Conflict at Work: AITA for Taking PTO My Coworker Wanted?

In the fast-paced world of healthcare, teamwork is crucial, yet one Reddit user finds herself caught in a difficult situation involving a coworker’s unpredictable attendance. In her post, she outlines a series of frustrations stemming from her colleague's frequent last-minute absences, which force her to shoulder an overwhelming workload.

With the holiday season approaching, the tension escalates as her coworker, referred to as A, announces her intention to take two Mondays off, leaving our original poster (OP) with the dilemma of whether to use her own PTO on one of those days. The OP learns from her boss that A has not officially booked the first Monday off, which opens the door for her to take it instead.

This situation raises important questions about workplace ethics, personal boundaries, and the balance between compassion and self-care. Should she prioritize her own well-being and family time, or should she step aside and allow A to take the day off, despite her track record of calling in sick without notice?

As the thread unfolds, responses from the Reddit community range from strong encouragement to take the day off to cautioning against further complicating the workplace dynamic. This discussion invites us to reflect on the complexities of professional relationships, personal responsibility, and the nuances of workplace expectations.

What would you do in her situation?

Original Post

I (f) have been working at my job for the past 9 months. I work very closely with a coworker (also f, we’ll call her A) and if she is gone, I have to take over all of her patients as we work in healthcare.

At least one of us has to be at work during the week. Although regular hours plan for both of us to be there.

In the time that I have been there, this coworker has called in the day of at least 16 times (if not more). This is very difficult as our job moves very quickly and it creates double the work.

I understand that life happens and you get sick. Although I have proof of this coworker has lied about being sick or what she was doing at least a couple times.

In a recent incident, she had asked another coworker (M) to come into work to cover for her. M had told her that she could not.

This was a day before A was going to out of work. A told M that she would try to come into work that day but would probably be late.

Protocol for missing work at our job is to at least inform the people that you work closely with (me) and our boss. I was not informed that I would be working by myself until I was told my someone else that morning.

This means I had to replan my whole day. There have been many instances where I have to skip lunch and stay 1 1/2 to 2 hours overtime.

This is not normal for my job and you could get in trouble for it. Anyways, our doctor is going to be gone for two weeks around the holidays except for the Mondays.

My coworker has been saying that she is taking both of the Mondays off. This means that I cannot take them off.

After talking with my boss, she said that A did not take off the first Monday in the system and I could still take it off. I believe that A has not accrued enough PTO to put it in the schedule yet.

Days off are first come first serve. I know that this coworker is also going to visit family, but I don’t know what days.

I really want to take that Monday off because I never take off work and I want to spend time with family too. Should I retract the day and let A have it?

Or should I keep it and let her figure it out?

Workplace dynamics can often be complicated, especially in high-stress environments like healthcare. According to Dr. Michael Thompson, a noted child psychologist, absenteeism can lead to significant team strain and decreased morale.

He emphasizes that addressing such issues requires open communication. It’s essential for team members to discuss their needs and constraints openly and honestly. Setting boundaries and fostering a culture of accountability can help alleviate tensions and promote collaboration.

Comment from u/looneybinguard

Comment from u/apothekryptic

Comment from u/Izzybee543

Conflict resolution expert Dr. Carl Rogers reiterates the importance of empathy in resolving workplace disputes. He suggests that understanding the underlying issues behind a colleague's absenteeism can facilitate productive discussions.

By approaching the situation with compassion instead of judgment, colleagues may find common ground. This can help transform a competitive scenario into a collaborative one, fostering a supportive environment that can ultimately benefit everyone involved.

Comment from u/Puskarella

Comment from u/DogsNCoffeeAddict

Comment from u/WhiteGhost99

Setting clear expectations and boundaries can prevent misunderstandings in the workplace. David Allen, a productivity expert, advocates for creating transparent communication channels among team members.

He recommends regular check-ins to discuss workload and availability, which can help set realistic expectations. By fostering a culture of accountability and support, employees can better navigate their responsibilities and reduce friction, ensuring that everyone feels valued and balanced.

Comment from u/Naomeri

Comment from u/myst3ryAURORA_green

Comment from u/Ruebee90

Organizational psychologist Dr. Adam Grant emphasizes the importance of understanding individual motivations in workplace dynamics. He notes that recognizing the reasons behind a coworker’s absenteeism can help in addressing the root causes.

Employers should consider that personal challenges may be influencing work patterns. Offering flexible work arrangements or support can foster loyalty and improve overall team performance. Creating an environment where employees feel comfortable discussing their struggles can lead to more effective solutions.

Comment from u/lifeinwentworth

Comment from u/Dry_Custard_3255

Comment from u/Epic-Gamer_09

When faced with a colleague's erratic attendance, it’s crucial to address the issue directly. Dr. Tina Payne Bryson, a child development expert, suggests that fostering open dialogue can prevent resentment from building.

She advocates for the 'nonviolent communication' approach, where individuals express their feelings without blame. This can help in collaboratively finding a resolution that respects both parties’ needs while promoting a healthier workplace culture.

Comment from u/fuckyou04

Comment from u/KnittinKityn

Comment from u/Remarkable-Cry7123

In conflict situations, it’s essential to focus on solutions rather than blame. Gretchen Rubin, a happiness researcher, advocates for positive communication strategies.

She suggests framing discussions around shared goals instead of personal grievances. This shift in focus can transform the conversation from confrontational to collaborative, ultimately leading to more constructive outcomes. Engaging in active listening and validating concerns can help build trust and understanding within the team.

Comment from u/JosieGenX

Comment from u/littlesis7

Comment from u/No-BSing-Here

Understanding workplace absenteeism is complex. Dr. Leana Wen, a public health expert, emphasizes that stress and burnout can significantly impact attendance.

Encouraging mental health days and promoting a culture that prioritizes employee well-being can help mitigate these issues. Organizations should also provide access to counseling or support services to address any underlying mental health conditions, ultimately fostering a healthier work environment.

Comment from u/annedroiid

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

Expert Opinion

In this scenario, the tension between the two coworkers highlights a common workplace dynamic where feelings of resentment and unfairness can arise. The original poster is caught between self-preservation and compassion, illustrating the psychological concept of boundary-setting—important for maintaining one's well-being. Ultimately, the decision reflects deeper motivations about responsibility, fairness, and the need for recognition, which can be crucial in shaping workplace relationships.

Analysis & Recommendations

In navigating workplace conflicts, especially concerning absenteeism, fostering an environment of open communication and empathy is vital. Experts like Dr. Adam Grant and Dr. Carl Rogers advocate for addressing underlying issues through understanding and collaboration. By implementing structured communication strategies and promoting mental well-being, organizations can create supportive environments that enhance teamwork and productivity. Ultimately, prioritizing mental health and encouraging accountability can lead to a more harmonious workplace, benefiting both employees and the overall organization.