment from u/AmazingAmy95

Comment from u/IanDOsmond

Comment from u/Craftyhobby

Comment from u/Bright_Sea_7567

Psychological Analysis

This situation really sheds light on the psychological toll that perceived neglect can take on new parents, especially during such a vulnerable time like postpartum. The woman’s feelings of frustration and isolation likely stem from a lack of support, which can heighten stress and even lead to postpartum depression. It’s crucial for partners to actively communicate and prioritize each other’s needs, as failing to do so can create significant rifts in relationships and exacerbate feelings of neglect.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, this situation highlights the importance of perceived support, effective communication, and recognition of a new mother's needs in a postpartum context. It underscores the need for family members, particularly the husband, to be aware and responsive to these needs. A lack of this awareness can lead to feelings of neglect and potential mental health issues, as evidenced by the woman's distress. Continued research in family dynamics and postpartum psychology can lead to more effective interventions and support for new mothers.