Confronting Parents About Siblings' Wedding Exclusion: Am I The Jerk Or Just Honest?

Are you ready for some family drama that sounds straight out of a soap opera? In this gripping Reddit post, a user seeks advice on whether they are in the wrong for calling out their parents on their favoritism towards their brother.

The story unfolds with vivid details about a family dynamic filled with entitlement, bullying, and a long-overdue confrontation. The post delves into the backstory of a golden child brother, Mike, who has been coddled and excused for his behavior by their parents, turning him into an entitled bully.

The user recounts how their sister, Kelly, bore the brunt of Mike's bullying for years, leading her to distance herself from the family. With Kelly's wedding on the horizon, tensions escalate when she decides not to invite Mike, sparking a showdown with their parents.

The user bravely confronts their parents about their failures in parenting, leading to a heated argument and rift within the family. As the narrative unfolds, fellow Redditors weigh in with their judgments and advice, painting a picture of a family on the brink of collapse due to years of unchecked favoritism and toxicity.

From calling out parental neglect to supporting a sister's journey to happiness, this Reddit thread is a rollercoaster of emotions, revelations, and tough love. So, buckle up and dive into the comments section to dissect this family saga and share your thoughts on who's in the right and who's in the wrong.

Original Post

This is a throwaway as my brother is on reddit and I dont want him knowing my real account name. So, my 37f, brother Mike 35m, is a knob.

Always has been and always will be. He has been babied to the point of uselessness by our mum and dad and that's made him an entitled slob.

When he was younger he showed promis playing Rugby which had my mum and dad believing he was gonna be a superstar. The problem was though that he never had the work ethic to fully fulfill his potential.

However this meant that he was the golden boy of the family and he could do wrong in my parents eyes. He was a bully at school, which they brushed off as other kids making up lies, but he was an even bigger bully at home to our younger sister Kelly 31f.

He would constantly 'prank' here. Which basically meant he would do anything he could embarrass her, including things like pulling her dress up infront of the whole family at a wedding when she was 15.

Mum and dad just said it was siblings being siblings, but the rest of the family were mortified by his behaviour. I did try and stick up for my sister and it worked to a certain extent, but after I went to away to Uni, there wasn't much I could do as mum and dad just dont listen to anyone.

It got so bad that when she was 18, my sister gave up going to her dream University, St Andrews and instead moved to London to go to the Imperial College London. This was a huge shock to all of us as she had been talking about St Andrews since she started high school at 11.

When i asked why, she said that St Andrews was too close to home and she would be expected to go back home more often, but if she went to London she would only have to go home for Christmas. This broke my heart.

After she left, she did exactly that, the only time she was home was Christmas and when I got married. This really annoyed mum and dad as they said she was abandoning the family.

I kept my mouth shut and just let them whine occasionally as I didn't want an argument. After graduating from Uni my parents expected her to move back home, but she didn't.

She got a job working in southern England and stayed down there. We are from Scotland for reference.

Six years ago, Kelly met a great guy, Jake 30m. The day she met him she called me gushing about him and I've honestly never heard her speak about anyone the way she does him.

I've met him several times when I've gone down to visit Kelly and he's great. Good looking, funny, great job, his family are lovely and most importantly, he treats Kelly like she hung the moon.

Its very cute. After she met him, she cut down how much she came home even more as she spent the first Christmas with his family and then the pandemic happened so she ended up not coming home for 3 years.

Her first Christmas home Mike started his usual bullshit, trying to be there center of attention. When it didn't work out as well as he wanted, as most of the family were more interested in getting to know Jake, he then tried to 'prank' Kelly.

He got a big bowl of water and was going to pour it over her. Jake saw what was happening and stepped infront of Kelly telling Mike to not even think about it.

Side note, Jake is 6ft 3 and a has been doing martial arts since he was 4, so he can be very intimidating when needed. Mum and dad tried to play it off as a harmless prank, but Jake was having none of it.

Mike started whining about it just being a prank and Jake told him that if he 'pranked' Kelly one more time, he would 'prank' Jake by putting his foot up his a**e and his fist down his throat. Kelly and Jake left about an hour later, but after that Mike, mum and dad all had an issue with Jake.

Kelly hasn't been back home since. That leads us to now, Kelly and Jake are getting married.

They sent out invites in February for August. However, they didn't invite Mike.

Mum and dad are obviously incensed by this and had a huge argument with Kelly. They threatened not to go, and Kelly just said no problem she would get grandad to walk her down the aisle.

I went around to their house on Saturday with my kids. Immediately my mum started complaining about Kelly and the wedding.

I sat and listened for a while before I'd had enough. I asked her what did she actually expect?

Her and dad have allowed Mike to be the golden child and get away with everything. Because of that, he can't keep a relationship, due to him thinking everyone should do everything for him, he can't hold down a job because every job is beneath him and he still living at home with zero prospects in life.

The man-child is a bully who I dont trust to be around my children unsupervised. He bullied Kelly for most of her teen years and her only escape was to move over 400 miles away and never come home.

My mum got very quiet and then asked me to leave. A few hours later my dad called going mad because I'd upset my mum and was taking the side of a ungrateful little girl instead of my parents who gave me everything.

This started a huge argument between me and him where I told him he'd been a crap dad to Kelly and didn't deserve to walk her down the aisle. Ive just had enough, but now I've got extended family members telling me I've gone too far as my mum is bearly speaking to anyone and keeps crying.

My grandad said it was about time I told them off, but my grandma is upset by all the arguing. So aitah for telling my parents that they sucked a parents and deserved to be kicked out of my sisters wedding?

Understanding Family Dynamics

Family systems theory, as articulated by Dr. Murray Bowen, emphasizes how family relationships can create patterns of behavior that impact individual members. In situations involving favoritism, like the one described, it’s common for siblings to feel marginalized, leading to resentment and conflict.

Research has shown that these dynamics can manifest as emotional cutoff, where individuals distance themselves from family members to cope with perceived injustices. This often creates a cycle of misunderstanding and emotional pain that can be difficult to break.

Comment from u/ridiculousdogma

Comment from u/Accomplished-Emu-591

According to studies in the Journal of Family Psychology, sibling relationships can be significantly affected by parental favoritism. This favoritism not only influences individual self-esteem but can also lead to long-term relational issues between siblings.

Moreover, the emotional toll of these dynamics often leads to anxiety and depression, with affected individuals feeling caught in a tug-of-war between loyalty to family and their own emotional needs.

Comment from u/Hel3nO27

Comment from u/Substantialgood4102

The Psychological Impact of Favoritism

Research indicates that favoritism within families can lead to feelings of inadequacy and jealousy among siblings. A study published in the American Journal of Family Therapy found that siblings who perceive unequal treatment often experience a decline in their emotional well-being.

These feelings can become ingrained, affecting adult relationships and personal development, as individuals may carry forward these unresolved conflicts into their future interactions.

Comment from u/Puzzleheaded-Ask-157

Comment from u/aquavenatus

It’s vital to address these family issues through open communication. Experts recommend that families engage in dialogue about their feelings and perceptions, using 'I' statements to express emotions without placing blame.

Therapy can also provide a safe space for family members to explore these dynamics and work towards a more equitable relationship. Utilizing family therapy techniques can help in addressing underlying issues and promoting understanding.

Comment from u/Aggravating-Plum8147

Comment from u/Impossible-Cap-6433

How would you handle this situation? Let us know in the comments.

Comment from u/sbull630

Comment from u/manxbean

Comment from u/MomofaMalsky

Comment from u/WoodlandElf90

Comment from u/L_Dichemici

Comment from u/Snoo_61002

Comment from u/mca2021

Comment from u/HotWillingness5464

Comment from u/heyheypaula1963

Comment from u/Informal-Dentist2031

Comment from u/Sunshine_0203

Comment from u/Geezell

Psychological Analysis

From a psychological standpoint, the situation reflects deep-rooted family dynamics that are often difficult to navigate. The feelings of exclusion and favoritism can be understood as manifestations of unmet emotional needs, which can lead to lasting conflict if not addressed.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

The complexities of family dynamics, particularly around favoritism, are well documented in psychological literature. As noted by family therapists, understanding the roles each member plays can lead to healthier family interactions.

With appropriate interventions, families can navigate these challenging waters and foster better relationships, promoting emotional health for all members involved.