Am I the Jerk for Moving in with My Boyfriend Despite Verbal Agreement with Flatmate?

Are you the jerk for wanting to move in with your boyfriend, breaking a pact with your flatmate in the process? You've been living with a close friend for years, sharing the financial burden to make ends meet.

However, things took a turn when you decided to take your relationship with your boyfriend to the next level by planning to move in together. Despite giving your flatmate a generous 14 months’ notice, she reacted extremely, calling you selfish and claiming you'd leave her "homeless." Even though you offered to help find solutions, she's been unwilling to have a productive conversation, making you feel guilty for wanting to progress in your personal life.

The Reddit community seems divided on the issue. Some believe your friend is being unreasonable, given the ample notice you provided.

They argue that it's not your responsibility to put your life on hold indefinitely to uphold a verbal agreement made years ago. Others suggest giving your friend space to process and come to terms with the change, hoping she'll eventually understand and accept the situation.

In the end, it boils down to balancing your own happiness and honoring commitments while considering the impact on those around you. The discussion sheds light on the complexities of friendship and navigating evolving relationships as life progresses.

Original Post

I (26M) live with a close friend whom I have known since we were 11, and when we first moved in together, we made a verbal agreement: neither of us would move out to live with a partner unless the other could also afford to move out. The idea was to look out for each other financially, as neither of us can afford the flat on our own.

Although, in hindsight, I can see how this is unrealistic and unfair. Here’s the issue: I’ve been with my boyfriend for a year, and a couple of months ago, we decided we’d like to move in together.

This wouldn’t even be happening until August 2026, as I’d just renewed our lease. I told my flatmate within days of making the decision, so she has 14 months’ notice.

Her reaction was extreme. She immediately called me selfish, a bad friend, and said I’d be making her “homeless.” She’s also said that if I leave, she’ll have to move back to her dad’s (several hours away), which would mean quitting her job.

I do feel bad, but I honestly thought I was being considerate by giving her over a year to prepare and by offering to help find solutions. Instead, she’s refused to even have a proper conversation about it, and when we do talk about it, I’m made to feel guilty, and it feels like she doesn’t want to listen to my side of the story.

The way I see it, I can’t put my relationship on hold forever because of a verbal pact we made three years ago. I want to support my friend, but it feels unreasonable for her to expect me to delay a huge step in my life indefinitely, especially when I’ve given her so much notice and offered to help.

So, AITA for planning to move in with my boyfriend even though it breaks the agreement I made with my flatmate? Edit for clarity:
1) The agreement was verbal, not legally binding.

2) The lease runs until July 2026, with both of our names on it. 3) Rent is split 50/50; neither of us could afford the flat solo, but she makes a bit more money than I do and has the ability to do overtime a lot more than I can.

4) I’ve offered to help her find someone new or look for alternatives, but she’s flatly refused.

According to Dr. Laura Berman, a renowned sex therapist, "verbal agreements create a bond of trust that can be easily broken, leading to feelings of betrayal." This highlights the importance of understanding 'social contracts' in interpersonal relationships. When individuals make verbal agreements, they often feel a sense of obligation to uphold them, which can lead to conflict if one party decides to break the agreement, as seen in the situation with the flatmate. Dr. Ian Kerner, a sex therapist, adds, "Open communication about expectations and feelings is essential to navigate these challenges." Understanding this dynamic can help both parties communicate their feelings more openly and find a resolution that respects both their needs and relationship.

Comment from u/Whorible_wife69

Comment from u/Paul-Kersey

Communication Strategies for Conflict Resolution

Research indicates that effective communication can significantly ease tensions in relationships. A study by Dr. John Gottman, a renowned psychologist, shows that using 'I' statements rather than 'you' accusations leads to more constructive conversations. For instance, saying "I feel worried about the future of our living situation" instead of "You're being selfish" can foster understanding.

Moreover, practicing active listening, where one paraphrases and reflects back what the other has said, can build empathy and reduce defensiveness, enhancing the dialogue about moving in with a partner.

Comment from u/Areebob

Comment from u/Individual_Ad_9213

Psychological research highlights that transitions, like moving in with a partner, can trigger various emotions, including anxiety and guilt. Dr. Susan Silk, a psychologist, suggests that these feelings can stem from conflicting loyalties, particularly in close friendships.

Understanding the psychological impact of these transitions can help the individual process their feelings more effectively. By acknowledging the emotional complexity, they can better navigate the disagreement with their flatmate, ultimately leading to a more amicable resolution.

Comment from u/Astatine360

Comment from u/Donutsmell

The Importance of Emotional Intelligence

Emotional intelligence (EI) plays a crucial role in managing interpersonal conflicts. Research by Dr. Daniel Goleman emphasizes that those with higher EI can recognize and manage their emotions as well as empathize with others. This capacity is vital in situations where verbal agreements are involved, as it allows individuals to understand the emotional ramifications of their decisions.

Practicing mindfulness techniques, such as meditation, can enhance EI. By becoming more aware of their own feelings and those of others, individuals can approach sensitive situations with greater compassion and understanding.

Comment from u/Traditional-Sky-2547

Comment from u/DaneDenz3311

According to a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, social support is essential during life transitions. When individuals feel supported by friends or family, they experience less stress and more positive outcomes in their decisions. This support can be especially important when making a significant life change, like moving in with a partner.

Building a support network can help individuals navigate these transitions more smoothly. Engaging in open dialogues about feelings and expectations can foster understanding and mitigate potential conflicts with flatmates.

Comment from u/Casual_Lore

Comment from u/Dummyact321

Addressing Feelings of Guilt

Feelings of guilt often arise when breaking commitments, as seen in this situation. Research by Dr. Brené Brown illustrates that guilt can serve as a signal for reflection and personal growth. Instead of wallowing in guilt, individuals can use it as an opportunity to reassess their priorities and values.

Practicing self-compassion, as suggested by Dr. Kristin Neff, can help individuals manage these feelings. Techniques such as journaling about one's feelings or discussing them with a trusted friend can also promote emotional clarity and resolution.

Comment from u/Thick_Place2105

Comment from u/Hefty_Hippo5385

What are your thoughts on this situation? Share your perspective in the comments below.

Comment from u/your-mom04605

Comment from u/Human-Obligation3621

Professional Assessment & Guidance

Conflict in relationships, particularly regarding verbal agreements, can be intricate but manageable with the right tools. Studies show that employing effective communication strategies, fostering emotional intelligence, and building a supportive network can significantly improve how individuals navigate such transitions. Open dialogues and mutual understanding are vital in addressing feelings of guilt and anxiety associated with breaking commitments.

Incorporating these evidence-based strategies can help mitigate conflict and promote healthier relationships. Ultimately, acknowledging the emotional complexities involved allows individuals to approach their decisions more thoughtfully, benefiting all parties involved.

Comment from u/GnomieOk4136

Comment from u/Less_Instruction_345

Comment from u/SummitJunkie7

Comment from u/Sue323464

Comment from u/Spare_Ad5009

Comment from u/OhmsWay-71

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights a common tension between personal growth and maintaining commitments. The flatmate's reaction likely stems from fear of loss and insecurity, as moving in with a partner can trigger feelings of abandonment. On the other hand, the person wanting to move is trying to prioritize their relationship, which is a natural and healthy motivation, showing the need for balance between self-advocacy and empathy in friendships.

Analysis generated by AI