Harsh Father Tells His 12-Year-Old Son That He Caused Their Divorce, Thinks It Was Justified

Knowing he would be immediately judged by thousands of Redditors based on the title of his post alone, a father wrote, "Am I The A**hole for telling my son that he is the reason his mother and I are getting divorced?" He thought his explanation would be enough to change a few people's minds but was sorely mistaken.

OP and his wife were high school sweethearts. They stayed together during college, and OP believed they were meant to be with each other for life.

Things changed when they had their son. OP and his wife found it difficult to raise him because he frequently threw tantrums, got in trouble at school, and refused to listen to either parent.

They couldn't see eye to eye on the appropriate way to instill discipline and accountability in their son. They didn't know whether to let him sit with his feelings or to punish him for acting out.

Their inability to effectively parent their son caused friction in their marriage. They developed unhealthy habits to cope with their issues and favored solitude over each other's company.

They argued more as their marriage deteriorated. Their marital problems were so evident that relatives voiced their concerns.

They agreed to file for divorce. Their 12-year-old son was inconsolable when they first told him about their separation.

His son stays with OP most of the week because his wife couldn't handle their son as much as OP did.

u/CopyConnect106

He had been listening to their child yell about how unfair the situation was.

u/CopyConnect106

His patience ran thin when his son kept asking if he and his wife had forgiven each other. OP made it clear that the divorce would proceed no matter what.

u/CopyConnect106

The Impact of Harsh Parenting

The father's comment to his son reflects a harmful pattern often seen in punitive parenting styles. Dr. Diana Baumrind, a developmental psychologist, categorizes such parenting as authoritarian, which can have long-lasting negative effects on a child's self-esteem and emotional health. Research shows that children raised in harsh environments are more likely to experience anxiety and depression as they grow into adulthood.

This statement to his son not only conveys a lack of emotional support but also creates an environment where the child may feel responsible for family issues that are beyond his control.

He cried, and OP got mad. He told his son that the divorce happened because of him. He told him that they were happy before he was born and that he had no one to blame but himself.

u/CopyConnect106

OP offered his son a half-apology and said there was some truth to what he said. His wife mentioned that their son was more well-behaved when she was with him. OP admitted that it was wrong to speak to his son that way, but he felt his son's "improved" behavior justified it.

u/CopyConnect106

The fact that OP fully believes that the end of his marriage was caused by his son gives a clear image of what kind of person he is.

lucotti

According to studies published in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, children exposed to harsh criticism in their formative years often develop a skewed sense of self-worth. The implication that the son caused the divorce can lead to feelings of guilt and shame, which are detrimental to healthy emotional development. This situation exemplifies the need for parents to approach difficult conversations with empathy rather than blame.

He and his wife failed their child by not giving him the support that he needed.

CopyConnect106

A child psychologist called what OP did emotional abuse. No child should be told that they made their parents divorce.

Bakedpotatooooo

Their son needed help. He didn't need to be blamed for the choices made by the adults in his life.

Bakedpotatooooo

Strategies for Healthy Communication

Encouraging positive communication is vital for fostering healthy parent-child relationships. Dr. John Gottman's research on emotional intelligence emphasizes that parents should validate their children's feelings and experiences rather than dismiss or criticize them. This approach can help children feel secure and valued, reducing the likelihood of internalizing negative beliefs about themselves.

Practicing active listening and using supportive language can create a safe space for children to express their emotions and concerns.

OP still refused to accept that his son had nothing to do with his marriage ending.

CopyConnect106

OP can't face that he was, and still is, a terrible father to his son. The problems he faced with his ex-wife are not the fault of their 12-year-old child.

Bakedpotatooooo

OP, his wife who couldn't "tolerate" their son, and their poor kid all need professional help.

Bakedpotatooooo

In addition, parenting workshops or family therapy can provide tools for better communication and understanding within families. Research suggests that families who engage in therapeutic practices often experience improved dynamics and stronger emotional bonds. By working together, families can learn to express feelings constructively and support each other through difficult times.

His son's "improved" behavior is not because he needed to hear the "truth." It's because he was afraid that if he misbehaved again, more bad things would happen.

blockparted

OP failed his son. What he said to him will haunt him for the rest of his life.

blockparted

They just taught their son that their love is to be earned.

blockparted

The Importance of Emotional Support

Providing emotional support is crucial for healthy family functioning. Studies indicate that children who feel emotionally supported by their parents are more likely to develop resilience and better coping strategies. Encouraging open expressions of love and reassurance can help counteract the negative effects of harsh parenting and foster a more positive home environment.

OP's account was suspended before he could post any updates. Based on his replies, it's doubtful that he accepted that what he did was horrible.

Their poor son has one parent who can't stand him and another who thinks he caused their divorce. OP said in another comment that neither wanted full custody of their son and were working out an arrangement that was best for them, not their son.

Psychological Analysis

This scenario illustrates how damaging statements from parents can shape a child's self-perception and emotional health. It's essential for parents to recognize the long-term implications of their words and to engage in nurturing communication that fosters a sense of security and self-worth in their children.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, the impact of harsh parenting can have profound effects on a child's emotional development and sense of self. Research underscores the importance of supportive communication and emotional validation in fostering healthy relationships within families. By adopting more compassionate parenting practices, families can promote emotional well-being and resilience.