AITA for making my son leave after he spent his college fund?

Are you the one in the wrong for kicking your son out? This hot topic has the Reddit community split.

The story goes like this: a couple saved $106k for their kids' education, promising each child $53k or the option to take it out at 21. The daughter chose wisely, attending a local university, graduating with minimal debt.

The son, however, opted for a pricier school, exhausting his fund and refusing loans. Despite warnings, the son found himself broke after two years, spending aimlessly.

He moved back home but continued his reckless habits. Frustrations peaked as he demanded more money, blaming his parents for his predicament.

Tensions rose, leading to his eviction. The mom wants to cover his schooling to prevent his downfall.

The top comments vary from supporting the tough love approach to suggesting solutions like transferring to a cheaper school. Many criticize the son's entitlement and lack of responsibility.

Some suggest interventions like seeking mental health services or financial aid counseling. The consensus leans towards tough love and letting the son learn from his mistakes.

So, what's your take on this complex family situation?

Original Post

My wife, Anne, and I started saving money for our kids' future a long time ago. We didn't realize how pricey college could get.

By the time our kids were ready for college, we had $106k saved. Our son, Tim, was going to college first.

We told both our kids they would get $53k each. They could use it for college or take it out when they turned 21.

But, that was all the money they would get from us. This cash would cover almost all of the cost at our local state university.

If they wanted to go to a more costly school, they had to pay for it. Our daughter, Lisa, went to the local university and lived at home.

She got a business degree and almost no debt. Tim decided to go to a more costly school.

The tuition there was $27k a year. We tried to change his mind, but he didn't listen.

We warned him he would have to pay his own way. After 2 years, Tim ran out of money.

He wanted to change his major, which meant another year in school. He asked us for money but we said no.

He used up his education fund. He didn't want to take out loans, so he started working.

Then the pandemic hit. We let him move back home to save money.

But he spent all his earnings on Amazon. Even when he got a better job, he spent his money on video games and clothes.

He never saved any money. Four years later, Tim hadn't saved any money.

Lisa was now making a lot of money, which made him feel bad. Tim started smoking w**d and playing video games all day.

His boss noticed and let him go. He got unemployment money, but it wasn't enough to save for college.

He asked us for money again. We reminded him that he chose the costly school.

He said he didn't understand what that meant when he was 18. He blamed us for letting him choose.

We tried to talk him out of it, but he didn't listen. We couldn't make him go to the cheaper school.

We said he should take out loans, but he wanted us to pay for his school. We had many fights over this.

Tim thinks we treated him unfairly. He parties late, makes noise at night, and won't help around the house.

He lives with us for free. We had no choice but to tell him to move out.

He left last week to live with friends. He got mad at us and said we would never be part of his life.

Anne wants to pay for his schooling so he doesn't fail in life. Make sure the story is easy to read, natural, and covers the same moral question.

Understanding the Psychology of Squandering

Understanding the psychology behind impulsive spending is crucial, especially for young adults navigating their financial landscape. According to Suze Orman, a renowned financial advisor, "Impulsivity often stems from a lack of understanding of the long-term consequences of financial decisions." Many young adults struggle to foresee these consequences, leading to detrimental outcomes like squandering education funds or accumulating unnecessary debt. This tendency can manifest in various behaviors, such as prioritizing immediate gratification over strategic financial planning, which can have lasting impacts on their financial health. In your son's case, for instance, this impulsive behavior may prevent him from saving for important milestones, such as a car or his future education. Recognizing these patterns is the first step towards fostering healthier financial habits and making more informed decisions.

Comment from u/Think-Level-2029

Comment from u/iaincaradoc

Overconfidence can play a pivotal role in financial decision-making, significantly impacting how individuals assess their understanding of financial matters. The 'Overconfidence Effect' suggests that individuals, particularly young adults, often overestimate their knowledge and abilities regarding financial issues. According to David Bach, a financial author and expert, "Many young adults believe they can handle their finances without guidance, which often leads to costly mistakes." This cognitive bias can lead to poor financial choices, as individuals may believe they can manage risks far better than they actually can. This can result in misguided investments or avoidance of necessary financial strategies that could benefit them in the long run.

In your son's situation, his refusal to take on loans may stem from this overconfidence, leading him to underestimate the financial implications of his college choice. He might firmly believe that he can navigate his education without financial assistance, failing to recognize the potential long-term benefits of strategic borrowing. As Liz Weston, a financial columnist, notes, "Understanding the value of education and how to finance it wisely is crucial for long-term success." This mindset could ultimately hinder his academic and career prospects, emphasizing the importance of balanced financial awareness.

Comment from u/artsyaspen

Comment from u/Mama-Sawka

The Impact of Parenting Styles

Parenting styles significantly influence children's financial behaviors and decision-making processes, shaping their attitudes toward money from a young age. According to Farnoosh Torabi, a financial expert, "The financial habits children learn from their parents can set the stage for their future financial success or struggles." Authoritative parenting, which encourages open communication and sets clear expectations, is particularly effective in equipping children with the skills they need to navigate complex financial landscapes with confidence. In contrast, permissive or neglectful parenting can hinder the development of these essential skills. As noted by Dr. Lawrence Cohen, a child psychologist, "Children learn best when they are in a supportive environment that encourages them to explore and make decisions." This dynamic might explain your son's financial missteps, highlighting the critical role that parenting plays in shaping not just behavior, but also long-term financial well-being.

Comment from u/nothingclever4now

Comment from u/Wide-Employment-7922

Social pressures and societal norms can heavily influence financial behaviors, especially in young adults navigating their formative years. The desire to fit in or 'keep up with the Joneses' can drive individuals to make unwise financial decisions, prioritizing status and appearances over sound financial planning. This phenomenon is often exacerbated by social media, where curated lifestyles can lead to unrealistic expectations and comparisons. Research highlights that social comparison can lead to increased financial strain and impulsivity, as seen in your son's choices. He may feel the need to spend beyond his means to align with peers or to project an image of success.

Understanding these influences can provide valuable insight into his actions and emotions, potentially fostering more constructive dialogues about financial responsibility. By addressing these societal pressures, you can help him develop a healthier perspective on money management and the importance of prioritizing long-term stability over fleeting trends.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/ClothesQueasy2828

The Effect of Tough Love

Tough love can be an effective parenting strategy, particularly when teaching children about consequences. According to research from the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, imposing boundaries can help children understand the implications of their actions. This approach fosters a sense of responsibility, enabling kids to grasp the connection between their choices and the outcomes that follow.

However, it's crucial to approach this method with empathy and ensure that the child feels supported rather than abandoned. When parents implement tough love, they must communicate their intentions clearly, reinforcing that the goal is to help, not to punish. By balancing accountability with understanding, parents can guide their children toward better decision-making, equipping them with the tools they need to navigate challenges in the future. Ultimately, a compassionate approach to tough love can lead to healthier parent-child relationships and positive personal growth.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/Desc440

Instead of placing blame, it's essential to promote constructive conversations about responsibility. Engaging in discussions framed around accountability can lead to more meaningful learning experiences for both parents and children alike. As Dr. Madeline Levine, a renowned child psychologist, states, "When parents engage in open dialogue, it allows children to learn from their mistakes without feeling judged." This nurturing environment encourages kids to express their thoughts and feelings, ultimately leading to improved decision-making skills. When parents approach topics with empathy and support, it can pave the way for healthier financial habits and stronger parent-child relationships. By prioritizing communication over criticism, families can create a safe space where learning takes precedence, helping children navigate challenges with confidence and resilience.

Comment from u/666POD

Comment from u/TinyRascalSaurus

Preventing Similar Incidents

To prevent similar incidents, early financial education is crucial for the development of responsible money management skills. Research shows that financial literacy at a young age leads to better financial decision-making later in life, ultimately promoting a healthier financial future. Here’s a structured approach to instilling these essential skills in children:

Immediate (today): Start by having a candid conversation with your children about the importance of budgeting and saving. Explain how these practices can help them achieve their goals and avoid unnecessary debt, fostering a sense of financial responsibility from an early age.

Short-term (1–2 weeks): Introduce them to simple budgeting tools and encourage them to track their spending. This hands-on experience will help them understand the value of money and the impact of their financial choices.

Long-term (1–3 months): Consider enrolling them in a financial literacy course or workshop, which can provide them with the skills necessary for sound financial management. Such educational opportunities will empower them to make informed decisions as they grow older.

Comment from u/thirdtryisthecharm

Comment from u/baneline2

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Comment from u/Neat-Boysenberry5333

Comment from u/fargoLEVY13

Comment from u/Fainora

Comment from u/HearseWithNoName

Comment from u/Still_Storm7432

Comment from u/lyan-cat

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights how impulsivity and a lack of future orientation often drive young adults to make poor financial choices. The son’s behavior could stem from an overconfidence bias, where he underestimated the consequences of his decisions. It’s also interesting to consider the impact of parenting styles; clear boundaries and financial education could have better prepared him for these responsibilities.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, a combination of psychological factors, parenting styles, and social influences might have contributed to the son's financial behavior. Although tough love might seem like the right approach in this situation, it's crucial to balance it with support and understanding. Early financial education and fostering a future-oriented perspective can help prevent such situations. This case is a reminder of the importance of understanding the psychological underpinnings of financial behavior, as it can significantly impact one's life.