AITA for moving out of state and abandoning my mom?

Are you ready for some family drama? A Reddit user shared their story about wanting to move out of state with their husband, only to have their mom accuse them of abandoning her.

The couple, both small business owners, are tired of California's high cost of living and are eyeing a move to Minnesota for a better quality of life. Despite having family support in their new location, the mom's reaction was less than supportive, claiming the user is choosing their husband's family over their own.

The thread is filled with supportive comments reassuring the user that pursuing their happiness and financial stability is not selfish. Many users highlight the importance of independence and making decisions that benefit their own family unit.

Some even share personal experiences of moving away from family and the challenges it brings. However, not everyone is on board with the move, raising concerns about the drastic weather change, cultural differences, and political landscapes between California and Minnesota.

Despite the differing opinions, the consensus remains that the user is not in the wrong for wanting to make a life-changing decision for themselves and their partner.

Original Post

Hi all! My husband and I have been together for 10 years, married for 3, and have always wanting to move out of state.

We both were born and raised in California, and quite frankly are just tired of the rat race here. We both have our own businesses (he’s a plumber, I’m a hairstylist), and make pretty decent money, but still can’t (and probably won’t ever) afford a house here in CA.

Even if we could afford a home here, we would be overworking ourselves and wouldn’t have the quality of life that we want. We have been back and forth about moving for the past 4 years.

We were dead set on moving to Tennessee in 2022, and then my dad unexpectedly passed, so we put moving on the back burner. Summer of 2023, we took a trip with my in laws to their families lake house in Minnesota, and fell in love with it.

Over the last 3 years, we have visited where my husband’s grandparents live in Minnesota (during every season), which is a small suburb outside of Rochester. We love it.

Love the small town feel, and love that within a 20 minute drive to the city, you have all your normal stores and lots of activities to do. Long story short, we have been going back and forth with moving.

My in laws actually just decided that they were going to move there, and bought a house. This kind of lit a fire under mine and my husband’s ass lol.

Having them there would make our transition MUCH easier. They have already told us that we could live with them for as long as needed, while we’re getting settled and finding jobs.

Anyways, I knew my mom wouldn’t react well, and surprise, she didn’t. She told me that I’m basically choosing my husbands family over my family and that I’m “leaving her high and dry” (along with a lot of other things) I know she’s sad, but the way she is talking about us moving is pretty hurtful.

I should also mention that my older sister has lived in multiple different states over the last 6 years with her family. I also have a younger brother who lived at home with my mom.

Am I really choosing one family over the other? Am I a horrible daughter for leaving the state, and choosing to do what my husband and I truly want?

Understanding the Psychology of Family Dynamics

Family dynamics often become complex when one member decides to make significant life changes, such as moving out of state. This decision can trigger various emotional responses and may lead to misunderstandings among family members. According to a study published by JSTOR, the relational patterns within families can heavily influence how decisions are perceived and reacted to by other members. Such shifts can create ripples that affect the entire family structure.

This is especially relevant when the decision involves a perceived shift in loyalty or availability, which might explain the mother's reaction in this case. Her feelings may stem from a fear of losing connection or support, which is common in familial relationships. Understanding these dynamics can help individuals navigate their own feelings and those of their family, fostering healthier communication and emotional resilience during transitions.

Comment from u/Laughorcryliveordie

Comment from u/Tough-Combination-37

From a psychological perspective, the mother's feelings of abandonment may be deeply rooted in her fear of being alone, which can often stem from a lack of self-sufficiency. Additionally, her reliance on her child for emotional support complicates the situation further. A study published in Psychological Bulletin highlights how dependence on family can create an emotional barrier when one member seeks independence, leading to feelings of resentment or betrayal.

These emotional dynamics can manifest in various ways, particularly during pivotal life changes such as a child's move away from home. Recognizing these underlying fears can allow for a more empathetic response to her accusations, creating an opportunity for understanding and compassion. This approach can potentially ease tensions during discussions about the move, fostering a more supportive dialogue that respects both parties' feelings.

Comment from u/Physical_Lemon_8276

Comment from u/KoomDawg432

The Impact of Guilt

Guilt is another powerful emotion that adult children often experience when contemplating significant changes, especially moves. Dr. Susan David, an emotional agility expert, states, "Guilt can arise from the tension between our desire for personal happiness and the expectations of our family." This emotional conflict can be particularly intense when considering the impact of one’s decisions on family dynamics and relationships, as noted on her website susandavid.com. It's crucial for the individual to acknowledge this guilt but also to understand that prioritizing their well-being is not inherently selfish. Recognizing that personal growth and happiness can coexist with familial loyalty is essential. Balancing these emotions can lead to healthier family interactions, as it encourages open communication and understanding among family members, ultimately strengthening the bonds they share.

Comment from u/silfy_star

Comment from u/briana28019

The emotional states of individuals significantly influence decision-making in profound ways. According to Dr. Michele Gelfand, a cultural psychologist, "Emotions play a crucial role in how we interpret our experiences and make choices. When negative emotions dominate, they can cloud our judgment and lead to poor decision-making." This insight highlights the importance of emotional awareness in our daily lives. Recognizing when emotions are clouding judgment can empower individuals to step back and evaluate their circumstances more objectively. By doing so, they can make more informed and deliberate choices regarding their futures, including significant decisions such as geographic relocations. Understanding the interplay between emotions and decision-making equips individuals to navigate life's challenges with greater clarity and confidence, ultimately leading to better outcomes in both personal and professional contexts.

Comment from u/HodorTargaryen

Comment from u/nothing-is-equal

The Importance of Open Communication

Open and honest communication can be a vital tool in addressing family tensions that often arise from major life decisions. Dr. John Gray, a renowned relationship author, emphasizes, "Communication is the foundation of any relationship; it fosters understanding and connection" on his website marsvenus.com. When individuals express their thoughts and feelings openly, it lays the groundwork for empathy and understanding.

Engaging in calm discussions with family members about feelings and concerns can significantly help bridge emotional gaps. This approach not only facilitates a more supportive environment but also encourages everyone involved to feel heard and validated. As Dr. Michele Weiner-Davis, a marriage therapist, notes, "Effective communication is essential for resolving conflicts and strengthening relationships" on her site divorcebusting.com.

Ultimately, prioritizing communication can transform challenging conversations into opportunities for growth, allowing families to bond over shared experiences and navigate life's complexities together.

Comment from u/International-Fee255

Comment from u/No_Scarcity8249

Open and honest communication can be a vital tool in addressing family tensions that often arise from major life decisions. Dr. Sue Johnson, a pioneer in couples therapy, emphasizes, "The quality of our relationships depends on our ability to communicate openly and honestly" on her website iceeft.com. When individuals express their thoughts and feelings openly, it lays the groundwork for empathy and understanding.

Engaging in calm discussions with family members about feelings and concerns can significantly help bridge emotional gaps. This approach not only facilitates a more supportive environment but also encourages everyone involved to feel heard and validated. As Dr. Michele Weiner-Davis, a marriage therapist, notes, "Communication is the lifeblood of any relationship; without it, misunderstandings and resentments can fester" on her site divorcebusting.com.

Ultimately, prioritizing communication can transform challenging conversations into opportunities for growth, allowing families to bond over shared experiences and navigate life's complexities together.

Comment from u/ETHan_Carver

Comment from u/SamSpayedPI

Psychology of Decision Making

To effectively manage the emotional complexities of moving away from family, a structured approach can be beneficial. This transition can often be daunting, filled with mixed emotions of excitement and anxiety. Start with immediate steps: have an open conversation with your mom about your feelings and intentions today. It's essential to express your emotions honestly, as this sets the groundwork for understanding and support.

In the short-term (1–2 weeks), explore family therapy options to facilitate discussions. This can provide a safe space for both of you to express your feelings and concerns about the upcoming change. For the longer-term (1–3 months), consider scheduling regular check-ins with your mom to maintain the relationship post-move. These check-ins can be through phone calls or video chats, ensuring both parties feel connected even at a distance. Staying engaged in each other’s lives will help ease the emotional strain of separation.

Comment from u/SpicyArms

Comment from u/elliottbtx

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

Comment from u/g3tbrnsd

Comment from u/peetecalvin

Comment from u/Hail-to-the-Sheep

Comment from u/LiveLongerAndWin

Comment from u/Parasamgate

Comment from u/FudgeNo7683

Psychological Analysis

This scenario showcases the complex emotional dynamics of family relationships and decision-making. The mother's reaction may stem from feelings of abandonment or fear of being alone, while the Reddit user is likely grappling with guilt and societal expectations of familial obligations. Open communication could be key in navigating these emotions and ensuring decisions are made with a clear mind, not under emotional duress.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, the Reddit user's situation is a complex interplay of family dynamics, emotional attachments, guilt, and decision-making processes. By understanding the underlying psychological principles, they can navigate this challenging situation more effectively. They should remember that their emotions are valid and that open communication could pave the way for a resolution. In the end, their decision should be based on what's best for their personal well-being and quality of life.