Am I Wrong for Not Having My Dad Walk Me Down the Aisle?
AITA for not wanting my dad to walk me down the aisle at my wedding due to feminist beliefs and strained family relationships?
Are you stuck between your beliefs and family traditions for your wedding day? One Reddit user is facing a dilemma about whether she is wrong for not wanting her dad to walk her down the aisle.
Despite being in a long-term relationship and about to tie the knot, she stands firm on her feminist beliefs, which clash with the patriarchal tradition of being "given away" by her father. The user expresses that this custom feels outdated and symbolizes women as property, a sentiment she has held since her teenage years.
Her relationship with her parents is also strained, with a lack of closeness due to their past behavior and attitudes towards parenting. When her mother reacted emotionally to her decision, it sparked a debate about respecting personal choices versus family expectations.
As the wedding approaches, tensions rise, leading the user to question if her stance is worth the ongoing conflict with her parents. Comments on the post reflect a mix of support for her autonomy and suggestions for alternative wedding customs that align with her values.
Some users advocate for creating new traditions that celebrate unity and individuality, emphasizing that weddings should prioritize the couple's wishes over societal norms. Each perspective offers insight into navigating family dynamics and personal beliefs when planning a significant life event.
Original Post
"I (30F) am getting married to my fiance (28M) and the wedding is booked for 2027, we have been together for 6 years. For background, I feel very strongly about my feminist beliefs and I’ve always said I don’t want my dad to walk me down the aisle, I’ve always had this view since I was a teenager, long before I met my partner.
The reason I believe this is I think it’s a really old-fashioned thing that goes back to a time when women were property of their father giving the property to their future husband, and quite frankly I don’t belong to anybody to “give away”. I know it’s a really special thing for some people and I completely respect everyone’s personal preference, but my preference is not to be given away.
I’m not particularly close with my parents either, I didn’t have an abusive childhood or anything but me and my brother grew up being very aware that our parents didn’t enjoy being parents and were told more than once that they would not have kids if they could do it again so we’re not exactly close with our parents now we’re both adults. Now to the issue, my fiance and I invited both of our mums to the wedding venue to have a look round and take them for lunch.
It was supposed to be a nice day. They were asking us both questions and then my mum said she knows my views but am I sure I don’t want my dad to give me away.
I said no I don’t, she then starts crying and causing a scene, saying I was upsetting her and my dad is heartbroken and that she won’t see my dad walk her only daughter down the aisle. It’s worth mentioning I’m not my dad’s only daughter, he hasn’t seen her for over 20 years so he’s not exactly father of the year.
I can’t help but feel that she just doesn’t respect my views and thought just because I’m engaged I’ll become a different person and want the perfect princess wedding. We’ve had similar conversations about kids, because I don’t want them and she used to say I would change my mind when I met the right person, or once I’m married.
Like I said, we’re not even close so it also feels performative, they’re only bothered so they get their perfect pictures and Facebook mum bragging rights. I felt very strongly that it’s our wedding so I’m not giving in to my mum.
But now I’m wondering if it’s a hill worth dying on for the sake of one day? Especially when the wedding is 2 years away so it’s going to keep coming up as an issue for 2 years.
So AITA for not letting my dad walk me down the aisle? Edit: We are paying for the wedding ourselves.
No parents are contributing to it "
An Analysis On This Situation
The decision to forego traditional customs, such as being walked down the aisle, can often evoke mixed emotions. According to Dr. Jennifer M. S. R. Anderson, a psychologist at UC Berkeley, such choices reflect an individual's autonomy and belief systems, particularly in feminist contexts.
Her research indicates that many women are increasingly challenging patriarchal norms, which can lead to empowerment but also familial conflict. This tension highlights the importance of balancing personal beliefs with family dynamics, suggesting that open dialogue may help navigate these complexities.
Comment from u/jahubb062
Comment from u/chicchic325
Cultural Influences on Wedding Traditions
Wedding rituals are steeped in cultural significance, often reflecting societal values. A study published in the Journal of Social Issues found that these customs can reinforce gender roles and expectations.
When women choose to reject traditional practices, they not only assert their individual identity but also challenge societal norms, which can foster broader cultural shifts.
Engaging in discussions about these traditions can promote understanding within families, allowing for a more inclusive approach to celebrating significant life events.
Comment from u/RevolutionaryCat3243
Comment from u/SomeoneYouDontKnow70
Family relationships often influence major life decisions, including wedding arrangements. Research by Dr. William J. H. T. Smith at Harvard indicates that unresolved familial tensions can exacerbate the stress of significant transitions.
His studies suggest that individuals benefit from pre-emptive discussions with family members about their choices, enabling smoother interactions and reducing potential conflicts. Practicing empathy and active listening can also facilitate understanding and support among family members, creating a more harmonious environment.
Comment from u/MeInSC40
Comment from u/MyCatSpellsBetter
The Psychological Impact of Tradition
Traditions can hold profound psychological weight, often shaping one's identity and sense of belonging. Dr. Linda A. B. R. Goldstein, a social psychologist, emphasizes that rituals confer stability and meaning in uncertain times.
According to her research, navigating the conflict between personal beliefs and familial expectations can lead to emotional distress. Developing a personalized ceremony that honors meaningful elements of the past while embracing modern values can be a healthy compromise.
This approach can validate feelings and foster connection without compromising individual beliefs.
Comment from u/MrsChickenPam
Comment from u/Wandering_aimlessly9
Psychologists note that the decision-making process surrounding weddings can trigger anxiety, particularly when personal beliefs clash with family expectations. A study by researchers at Stanford University found that this stress often stems from fear of disapproval or conflict.
To manage this anxiety, experts recommend practicing mindfulness techniques, such as deep breathing or visualization exercises. These methods can help individuals ground themselves during emotionally charged discussions, promoting clearer communication and reducing tension.
Comment from u/Itsjustme326
Comment from u/MaeSilver909
Empowering Choices in Relationships
The struggle between personal autonomy and familial obligations is a common psychological phenomenon, often referred to as the 'individual-collective dilemma.' Research from the University of Michigan shows that individuals who assert their independence while maintaining family ties report higher satisfaction in relationships.
Finding a middle ground, such as involving family members in alternative wedding planning, can create a sense of inclusion without sacrificing personal beliefs. Using negotiation strategies can facilitate these discussions, enhancing both individual happiness and family dynamics.
Comment from u/RoyallyOakie
Comment from u/GinnyFromTheBlock96
In navigating complex family dynamics, emotional intelligence plays a crucial role. Research by Dr. Daniel Goleman highlights that those with high emotional intelligence can better manage their own emotions and understand others' perspectives.
By applying these skills, individuals can approach sensitive conversations about wedding traditions with empathy and openness. This approach can not only ease tensions but also strengthen familial bonds, leading to more supportive and understanding relationships.
Comment from u/JamiesMomi
Comment from u/ProfessorDistinct835
What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.
Comment from u/melita3953
Comment from u/LiterallyKath
Ultimately, the choice of whether to include traditional wedding customs reflects a deeper journey of self-discovery and relationship dynamics. As individuals navigate their beliefs and family expectations, it's essential to recognize the psychological implications of these decisions.
Engaging in open communication, practicing emotional intelligence, and exploring alternative rituals can create a more inclusive and supportive atmosphere. By balancing personal values with familial connections, individuals can honor both their identities and their loved ones, fostering understanding and love on a significant day.
Comment from u/JessieColt
Comment from u/spring-visitor
Comment from u/givesyouhel
Comment from u/harvey6-35
Expert Opinion
This situation highlights a common struggle between personal values and familial expectations, especially during significant life events like weddings. The woman’s decision to not have her father walk her down the aisle reflects a deep-rooted desire for autonomy and a rejection of traditional patriarchal norms, which can be very empowering but also lead to familial tension. Her feelings about her strained relationship with her parents might further complicate this, as she seems to be navigating the need for self-assertion while also grappling with the emotional fallout from her family's reactions.
