Brother Gifts Baby Chickens: AITA for Billing Him for Coop?

In a world where surprises can either bring joy or create unexpected dilemmas, one Redditor finds himself in a peculiar predicament with his brother. The original poster (OP), a 26-year-old man living in the suburbs, was shocked when his 28-year-old brother, Josh, gifted him four baby chickens without any prior warning.

While the gesture was undoubtedly thoughtful, it left OP grappling with the realities of poultry ownership, especially since he had no coop or supplies ready for their arrival. After spending an entire weekend building a coop to accommodate his new feathered friends, OP confronted a moral quandary.

On one hand, he appreciated Josh's intentions; on the other, he felt overwhelmed by the responsibilities that came with caring for live animals. When Josh came to visit and check on the chickens, OP handed him a bill for half the expenses incurred in building the coop, which led to a heated argument.

Josh felt blindsided and accused OP of taking advantage of his goodwill, while OP believed he was justified in seeking financial help for the unanticipated costs. Now, the community is left to weigh in on whether OP was in the wrong for accepting the chickens and subsequently billing his brother.

Is it fair to ask for help when a surprise gift turns into a burden, or does this situation reflect a deeper issue of communication between siblings? Dive into the comments to explore the nuances of this family conflict.

Original Post

I (26M) live in the suburbs with a small backyard where I grow veggies. Last week, my brother Josh (28M) drove across the state to 'gift' me four baby chickens without any warning.

I was taken aback as I had no coop or supplies for them. Nevertheless, I decided to build a coop over the weekend to provide a suitable shelter for the chickens.

It was no easy task, and I had to spend a good amount of time and money on materials. However, after completing the coop, I felt conflicted.

On one hand, I appreciated the gesture from Josh and understood his intentions behind the surprise gift. On the other hand, the responsibility that came with it was unexpected and quite burdensome.

So, when Josh came by to check on the chickens and the new coop, I casually mentioned that I had built it over the weekend and handed him a bill for half of the expenses, including materials and my time. Josh seemed taken aback and questioned my decision to bill him, stating that he had given me a thoughtful gift and didn't expect me to incur additional costs.

He argued that I should have communicated with him before proceeding with the coop construction. I tried to explain that while I appreciated the gesture, the practical aspects needed to be considered, especially since I wasn't prepared for livestock on my property.

Josh left in a huff, and now our interactions have been strained. He feels like I've taken advantage of his goodwill, while I believe I was justified in asking for a financial contribution towards the coop I built to accommodate the unexpected gift.

So, Reddit, I'm in a dilemma. AITA for accepting my brother's surprise gift of baby chickens and then billing him for half of the coop expenses?

Dr. Patricia McConnell, an animal behaviorist, emphasizes that welcoming new pets requires careful consideration and preparation. She notes that many people underestimate the responsibilities associated with poultry ownership, such as their dietary needs and housing requirements.

According to McConnell, establishing a safe and comfortable coop is vital for the health of the chickens and the owner's peace of mind. She suggests researching local ordinances and best practices before accepting such gifts to ensure a smooth transition into poultry parenting.

Comment from u/gamer_gal2000

Comment from u/CoffeeFreak88

Comment from u/jaded_reader

Experts in family dynamics, like Dr. John Gottman, emphasize the importance of open communication in maintaining healthy relationships. In situations where unexpected gifts, such as chickens, lead to financial strain, discussing feelings and expectations can prevent misunderstandings.

Gottman advises that setting boundaries and having clear conversations about responsibilities can enhance mutual respect. By addressing these topics early on, families can navigate the challenges of unexpected gifts with greater ease and understanding.

For more insights, visit Dr. John Gottman's website.

Comment from u/cats_and_coffee

Comment from u/pizza_lover57

Comment from u/MountainDewQueen

Animal welfare advocate Dr. John Bradshaw stresses that owning chickens can be rewarding, yet challenging. He highlights that many new chicken owners are unprepared for the long-term commitment involved in caring for their birds, which can live for several years.

Bradshaw suggests prospective owners create a detailed plan outlining costs, time commitments, and proper care practices, such as regular veterinary check-ups and appropriate housing. This proactive approach can help avoid tension between family members when unexpected gifts lead to shared responsibilities.

Comment from u/thebookworm89

Comment from u/SingingInTheRain

Comment from u/DanceDad42

Dr. Temple Grandin, a renowned animal behavior expert, points out that understanding animal behavior can significantly improve the human-animal relationship. She recommends spending time observing chickens to understand their needs and social behaviors, which can enhance the owner's experience.

Additionally, Grandin advises setting up a coop that mimics natural conditions to promote the chickens' well-being. This not only fosters a healthy environment for the chickens but also provides a fulfilling experience for the owner as they engage with their new pets.

Comment from u/AdventureTimeFan

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

In navigating unexpected gifts like chickens, open communication and preparation are key. Experts like Dr. McConnell and Dr. Gottman underline the importance of addressing responsibilities and expectations to avoid potential conflicts.

By creating a plan and understanding the needs of the new pets, family members can enjoy the rewards of poultry ownership while maintaining healthy relationships. Future interactions can be smoother through proactive discussions, ensuring that everyone feels valued and heard in the decision-making process.

Expert Opinion

This situation highlights how unexpected gifts can create unspoken expectations and responsibilities, leading to tension. The brother's gesture, while well-intentioned, lacked communication about the implications of poultry ownership, which often requires deeper planning than many anticipate.

This incident reflects a common pattern in relationships where assumptions take precedence over open dialogue, ultimately straining connections instead of strengthening them.