Dealing with Picky Eaters: Should I Allow My Sister-in-Laws Kids to Bring Their Own Dinner?

A 29-year-old woman is about to host what sounds like the perfect “everyone eats” family dinner, right in her own home. Her husband’s family is coming over Sunday, and she’s already planned a full spread with vegetarian options, gluten-free choices, and even a kid-friendly meal.

Then her sister-in-law, Sarah, calls the night before with a request that throws everything off. Sarah has three kids, two of whom are notorious picky eaters, plus one child with dietary restrictions. Sarah asks if the picky kids can bring their own packed dinners because they “probably wouldn’t eat what you’re making,” even though OP insists she accounted for everyone’s needs.

Sunday arrives, and the dinner turns into an awkward standoff: Sarah’s kids refuse OP’s food and end up sitting there with their separate meals while everyone else eats.

Original Post

So I'm (29F), and my husband's family decided to have a big family dinner at our house this Sunday. We're known for hosting fun events, and everyone was excited.

My sister-in-law, Sarah, has three kids - two picky eaters and one with dietary restrictions. I planned an extensive menu taking everyone's preferences into account - vegetarian, gluten-free, and even a kid-friendly option.

Sarah calls me the night before, asking if the picky kids can bring their own food because they probably wouldn't eat what I was making. I was a bit taken aback but politely said that I had already considered everyone's needs and that bringing a separate meal wouldn't be necessary.

I assured her there would be plenty of options for everyone. Sunday arrives, and the dinner is going great until Sarah's kids start fussing about the dishes.

They refuse to eat anything and ask if they can just have their packed dinners from home. At this point, I feel a mix of frustration and confusion.

I tried so hard to accommodate everyone, but it seems like it's not enough for them. Sarah then pulls out pre-packed meals, trying to convince her kids to eat, but they still refuse.

It got awkward as they sat there with their separate meals while everyone else enjoyed the food I had prepared. Now, Sarah is upset with me, saying I should have let her kids have what they wanted since it wouldn't have been a hassle.

I'm torn. On one hand, I feel like I went above and beyond to cater to everyone's needs, but on the other, I feel bad for not allowing the kids to eat what they preferred.

So WIBTA if I refused to allow my sister-in-law's picky kids to bring their own dinner to our family dinner?

Why This Request Crossed a Line

This scenario hits home for many families where food preferences can stir up unexpected tensions. The Redditor put in considerable effort to plan a menu that accommodates various dietary needs. Then, just before the dinner, her sister-in-law Sar pushes back, wanting her kids to bring their own meals. It’s not just about the food; it’s about respect for the host's efforts and the collective family experience. Allowing special meals can undermine the communal aspect of dining together, which many families hold dear.

By asking for exceptions, Sar not only places the burden on the host but also raises questions about how far one should go to accommodate picky eaters. It’s a delicate balance between family harmony and standing firm on one’s boundaries.

Comment from u/CandyCaneGirl99

Comment from u/TomatoTornado

Comment from u/Jellybean_Jane

OP spent all the time planning a menu for Sarah’s three kids, and it still started with Sarah asking for a separate dinner the night before.

The Picky Eater Dilemma

The issue of picky eaters often reveals deeper family dynamics. While it’s understandable that kids have their preferences, it’s worth examining why those preferences might be accommodated at the expense of the host’s efforts. In this case, the OP's thoughtful menu was designed to be inclusive but was overshadowed by Sar's insistence. Some might argue that Sar is prioritizing her kids' comfort over the hard work put in by the OP, creating an uncomfortable divide.

This tension isn't just about food; it’s a reflection of how we navigate family obligations and respect. It begs the question: should family gatherings cater to individual whims, or is there value in encouraging kids to try new things in a supportive environment?

Comment from u/GardenGnome23

Comment from u/BlueMoonRising

Comment from u/Mountain_Mama

The first fussing begins mid-dinner when Sarah’s picky kids refuse everything on the table and request their packed meals from home.

It’s also like the case where grandma’s picky-eater friend was told she couldn’t bring her own food.

Community Reactions Show Complexity

The Reddit community's divided opinions highlight how personal experience shapes our views on family dynamics.

Comment from u/CoffeeAndChaos

Comment from u/MidnightSnacker

Comment from u/ApplePieDreams

When Sarah pulls out pre-packed meals to try to get them to eat, the vibe shifts from “family dinner” to “everyone is watching this happen.”

The Burden on Hosts

At the heart of this situation lies the often-unrecognized burden placed on hosts during family gatherings. The OP is not just providing a meal; she’s creating an experience meant for connection and joy. Sar’s request to bring alternative meals shifts that responsibility, potentially leading to feelings of resentment from the OP.

This conflict illustrates a common scenario where someone’s personal needs can inadvertently overshadow the collective effort of the group. It raises an important question: how do we find that balance between accommodating individual preferences and honoring the work that goes into family traditions?

Comment from u/StarryNightSkyline

After the kids sit there with their own food while the rest of the family enjoys OP’s cooking, Sarah flips it on OP and says she should have just let them do what they wanted.

What do you think about this situation? Let us know in the comments.

This story resonates with anyone who’s tried to mesh diverse family dynamics around a dinner table.

The Bigger Picture

In this family dinner scenario, the tension stems from differing priorities around mealtime. The Redditor put considerable effort into planning a diverse menu, aiming to create a welcoming atmosphere for everyone, including her sister-in-law's kids. However, Sarah's insistence on bringing separate meals for her picky eaters not only undermines the host's efforts but also shifts the communal dining experience into a more chaotic territory, where individual preferences take precedence over shared moments. This conflict highlights a common struggle in family dynamics: balancing the need for inclusivity with the importance of encouraging children to try new foods in a supportive environment.

The family dinner did not end well, because Sarah’s kids bringing their own food was never really about food, it was about control.

Before you decide on Sarah’s picky kids, read about the sibling who upstaged tradition with a gourmet dish.