Am I Wrong for Having Different Expectations for My Working Daughters?

A dad is getting hit with a very specific kind of family drama: he and his wife help their older daughter, Maya, a lot because she’s working brutal hours, but they expect their younger daughter, Eva, to handle her own stuff because she’s only working part-time.

On paper, it sounds fair. Maya is pulling 50-hour weeks, sometimes doing 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. shifts, teaching ballet and music, and even sleeping at her nanny job when the schedule stacks up. Eva, fresh out of nursing school, works 20 hours a week from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m., then heads home, and she’s even considering switching to cosmetology. But the moment laundry and pet care become “who does what,” the dad says Eva pushes back hard, like it’s all the same deal for both sisters.

And then there’s today’s reminder about the dryer, which is when the whole simmering resentment finally boiled over.

Original Post

I have two daughters, Maya (27) and Eva (23). Maya has earned associate degrees in child development, music education, and psychology, and she takes classes part-time in special education and school administration to obtain additional certifications.

Eva completed nursing school a few months ago. They both live at home to save money.

Maya works a minimum of 50 hours a week. She’s a nanny to a single mom who works as a nurse, so one week she works from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. three days a week, and the next week she does the same hours four days a week.

She also teaches ballet and music classes at a couple of local schools. When she works back-to-back shifts at her nanny job, she tends to sleep there so she doesn’t have to leave the house by 5:30 a.m.

Eva is burnt out from nursing school, so she only works 20 hours a week at a clinic. She works from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. and then goes home.

She’s considering quitting altogether and going back to school for cosmetology. Since Maya works so much, if she starts a load of laundry before work, my wife and I have no problem transferring it to the dryer and folding it for her.

Since Eva only works part-time, she’s expected to be responsible for her own laundry. Another difference in expectations is with pet care.

Maya is not expected to walk or feed the dogs (a chihuahua mix and what my kids call “the mutt of all mutts”) and the cat. Eva is expected to do so three days a week (Eva is also the one who asked for one of the dogs and the cat).

We also tend to do more favors for Maya (dropping off a meal at her work, picking up things for her, or making her a simple meal), especially on the days she comes home from a 15-hour shift and the day she returns from back-to-back shifts. Today we reminded Eva to take her clothes out of the dryer before she goes out (she has a habit of starting the washing machine and dryer before going out with friends for hours overnight), and she said that we do Maya’s laundry, so we shouldn’t have a problem doing hers too.

I told her it’s very different doing it for her sister, who works 15 hours a day, than doing it for her when she’s just going out with friends. Now she’s upset about favoritism because Maya doesn’t take care of the pets or pay her car insurance (she uses her car for work, so her boss covers her insurance).

My wife has always had a habit of giving in to her, so now she’s saying we should be harder on Maya because if Eva can handle these responsibilities, so can she. I still think it’s understandable to help the daughter who is working 15 hours a day, plus a 20-30 minute commute, but I don’t feel that the one who works 20 hours a week needs the same level of help.

Different expectations can stem from the unique strengths and weaknesses of each child.

Comment from u/Severe-Cow-2816

Comment from u/Available_Ad_4504

Comment from u/SnooRegrets7484

Right away, you can see why Maya gets the extra help, since she’s coming home after 15-hour days or back-to-back shifts and her laundry is basically a logistics problem at that point.

Differences in workload between Maya and Eva may lead to perceived favoritism, which can strain their relationship.

Comment from u/Jazilc

Comment from u/thecarpetbug

Comment from u/Cerridwen1981

The discussion surrounding the differing expectations for Maya and Eva reveals deeper insights into the impact of career-related stress and burnout on mental health. Eva's thoughts about shifting her career path serve as a poignant reminder that mental well-being should take precedence over conventional definitions of success. This situation underscores the necessity for parents to foster an environment where their children feel empowered to prioritize their mental health. By encouraging open dialogues about interests and passions, parents can help create a supportive atmosphere that values well-being as much as professional achievements. The family dynamic at play illustrates how crucial it is for parents to recognize the individual needs of their daughters, rather than imposing a one-size-fits-all expectation.

Comment from u/Rushzilla

Comment from u/binxie_

Comment from u/West_House_2085

Meanwhile Eva is treating the same house rules like they should magically bend, especially after she’s admitted she starts the washer and dryer before going out overnight.

This is similar to the woman who refused to change Super Bowl programming on community TV after her mom demanded YouTube for her toddler.

In this case, parents may unintentionally place financial burdens on their working daughter, Maya, leading to feelings of resentment from Eva.

To alleviate potential financial stress, families could establish transparent communication about finances, sharing expectations around contributions and support. This approach fosters mutual respect and understanding, allowing both daughters to navigate their choices without feeling undue pressure.

Comment from u/EvaSirkowski

Comment from u/PuzzleheadedPitch420

Comment from u/whittydee

Balancing Support and Independence

By nurturing independence, parents can help both daughters cultivate resilience and self-reliance. Implementing regular family meetings to discuss aspirations and challenges can create a supportive environment where each child feels empowered to pursue their goals.

Comment from u/QuestionMaker207

Comment from u/Awkward_Un1corn

Comment from u/LegalEssay6963

The discussion surrounding different expectations for Maya and Eva highlights a broader trend in how young adults navigate their career paths. Eva's yearning for a more meaningful work experience is indicative of many young professionals today who seek fulfillment over mere financial stability. This desire for change suggests a deeper need for personal growth and satisfaction in their chosen fields.

By encouraging Eva to pursue internships or volunteer opportunities, parents can play a crucial role in her career development. This strategy not only helps Eva clarify her aspirations but also fosters a supportive environment that mitigates sibling rivalry. In a family dynamic where expectations differ based on workload, promoting individual exploration can enhance both daughters' journeys and strengthen their relationship.

Comment from u/BeginningBit6645

Comment from u/BusydaydreamerA137

Comment from u/Material-Solution748

So when the dad and his wife reminded Eva to take her clothes out of the dryer before heading out, her response was basically, “You do Maya’s laundry, so why not mine too?”

Creating Equitable Family Dynamics

To create a supportive environment, parents should communicate openly about their expectations and actively listen to their daughters' concerns. Implementing family check-ins can facilitate ongoing discussions about each child’s needs and aspirations, fostering a sense of belonging and equality within the family.

Comment from u/CookieLovesChoc

Comment from u/Spirited-kiwi-98

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

This situation underscores the intricate balance between fairness and practicality in family dynamics. The differing expectations set for Maya and Eva reflect a common challenge parents face when navigating individual circumstances. Maya's demanding work schedule contrasts sharply with Eva's lighter responsibilities, which can easily create perceptions of favoritism or resentment. It is essential for the family to cultivate open communication regarding their feelings and responsibilities. By doing so, they can ensure that both daughters feel valued and understood, regardless of their differing workloads.

The differences in their workloads and responsibilities highlight a fundamental challenge in maintaining balance within familial relationships. When one daughter works over 50 hours a week while the other does not, it is crucial for parents to recognize the unique paths each child is navigating.

Engaging in regular family discussions about aspirations and responsibilities could serve as a pathway to fostering understanding and support. This approach not only promotes individual growth for Maya and Eva but also strengthens their relationships. By creating a space for open dialogue, the family can address the potential feelings of unfairness and ensure that both daughters feel valued and understood, ultimately contributing to a healthier family dynamic.

The dryer wasn’t the real issue, it was the fact that Eva wants the same privileges Maya earns through 50-hour weeks.

If you think your daughters’ expectations are tense, wait until you see what a woman refused to tip after bad service, then got called out by friends.