Mother Who’s Jealous of Her Daughter’s Good Finances Directs Her Sons to Ask Money from Her, Causing Big Family Dispute

Family relations are never simple. There is just too much love, connection, resentment, disappointment… you name the feeling, you can find it in any family.

And it is completely natural and understandable. You can’t live with someone for so long and be perfectly content with everything.

On the other hand, you can’t live with someone for so long and keep in close touch after moving out if you don’t love them. Every family has its little disputes, and it is usually up to the parents (yes, even when the kids are adults) to try to smooth things over and tone things down.

However, this is not always the case. Some parents can make things even worse and create a problem where there was none.

We have one of those stories today. One Redditor posted a question: “AITA for telling my kids to borrow money from their sister, not me?”

Our OP has four kids: “Carmen and Michael are both lower middle class. Carmen is a single mom of two and works as a nurse. Michael and his wife are teachers and are expecting their first child. Carmen makes $100k; Michael and his wife make a little over $100k combined, and we live in California near the Bay Area, where $100k is considered low income.”

But one of her daughters, Elisa, is a nanny for an extremely wealthy family: “She makes $250k per year plus bonuses, doesn't pay for rent or utilities, rarely buys groceries because she always eats with the family. They bought her a brand new car, they pay for her gas and maintenance, and all of her medical, dental, and vision expenses are 100% covered by the family.

Heck, they even pay for her gym membership and her vacations. She's worked for them for two years now and recently bought a rental building in cash. Needless to say, she's doing very well for herself.”

OP's sons asked her for money, and she told them to ask their sister. This caused a family dispute:

OP asks:

Reddit

She has four adult children, most of whom are lower middle class.

Reddit

However, one of her daughters has very solid finances.

Reddit

Family Dynamics and Financial Expectations

Family financial dynamics can be quite complex, often influenced by underlying emotions and expectations.

Dr. Karen Fingerman from the University of Texas highlights that financial decisions within families often reflect deeper relational patterns, including feelings of control and security.

This means that financial requests can be perceived as threats, leading to conflict when expectations are not aligned.

She works as a nanny for a very wealthy family, and she even bought a rental building.

Reddit

OP's sons asked her for money, $30K and $10K. OP responded that their sister is the person to ask and that she could "easily help them out."

Reddit

Her daughter called her to ask what's going on and why her brothers are asking her for money.

Reddit

The mother's jealousy towards her daughter's financial success may indicate deeper insecurities regarding her own self-worth and value.

Research shows that feelings of inadequacy can lead to overreaching behavior, where individuals project their fears onto family members, leading to conflict.

Encouraging open discussions about finances and aspirations can help alleviate these tensions and foster a more supportive atmosphere.

OP is quite a piece of work. She then tries to rearrange her daughter's Christmas bonus spending. Now she wants to know if she is wrong here.

Reddit

Redditors were furious:

Reddit

Working with wealthy people is exhausting, especially with their kids.

Reddit

The Role of Communication in Managing Conflict

Effective communication is crucial in navigating family conflicts related to financial matters.

Studies indicate that families who engage in open dialogue about finances can reduce misunderstandings and foster collaboration.

Creating an environment where family members feel comfortable discussing their financial goals can help align expectations and reduce tension.

Yes, OP would certainly like to handle her daughter's money.

Reddit

Yes, this is interesting:

Reddit

OP is playing some kind of game here.

Reddit

Implementing regular family meetings to discuss financial matters can provide a structured approach to addressing any concerns or conflicts.

Encouraging participation from all family members can help everyone feel valued and heard, reducing feelings of resentment.

Consider establishing a financial goal together as a family, creating a shared sense of purpose and collaboration.

The fact that her sons asked her for money means that they believe she has it.

Reddit

This is also a valid point.

Reddit

The bottom line is:

Reddit

The bottom line is, “You don't have to lend money, but you shouldn't volunteer someone else.” It is quite obvious that OP is jealous of her daughter’s money.

She probably hates hearing her daughter speak about the money she makes and not being able to influence how it is spent. So, this was her attempt.

And it backfired. But the problem is that OP won’t suffer the consequences—her children will.

Psychological Analysis

This situation reveals the complexities of family dynamics when it comes to financial expectations and feelings of jealousy.

Parents often struggle with their children's successes, leading to conflict rather than support.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

These insights emphasize the importance of understanding emotional dynamics in family financial discussions.

As noted by Dr. William Doherty, family therapist, "Effective communication about finances can prevent misunderstandings and foster stronger family relationships." Furthermore, Michelle Singletary, financial columnist, states, "Being open about money matters can help families navigate conflicts and build trust." These perspectives highlight how emotional awareness and dialogue can mitigate conflicts and strengthen family bonds.