Friends Sister Fails as Babysitter: AITA for Refusing Payment?

A 29-year-old man refused to pay his friend’s 17-year-old sister after she babysat his 5-year-old daughter, and now he’s stuck in the middle of a full-on friendship fallout.

It started with “just a few hours a week” for extra cash, but the first babysitting shift came with a late arrival, a kid left parked in front of TV too long, and takeout being ordered even though the daughter has a serious allergy. After she promised it would never happen again, she then no-showed and forgot to tell him, forcing him to call Sarah to figure out where Emily was.

And then came the part where he found missing valuables hidden in Emily’s bag, which is when Sarah decided he was the petty one.

Original Post

So I'm (29M), and my friend, let's call her Sarah, has a younger sister named Emily who's 17F. Sarah asked me if I could hire Emily to babysit my 5-year-old daughter for a few hours a week since Emily wanted some extra cash.

I agreed, thinking it would be a good opportunity for Emily to earn some money. For background, the first time Emily babysat, she was late, left my daughter alone watching TV for too long, and ordered food without permission that my daughter is allergic to.

I talked to Emily about these issues, and she assured me it wouldn't happen again. The following week, Emily was supposed to babysit, but she didn't show up or inform me.

I had to call Sarah to check on Emily, and she said she was out with friends and forgot. I was upset but decided to give her one last chance.

Yesterday, when Emily came over, I noticed valuable items were missing after she left. I confronted her, and she denied taking anything, even when I said I'd involve the police.

Later, I found the items hidden in her bag. I told her to leave and never come back.

Now, Sarah is angry with me for not paying Emily for the last babysitting session. She thinks I'm being petty and should still pay her since she technically showed up.

But I feel that given the situation and the stolen items, I have every right to refuse payment. So, AITA?

The situation with the 17-year-old babysitter highlights a common issue among adolescents: the struggle with self-discipline and impulse control. In this case, the babysitter's irresponsible actions, including tardiness and theft, reflect the ongoing development of these critical skills, which research shows can take years to fully mature. The prefrontal cortex, responsible for self-regulation, does not reach maturity until the mid-20s, suggesting that the babysitter may not have the necessary decision-making capabilities to handle significant responsibilities.

This incident serves as a reminder of the crucial role that parents and guardians play in guiding young people. By fostering structured routines and providing consistent feedback, they can help adolescents navigate their responsibilities more effectively. Such support not only promotes accountability but also lays the groundwork for responsible behavior that will serve them well into adulthood. In this case, however, the lack of proper preparation has led to a breach of trust, raising the question of whether it is fair to compensate someone who has failed to meet the expectations of the role they were hired for.

Comment from u/RainbowUnicorn12345

Comment from u/CoffeeBeanLover22

The second Emily didn’t show up for her shift and Sarah “forgot,” OP’s patience was already hanging by a thread.

After OP had to call Sarah just to locate Emily, the missing-permission-food and TV-alone situation stopped feeling like “a mistake.”

Stealing, particularly among younger individuals, can often be a maladaptive response to stress or feelings of inadequacy.

It’s kind of like the coworker conflict where someone clashed over desk space boundaries.

See the AITA boundary fight over desk etiquette.

Comment from u/GoldenSunflower99

Comment from u/LazyPanda777

When OP confronted Emily about the stolen items and she denied it even with police mentioned, it crossed a line fast.

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/BookWormGirl_28

Finding the valuables hidden in Emily’s bag is what turned Sarah’s payment demand into an argument OP could not ignore.

The situation surrounding the babysitter highlights not just poor decision-making but also the complexities of adolescent behavior. The irresponsible actions taken by the 17-year-old sister reveal a troubling lack of judgment, particularly when it comes to her betrayal of trust by stealing from the very family she was meant to care for. This incident raises important questions about maturity and accountability in young adults. While it is tempting to consider the psychological factors that may influence such behavior, such as typical adolescent brain development and coping mechanisms, these do not excuse the babysitter's actions. The need for consequences in this scenario is paramount, as it serves to reinforce the importance of responsibility and trust, essential qualities in any caregiver. Ultimately, understanding the factors at play can inform how we guide young people in developing healthier coping strategies, but it should not overshadow the necessity of addressing their misdeeds appropriately.

Trust is a critical element in any relationship, and the recent incident involving a friend's sister as a babysitter highlights how quickly that trust can be shattered. The decision to hire a teenager for childcare seemed like a reasonable choice, yet the betrayal of responsibility and theft turned this arrangement into a nightmare. The aftermath of such a breach can lead to significant emotional and relational fallout. It is essential for the parent to engage in open and honest discussions with the young babysitter to address the expectations that were clearly not met. This dialogue could clarify misunderstandings and set the groundwork for any future interactions. In the immediate term, a trial period with explicit guidelines could help both parties gauge their comfort levels and establish boundaries, ensuring that expectations are aligned. Looking ahead, fostering a culture of accountability and transparency will not only aid in the recovery of this specific relationship but also serve as a preventative measure against similar issues arising in the future.

Nobody wants to pay for babysitting that ends with a no-show and stolen valuables.

Next, see why this Redditor says “share later” promises fell apart when parents’ house was at stake. Read the parents’ mortgage drama.