Young Woman Refuses Estranged Father's Request For Loan, He Sues Her For $85,000

Families can be both a source of love and support but also of complexity and, unfortunately, conflict. Relationships within families often hold a mirror to the full spectrum of human emotion and behavior.

In one such striking example, OP, a 29-year-old Vietnamese-Canadian woman, found herself at the receiving end of a bizarre legal dilemma perpetuated by her estranged father. After a lengthy period of absence, he reappeared in her life with a bold request for a large loan.

When she refused, he responded by taking legal action, serving her a court summons for a staggering $85,000 CAD. Initially, OP's father tried to reconnect with her sister, aiming to procure a significant loan for his business endeavors.

This was particularly audacious, considering his family had already cut him off financially. OP found the situation laughable and, quite understandably, declined.

She thought this would close that peculiar chapter, but her father decided to escalate the situation. OP was soon served with a court summons that claimed she owed her father $85,000 CAD.

He went to the extent of incurring court costs and hiring a process server, all with the aim of securing this supposed debt. Baffled but unfazed, OP turned to her best friend—a highly skilled lawyer who found the entire scenario amusing.

Her friend assured her that the only way she could lose this case would be by not appearing in court, offering to represent OP. Read the full story below:

OP writes:

Reddit

OP estranged from her entitled father for some time, recently received a court summons, he suing her for $85,000 CAD

Reddit

Baffled but unfazed, OP turned to her best friend—a highly skilled lawyer who found the entire scenario amusing.

Reddit

Estrangement and Financial Responsibility

Dr. Sarah Thompson, a psychologist specializing in family dynamics, explains that estranged relationships often lead to complex feelings regarding responsibility.

Her research indicates that financial requests from estranged family members can trigger feelings of guilt, obligation, and resentment.

In this case, the daughter’s refusal to loan money represents a protective boundary against past trauma, suggesting a desire to reclaim her autonomy.

We can already imagine the judge laughing...

Reddit

This Redditor had a similar experience, and the result was the same:

Reddit

OP has the money, but she wouldn't give it to him even if he were starving

Reddit

According to Dr. Harville Hendrix, a renowned relationship expert, "adult children often grapple with the emotional burden of supporting estranged parents, which can create significant internal conflict." This struggle is particularly pronounced when past relationships have been strained. Dr. Hendrix emphasizes that "refusing to provide financial support can be a necessary act of self-care, allowing individuals to prioritize their own well-being over familial obligations." In such scenarios, the decision to decline a loan request may reflect a healthy boundary rather than an act of selfishness.

It doesn't matter how much money OP has, this is an awful thing to do...

Reddit

"Dad: You owe me $85,000! OP: Why? Dad: For, umm, you know, reasons!"

Reddit

This Redditor has a point:

Reddit

The Psychology of Financial Boundaries

Setting financial boundaries is crucial in maintaining mental health, particularly in strained family relationships.

Research indicates that being able to assert these boundaries can significantly reduce feelings of anxiety and resentment.

Learning to say 'no' is an essential skill that can empower individuals to take control of their financial and emotional well-being.

The father sounds delusional and entitled

Reddit

This may be a cultural thing

Reddit

The situation OP finds herself in—being sued by a family member, particularly a parent, over money—doesn't seem to be specific to Vietnamese or Southeast Asian cultures. Family dynamics and conflicts over money can occur in any culture or community around the world.

That said, familial obligations and expectations about financial support can differ from culture to culture. In some Asian cultures, there is a strong sense of filial duty, where children are often expected to financially support their parents, especially in their old age.

However, this is a generalization and does not apply to all individuals or families within those cultures. Also, it's worth noting that suing a family member, especially over a significant sum of money, would generally be considered extreme in many cultures, including those in Southeast Asia.

For those facing similar dilemmas, it’s recommended to seek clarity about personal financial situations before making decisions that could impact mental health.

Engaging in open dialogues with trusted friends or therapists can provide perspective and support, helping individuals navigate these complex emotional landscapes.

Additionally, creating a list of pros and cons can help clarify the emotional and practical implications of such financial decisions.

Psychological Analysis

This situation underscores the complex emotions that arise when estranged family members request financial help.

It's important for individuals to recognize that saying no is not an act of unkindness, but rather a necessary step in protecting their own well-being and mental health.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, navigating financial requests within estranged relationships can be fraught with emotional complexity.

Recognizing the importance of self-preservation and setting boundaries is supported by psychological literature.

Ultimately, prioritizing one's emotional health while managing familial expectations is essential in fostering healthy relationships.