Debating Thanksgiving Duties: Am I Wrong for Refusing to Bring a Dish?

A 28-year-old woman is trying to get through Thanksgiving with two toddlers, a recent heartbreak, and exactly zero patience for the usual family power plays. She planned to skip the whole thing because the idea of cooking, entertaining, and then surviving a two-hour train trip to her mom’s house sounded like a disaster waiting to happen.

Here’s where it gets messy: her sisters L (27 F) and T (19 F) live nearby, and they were totally on board with her not bringing a dish. L even offered to cook extra and use OP’s kitchen so everyone would still have enough food. But her mom and her brother A (23 M) heard about the plan and flipped out, insisting OP should show up and cook anyway.

Now OP is stuck in a stalemate, and her brother A is calling her a d**k, leaving her wondering if refusing to bring a dish makes her the villain.

Original Post

I’m the oldest of my three siblings. There’s L (27 F), A (23 M) and T (19 F).

This year, the mother to my children passed away. While we were no longer in a romantic relationship, it was still a hard loss to take and it left a strain on me and my daughters.

Due to this, I was going to skip Thanksgiving all together because it just sounded too stressful to corral two toddlers, cook something, and keep everyone happy on a 2 hour train ride to my mom’s house. We live in a major city and L and T live within walking distance of me while A and my mom live in another state 2 hours away.

After expressing my concerns to L and T, they were both super understanding and said that I wouldn’t have to worry about bringing anything. They said they’d help with the girls and L said she’d cook an extra dish to compensate for me so long as they could use my kitchen since I have more space.

I was happy to accommodate. My mom and A heard about this and were upset.

My mom said that she expected me to show up and also cook a meal. I responded that I was an adult and that I would not be attending if I was expected to bring something as it was hard enough to get two young children on a train ride.

My mother got angry and said that she managed with 4 children as a single mom when we were younger and we never missed thanksgiving. I then pointed out that when she did that, we were much older.

Minus T, we were all teenagers who helped her with the cooking. This upset her further and we reached a stalemate.

I said that I’d only be showing up if I didn’t have to bring something and I could instead help my sisters out. A later reached out to me and told me that I should suck it up and that I was being a d**k.

While I don’t think I’m in the wrong, I do feel bad and wonder if I’m being an A hole.

The emotional landscape during the holidays often becomes complicated, particularly in the wake of loss. The father in this Reddit thread is facing a profound challenge as he prepares for Thanksgiving without the presence of his children's mother. This situation highlights the importance of openly acknowledging feelings of sadness and grief during such significant family gatherings.

By allowing these emotions to surface, the father can better process his own grief while setting an example for his siblings and children. It is crucial for families to cultivate an environment where sharing feelings is not only accepted but encouraged, fostering a deeper understanding and connection among members.

Moreover, integrating the memory of the deceased into holiday traditions can serve as a meaningful way to honor their presence. This practice could offer a source of comfort amidst the turmoil, allowing the family to celebrate their loved one while navigating their own grief.

Comment from u/RoyallyOakie

Comment from u/Sidneyreb

Comment from u/Vegetable-Section-84

Comment from u/International-Fee255

Comment from u/Trick_Few

Comment from u/Suspicious_Juice717

That’s when OP’s sisters L and T, who were ready to help with the toddlers and cover the food, started looking like the only ones acting normal.

Support Networks Matter

For the single father in this scenario, leaning on his sisters is a positive step, but it's also vital to engage in open discussions with family members about his emotional needs.

The healing process can be enhanced by involving loved ones, creating a shared experience that honors the deceased while providing emotional sustenance.

Comment from u/witsendgame

Comment from u/Changeofscenery65

Comment from u/0215rw

Then OP’s mom brought up the “I managed with four children” argument, completely ignoring that OP and her siblings weren’t teenagers anymore.

This is a lot like the fight over whether to use a Christmas gift to repay mom for spoiled food, where OP’s responsibility debate gets personal fast.

Setting boundaries can be particularly challenging during family gatherings, especially when expectations run high. "Expressing your struggles openly can foster empathy and understanding among family members," she states.

She suggests using 'I' statements to communicate feelings without casting blame, which can help set boundaries gently. This method encourages family members to listen and respond positively.

Moreover, enlisting family help in planning can ease individual stress, allowing everyone to contribute while maintaining emotional balance.

Comment from u/parodytx

Comment from u/concretism

Comment from u/Quick-Possession-245

When OP said she’d show up only if she didn’t have to bring anything, the whole thing hit full stalemate, no compromise in sight.

During the holiday season, self-care becomes paramount, particularly for those coping with grief. taking time for oneself can significantly improve emotional well-being.

She suggests practical strategies, like scheduling quiet moments for reflection or engaging in activities that bring joy, such as reading or walking. These self-care practices help individuals recharge and manage their emotional health more effectively.

Encouraging the father to prioritize self-care could lead to a more balanced approach to navigating family dynamics during this sensitive time.

Comment from u/TheDrunkScientist

Comment from u/Competitive_Ninja668

Comment from u/laughter_corgis

Comment from u/Severe-Rabbit-9476

Comment from u/brattamerlane

Comment from u/SalaudChaud

And just to make it worse, A later messaged OP to “suck it up,” turning a holiday family plan into a personal attack.

Creating a Grief-Friendly Environment

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

This father’s experience underscores a common conflict between individual emotional needs and the weight of family obligations, particularly in the wake of profound loss. His choice to prioritize his own well-being and that of his children during this challenging holiday season reveals a commendable understanding of the necessity for self-care amidst grief. The responses from his mother and brother illustrate how unresolved feelings about their shared loss can complicate family dynamics, shedding light on the often messy interplay of tradition and personal grief during such emotionally charged gatherings.

Navigating family dynamics during Thanksgiving can be particularly challenging, especially in the wake of loss. The father at the heart of this Reddit thread faces not only the grief of losing his partner but also the weight of family expectations. His story illustrates the necessity of open communication and compassion in handling these delicate situations.

As families gather, recognizing the need for space to grieve can foster healing and strengthen bonds. This father’s reluctance to bring a dish speaks volumes about his emotional state and the struggle to honor his late partner's memory. By prioritizing shared remembrance and emotional support, families can transform these gatherings into meaningful experiences, even amidst the absence of loved ones.

The family dinner didn’t just end with arguments, it ended with OP questioning whether she’s being punished for grieving.

If you think refusing a dish is hard, see what happened when a roommate’s TV license debts came back to haunt him, and OP had to decide whether to help. Roommate Ruckus: Should I Help with TV License Debts? AITA?