AITA for pushing my son out after he squandered his college savings?

Some families hand out college money like it comes with a receipt and a return policy. This one did not. Lisa and her husband had been saving early, feeling proud of how prepared they were, until Max decided to spend his future on a pricier school and “figured it out later. Molly took the local route, lived at home, graduated almost debt-free, and kept earning. Max, meanwhile, chose a college with a $27,000 yearly fee plus rent, blew through his savings, then asked his parents to cover extra time when he wanted to switch majors. He moved back during the pandemic to save, but instead he stalled, spent on video games and clothes, smoked weed, lost his job, and still couldn’t rebuild the money he’d already spent.

Now he’s out of the house, furious that his parents enforced the boundary they set years ago.

Original Post

Lisa and I started saving early for our children's future. However, we didn't foresee the hike in college fees.

By the time Max and Molly were college-ready, we had $106,000. We explained they'd get $53,000 each.

They could use it for college or wait until they were 21. But that's all they'd get.

The sum would almost cover the local college fees. If they chose a pricier one, they'd have to pay the difference.

Molly went local, lived at home, and graduated in business almost debt-free. Max chose a costlier college with a $27,000 yearly fee plus rent.

We tried to dissuade him, but he didn't listen. He was on his own.

Two years later, Max's money ran out. He wanted to switch his major, meaning an extra year.

He asked us for money. We reminded him that he'd used his share.

He didn't want loans and started working. During the pandemic, we let him move back to save money.

But he wasn't saving. He got a better job but still couldn't save for college.

Instead, he spent on video games and clothes. Four years went by, and he had no savings.

Molly, meanwhile, was earning well, which upset him. Max started smoking weed and playing video games all day.

He lost his job and started receiving unemployment benefits. But it wasn't enough to save for college.

He asked us again for money. We reminded him that we'd already given him his share.

He blamed us for letting him pick a costly college. We reminded him we'd tried to dissuade him.

I suggested he take a loan and go to the cheaper college, but he insisted we should pay. We argued a lot about this.

He thought we were unfair for not giving him more money. He also stayed out late and disrupted our sleep.

He wouldn't help with chores, even though he lived with us rent-free. We had no choice but to give him three months' notice.

He moved out last week to live with friends. He was angry and said we'd never be part of his life.

Now, Lisa wants to pay for his college so he won't fail in life.

The situation presented in this article highlights a troubling dynamic of entitlement that can arise when children are not held accountable for their financial decisions. The son, who squandered his college savings on an expensive college, embodies a mindset that seems to lack an understanding of the value of hard work and financial responsibility. This behavior suggests that he may have developed an expectation of being rescued without facing the consequences of his choices, a common outcome when parents do not enforce accountability.

Moreover, the parent’s decision to push their son out could serve as a necessary wake-up call, as it emphasizes the importance of setting boundaries and expectations. A structured environment where accountability is prioritized can help prevent the emergence of entitlement, allowing children to appreciate the significance of their actions and decisions.

Comment from u/Think-Level-2029

Comment from u/iaincaradoc

That $53,000 “this is all you get” plan was supposed to keep things fair for Max and Molly, but Max treated it like a starting point.

The modern landscape encourages a culture of instant gratification, particularly among younger generations. A study in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences illustrates that easy access to technology and quick rewards can lead to impulsive decision-making, often resulting in choices that prioritize short-term pleasure over long-term benefits. In the case discussed, the son’s choices—spending his college fund on immediate pleasures—highlight this troubling trend.

Such behaviors can stem from a lack of understanding of the long-term consequences of one's actions. This phenomenon underscores the critical need for parental guidance in fostering patience and foresight in children. Parents play a vital role in teaching their children the value of delayed gratification and the importance of making informed decisions. By encouraging discussions about future goals and the significance of planning, families can help cultivate a more thoughtful approach to life’s choices.

Comment from u/artsyaspen

Comment from u/Mama-Sawka

Consequences of Tough Love

When dealing with entitled behavior, many parents find themselves resorting to a 'tough love' approach.

Comment from u/nothingclever4now

Comment from u/Wide-Employment-7922

When Max’s money ran out after two years and he wanted an extra year to change majors, the request landed right where OP and Lisa had already said no.

Interestingly, the son’s tendency to retreat into video games and substance use may signify a form of escapism. This behavior often serves as a coping mechanism for stress or unresolved issues that may be too overwhelming to confront directly. Many young people turn to these distractions as a way to avoid dealing with their emotions and the challenges they face in their daily lives.

It’s vital for parents to recognize these signs early on and actively engage their children in conversations about healthier coping strategies. By opening up a dialogue, parents can help their children understand the importance of facing their problems rather than avoiding them. Encouraging hobbies, exercise, or creative outlets can effectively replace escapist behaviors with more constructive alternatives. This not only fosters emotional resilience but also enhances self-esteem, ultimately helping children develop the skills they need to navigate life's challenges more effectively.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/ClothesQueasy2828

Importance of Parental Guidance

Research indicates that parental involvement is crucial in shaping a child's attitude towards life.

It’s like the pickleball showdown where you’re stuck with partners who refuse to learn the rules or keep score.

Comment from u/Desc440

Comment from u/[deleted]

The pandemic move-back sounded like a second chance, until Max spent his time on video games and weed and still didn’t save a dollar.

The decision to 'push' the son out could serve as a crucial lesson in personal responsibility, emphasizing the importance of facing the consequences of one's actions. This aligns closely with the psychological concept of 'natural consequences,' where individuals learn from the outcomes that arise from their behavior. By experiencing these outcomes directly, individuals can gain valuable insights into the effects of their choices.

While this approach may present challenges and discomfort, it ultimately cultivates a sense of accountability in young individuals. By navigating their own experiences, they become better equipped to handle future challenges, reinforcing the idea that personal responsibility is a fundamental aspect of growth and development.

Comment from u/666POD

Comment from u/thirdtryisthecharm

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Comment from u/TinyRascalSaurus

Comment from u/baneline2

Comment from u/Neat-Boysenberry5333

Comment from u/fargoLEVY13

Comment from u/Fainora

Comment from u/HearseWithNoName

Comment from u/Still_Storm7432

Comment from u/lyan-cat

After Max disrupted their sleep, refused chores while living rent-free, and demanded more money anyway, OP and Lisa served him three months’ notice.

The dilemma faced by the parent in this situation underscores the importance of instilling financial literacy in children from an early age. The stark contrast between the parent’s diligent saving and the son's reckless spending highlights a critical gap in financial understanding. Engaging in open discussions about money management is not just beneficial; it is essential for setting a solid foundation for their future.

Moreover, the article suggests that parents should consider long-term solutions such as enrolling their children in financial education workshops. This proactive approach could equip them with the skills to handle real-world financial challenges, fostering a sense of responsibility and ownership over their finances. Ultimately, by prioritizing financial education, parents can help their children develop the habits and knowledge necessary to navigate adulthood without falling into the traps of poor financial decisions, as seen in this troubling case.

OP might be the villain in Max’s story, but he’s not wrong that nobody gets unlimited college money after squandering a set deal.

Max’s savings blowup feels harsh, but wait until you see the boyfriend who got mad after Dad fixed her car.