AITA for not letting my older daughter live with me to save on college fees?

In a recent Reddit post, a father seeks opinions on whether he was in the wrong for not allowing his daughter to move in with him. The man, a father of two girls, Tina and Lisa, had the opportunity to have Lisa live with him to attend a college near his home, enabling her to benefit from in-state fees.

However, citing limited space in his small apartment and concerns about Lisa missing her mother, he declined her request. Now, with Lisa set to attend a college far away, the father questions whether he made the right choice.

The Reddit community's responses are overwhelmingly critical, with many labeling the father as the antagonist in this scenario. They highlight that the father had a spare room used as an office that could have accommodated Lisa, and they question his priorities and commitment to his daughter's well-being.

Some comments express disappointment in the missed opportunity for the father to support his daughter's education and build a stronger relationship. The thread delves into complex family dynamics and the long-term impacts of parental decisions on children.

The discussion sheds light on the emotional nuances of family relationships and the importance of parental support during crucial life transitions, particularly in the context of higher education. The responses offer a mix of judgment and empathy, reflecting the diverse perspectives within the Reddit community on parenting and familial responsibilities.

Original Post

I'm a 47-year-old man. I have two girls, Tina (22) and Lisa (18).

Their mom and I split up, and we live in different cities.

Tina studies at a private college near her mom's house. Her mom and scholarships cover most of the costs.

Last year, Lisa found a college she loves. It's close to my house.

She called me and expressed her desire to live with me and my wife, Jane, for her last year of high school.

This would help her get cheaper in-state college fees. Jane and I live in a small two-bedroom apartment.

One room is Jane's office, but Jane has a bad back.

So, she often works from a comfy chair in our living room. We also have two pets.

I told Lisa I'd talk to Jane about her idea and get back to her. About a week later, Lisa called me.

She wanted to know if we had made a decision. I told her we didn't have enough room.

We also felt she would miss her mom too much. Now, Lisa has chosen a college.

It's far away from both me and her mom. I'm worried about her being so far away.

Am I the bad guy here?

The Impact of Parental Support on College Students

Parental support, both emotional and financial, is crucial during a student's college experience. According to research from the University of Michigan, students with strong parental backing often demonstrate higher academic performance and better mental health outcomes. This research highlights the importance of having a reliable support system, as it can significantly influence a student’s overall well-being and success in their studies.

However, this support is not just about finances; emotional support plays a significant role in a student's ability to cope with the stresses of college life. Parents who provide encouragement, guidance, and understanding help their children navigate the challenges they face. The father's decision to deny Lisa’s request for living arrangements may inadvertently affect her emotional stability and sense of security.

Without close parental support, students can feel isolated, which can lead to increased anxiety and decreased academic performance. This lack of connection may hinder their ability to engage fully in the college experience, making it essential for parents to remain involved and supportive, regardless of financial contributions.

Comment from u/No-Quiet-8208

Comment from u/No_Yogurtcloset_1020

Additionally, the father's choice could strain his relationship with Lisa in profound ways. A study by Fingerman (2013) highlights that parental decisions significantly impact children's perceptions of their parents, particularly during transitional life stages like college. This stage is critical for young adults as they seek independence and validation, making any perceived rejection from a parent especially poignant. If Lisa feels rejected by her father, it may hinder their relationship, leading to feelings of resentment, abandonment, and a sense of disconnection that could linger well beyond this phase of her life.

Recognizing this potential strain is essential for both parties to navigate their emotions effectively. Open communication and mutual understanding can help bridge any gaps formed by such decisions, allowing them to maintain a healthy relationship moving forward. Ultimately, fostering a supportive environment will be key in ensuring that Lisa feels valued and understood, despite the complexities of their situation.

Comment from u/Inconceivable44

Comment from u/GoblinOfficial

The Role of Proximity in Maintaining Relationships

The geographical distance introduced by Lisa's college choice can complicate their relationship further than either of them might have anticipated. Research by Jiang and Hancock (2013) indicates that physical distance often leads to diminished emotional closeness among family members, which can be particularly challenging during significant life transitions. This emotional strain can be intensified if not addressed proactively, leading to feelings of isolation or disconnect.

Frequent visits or consistent communication can mitigate this effect, but it requires concerted effort from both the father and daughter to maintain a connection despite the miles. They could explore various methods to stay in touch, such as scheduling regular video calls or planning visits during breaks, which could help foster a sense of closeness even from afar. By prioritizing their relationship, they can create shared experiences that bridge the gap created by distance.

Comment from u/sisival

Comment from u/HeatherKiwi

It's also important to acknowledge the father's valid concerns regarding space and Lisa's relationship with her mother. According to Dr. Dan Siegel, a renowned child psychiatrist, "Transitions can create emotional turbulence, and it's crucial to maintain open lines of communication to navigate these changes effectively." When a child transitions to a new phase in life, such as going to college, the emotional landscape can shift significantly, leading to potential feelings of division and conflict.

The father’s apprehension about Lisa possibly feeling torn between two homes is a legitimate concern that many families face during such transitions. Dr. John Gottman, a leading relationship researcher, emphasizes that "open discussions about feelings can foster understanding and support," which can ultimately lead to a more nurturing environment for her college journey. By addressing these issues collaboratively, they can foster a stronger bond and ensure that Lisa feels secure and confident as she embarks on this new chapter.

Comment from u/AppropriateScience71

Comment from u/Ok_Homework8692

The Impact of Decision Making on Self-perception

The father's decision could also reflect on his self-perception as a parent, which plays a crucial role in his emotional well-being. According to a study by Belsky and Jaffee (2011), parents often evaluate their effectiveness based on their children's outcomes. This means that if Lisa struggles at college, the father might start questioning his choices and parenting methods, leading to feelings of guilt, inadequacy, or even self-doubt.

Such emotions can be overwhelming, but it’s important for him to remember that parenting is a complex journey filled with ups and downs. Encouraging self-reflection and seeking peer support can help him navigate these feelings more effectively. Engaging with other parents can provide valuable perspectives, fostering a supportive environment that allows him to maintain a constructive relationship with his daughter, even during challenging times.

Comment from u/LaG1122

Comment from u/WavesnMountains

It's essential to consider societal norms that often dictate parental responsibilities and expectations. Many cultures around the world uphold the belief that parents should provide unwavering support during their children's educational journeys. This pressure can create significant stress and lead to feelings of inadequacy if a parent feels they cannot meet these expectations, potentially impacting their mental health and overall well-being.

Moreover, the weight of these societal expectations can sometimes result in a sense of isolation, as parents may feel they are alone in their struggles. Engaging with peers or support groups can provide valuable insight into similar experiences, helping to alleviate these feelings of isolation. By sharing their stories and coping strategies, parents can foster a supportive community that enhances their ability to navigate the challenges of parenting and education.

Comment from u/chihuahua001

Comment from u/tunagirltunaworld

Understanding the Complexity of Parental Decisions

To prepare for future interactions, the father should take actionable steps to improve communication with Lisa. Immediate actions might include scheduling a weekly check-in call, allowing them to touch base regularly and share updates about their lives. In the short term (1–2 weeks), he could send care packages filled with thoughtful items or encouraging messages to show his unwavering support and love, which can significantly uplift her spirits during challenging times.

In the longer term (1–3 months), they should plan visits that not only provide opportunities for face-to-face conversations but also help strengthen their bond through shared experiences. By proactively addressing their relationship in this way, the father can create a nurturing and supportive environment that fosters resilience and emotional connection, regardless of physical distance. This commitment to open communication will ultimately benefit both, enhancing their relationship and ensuring that Lisa feels valued and understood.

Comment from u/NothingMattress167

Comment from u/madisengreen

How would you handle this situation? Let us know in the comments.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/BuildingBridges23

Comment from u/car55tar5

Comment from u/Hot-Plum-874

Comment from u/Dittoheadforever

Comment from u/Ill-Conversation5210

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the intricate balance parents must navigate between their own limitations and their children's needs. The father's decision, rooted in concerns about space and his daughter's emotional ties, reflects common parental anxieties about supporting their children while maintaining family dynamics. However, the potential strain on their relationship due to perceived lack of support could lead to feelings of resentment or distance, underscoring the importance of open dialogue and understanding during critical life transitions.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Understanding the psychological complexities of such decisions can provide valuable insights for both parents and children. The father's scenario is a reminder that parental decisions, while often made with the best intentions, can have far-reaching impacts. It underscores the importance of open communication, understanding, and empathy in the parent-child relationship, especially during pivotal transitions like the move to college (Barnett, 2015).