AITA for requesting early arrival from mom and stepdad for birthday dinner?

AITA for prioritizing guests at my birthday dinner? Opinions vary on whether I handled seating constraints insensitively towards my mom.

Damjan

Published in Interesting
24 Oct 2025

AITA for requesting early arrival from mom and stepdad for birthday dinner?

Are you the type to meticulously plan every detail of your birthday celebration? Well, one Reddit user found themselves in a bit of a pickle when they had to navigate limited seating at a restaurant for their special day.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

The user, a 28-year-old woman, carefully curated the guest list for an intimate birthday dinner with friends and family. However, things took a turn when the user asked their mom and stepdad to arrive early to secure their spots at the table.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Navigating family dynamics and event logistics can be challenging, especially when tough decisions need to be made. The user found themselves wondering whether they had inadvertently hurt their mom's feelings by prioritizing certain guests because of space constraints.

The Reddit thread is buzzing with opinions on whether the user was in the wrong or if their actions were justified. Some Redditors argue that it's essential to set boundaries and prioritize practicalities when planning events, while others emphasize the importance of making loved ones feel valued and included.

The debate raises interesting points about balancing personal preferences with familial expectations during special occasions. Have you ever found yourself in a similar situation?

Share your thoughts and join the discussion on AITA for asking my mom and stepdad to arrive early at my birthday dinner?

Original Post

I (28F) recently planned a birthday dinner at a small, intimate restaurant to celebrate with close friends and family. Due to limited seating, I had to manage the guest list carefully.

I invited my mom and stepdad, and since they were important to me, I asked them to arrive early to secure their spots. I assured them that if space opened up later, others could join.

However, my mom seemed distant and acted as if she wasn't truly invited. She made comments hinting at feeling left out.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Now, I'm in a dilemma wondering if I handled the situation wrong. For background, my relationship with my mom has had its ups and downs.

While I value her presence, I also needed to ensure the dinner went smoothly with the space constraints. I didn't mean to hurt her feelings, but I felt the need to prioritize certain guests due to the limited seats.

So, AITA?

[ADVERTISEMENT]