Avoiding Religious Ceremony by Pretending to Have Periods: AITA?

A 28-year-old woman just wanted to skip a massive Hindu ceremony, but her in-laws treated her “No” like it was optional. Since she is an agnostic atheist and an introvert, the whole thing sounds like a nightmare: heavy sarees, crowded spaces, and forced small talk with people she does not even know.

Here’s where it gets messy. Her devout MIL has a history of making her do the labor during these events, sweeping, mopping, and dishwashing, even when she offered to pay for help. And this year, her MIL and FIL allegedly pushed her father into pressuring her to attend, even though last year they could not go because they were living three hours away.

So when her father kept pushing, she did the one thing she knew would shut it down, she claimed she had her period.

Original Post

My parents and my in-laws are devout Hindus however I on the other hand am an agnostic atheist and I am an introvert too. I don’t believe in performing religious ceremonies.

My body and mind gets extremely uncomfortable in situations like big Poojas where i have to literally wear in heavy sarees and be in the middle of a crowded places saying unnecessary hi hello to people i don’t even know. And above all that, my in laws have the tendency to make these events extremely large and beyond something that they can control.

My MIL doesn’t even lift a finger to work and in the past in the similar events have made me work like a maid. I had to do everything from literally sweeping mopping to dishwashing just because they didn’t want to help or hire a helper even when i suggested i would pay to hire one.

We couldn’t go last year because we were staying three hours away but this year we got recently transferred and had to move a bit closer to my MIL due to work reasons temporarily and my cunning MIL and FIL manipulated my own father to push me into going . My MIL technically doesn’t like me much because I am childfree by choice (which my husband is also strictly) and not very religious. She even called my husband day before yesterday and wanted to talk to me and was scolding him.

They were expecting that I would want to work for the religious ceremony. Thankfully my husband asked them to stop expecting from us and carry on with their own events.

But since they now manipulated my father to push me to go and ever since I lied that I have my periods my father is angry. But, I knew saying No wouldn’t work so I lied that I had my periods .

Because I tried saying no in previous years and it never worked. Am I A*****e in this whole situation?

Family dynamics often involve complex power structures influenced by cultural traditions. Cultural expectations can create significant internal conflict, particularly in families with strong religious affiliations.

Individuals may feel torn between their own beliefs and the expectations of their family, leading to feelings of guilt and frustration. This can result in behaviors like avoidance or deception to maintain personal comfort.

Comment from u/jensmith20055002

Comment from u/Latex-Siren

Comment from u/Right-Practice3910

That’s when her comfort level, which was already low during big poojas, got crushed by the reality that her MIL expected her to work like a maid again.

Establishing boundaries and sharing one’s feelings can help family members understand each other's perspectives.

Comment from u/Middle_Web_7289

Comment from u/HottterThanU

Comment from u/GrannyTurtle

Religious practices often serve as a cornerstone for identity in many families. These practices can create a strong sense of belonging.

However, for those who feel disconnected, like the Reddit user, it can lead to feelings of alienation. Balancing personal beliefs with familial expectations requires navigating these emotional landscapes thoughtfully.

Comment from u/ReadMeDrMemory

Comment from u/scary-the_bear

Comment from u/DryRecommendation795

After her husband shut down their “expectations,” her in-laws pivoted fast, pulling her father into the pressure campaign to get her to show up.

This is similar to a mom who threw away her own medication, then acted like she “didn’t need” it.

Psychologists highlight the importance of understanding one's own values in the context of family expectations.

Comment from u/M312345

Comment from u/Irish_lady_Sheanan

Comment from u/ifitsmeanttobe

Then the night before, MIL wanted a talk, and the next day her father was angry because OP had lied that she had her periods to avoid the ceremony.

Coping Strategies for Discomfort

Developing coping strategies can help individuals manage discomfort in high-pressure situations like family religious events.

Comment from u/Eucalyptusthoughts

Comment from u/AdelleDeWitt

Comment from u/Aladdin_Caine

Emotional intelligence plays a crucial role in how individuals navigate familial expectations.

Comment from u/xpoisonvalkyrie

Comment from u/Critical-Champion365

Comment from u/lamplightas

Now everyone is stuck in the fallout, with OP wondering if dodging a ceremony by pretending was actually an a-hole move or just self-defense against being cornered.

Negotiating Religious Participation

Instead of outright refusal, presenting alternatives such as attending certain parts of a ceremony can serve as a compromise.

This approach allows individuals to honor their beliefs while still engaging with family traditions, thereby reducing tension and fostering a more inclusive family atmosphere.

Comment from u/xError404xx

Comment from u/Pleasant_Expert2258

How would you handle this situation? Let us know in the comments.

This situation sheds light on the often painful conflict between personal beliefs and familial expectations, particularly within a religious framework. The user's decision to fabricate a reason to avoid participation in her in-laws' religious ceremonies illustrates her struggle for autonomy in a setting that feels suffocating. This act of deception is not merely a lie; it symbolizes her attempt to navigate a web of expectations that clash with her own values. When individuals find themselves caught between their own identities and the pressures imposed by family traditions, they may resort to avoidance strategies as a means of self-preservation. This story serves as a poignant reminder of the lengths some may go to in order to reclaim control over their lives in the face of overwhelming external demands.

Navigating the complexities of family expectations, particularly within a religious framework, can indeed be a formidable challenge, as illustrated in this Reddit thread. The user’s experience reflects the tension many feel when their personal beliefs starkly contrast with those of their devout family members. The struggle to maintain one’s identity while addressing familial obligations is evident. By employing open dialogues and negotiating terms of participation in religious practices, families can work towards a more harmonious understanding. This approach emphasizes that mutual respect and empathy are crucial in reconciling personal convictions with the expectations set by family traditions.

Claiming a period might be petty, but nobody wants to be drafted into someone else’s religious event as free labor.

Want another brutal family betrayal, read about a dad who swindled his Redditor out of mom’s will, then played victim.