Redditors Learn That Sirens From The Greek Myth Were Never Mermaids But Strange Human-Faced Bird Creatures That Lured Men To Their Deaths

In 1891, there was an uproar in the Australian press. A creative rendition of The Odyssey by British Pre-Raphaelite artist John William Waterhouse had just been acquired by the National Gallery of Victoria, and the critics were outraged by the vision.

In contrast to his contemporaries, who portrayed the Sirens from ancient Greek mythology as characterized by feminine allure and physical beauty, Waterhouse's portrayal of Ulysses and the Sirens resembled a terrifying nightmare. The critics questioned why Waterhouse had departed from Homeric legend and depicted the Sirens as terrifying winged monsters.

Why weren't they combing their golden hair on the seashore but hovering menacingly over the terrified crew? Most importantly, where was the allurement, mystery, and intrigue that captivated the maritime hero, Odysseus?

One irate Melbourne resident claimed that Ulysses looked like a criminal who had been "exposed to the attacks of furious birds of prey," completely dismissing the scene's tragedy. It was agreed that Waterhouse's rendition fell short of what the public had come to expect from the romantic femme fatales.

However, Waterhouse's interpretation wasn't entirely improvised. We must go back to ancient Greece to fully comprehend the origins of the Sirens, where, according to legend, winged and clawed birdwomen lured sailors to their deaths with the power of their song.

More Info: Reddit, Vice

Redditor u/wakeupits2009 has this interesting piece of information to share

u/wakeupits2009

There are many different historical accounts of the Sirens' ancestry. They were most frequently portrayed as Terpsichore, Melpomene, or Calliope, three of the nine Muses, and the daughters of the river god Achelous.

Why weren't they combing their golden hair on the seashore but hovering menacingly over the terrified crew?

Vice

According to some tales, Persephone's human friends, the Sirens, were turned into winged monsters by Demeter after they failed to stop Hades from stealing Persephone. However, according to Ovid's Metamorphoses, which was written in the late first century, the Sirens prayed to the gods for wings and received them, which aided them in their quest to find Persephone.

Here are what Redditors had to say:

Reddit

The Psychology of Myths and Beliefs

Dr. Michael Evans, an anthropologist at Cambridge University, explains that myths often serve as a means to explain complex phenomena through accessible narratives.

His research emphasizes that understanding the origins of these stories can illuminate cultural beliefs and societal norms.

In the case of Sirens, the transformation from bird-like creatures to mermaids reflects changing societal values regarding femininity and danger.

The Allure of Myth in Human Culture

Myths play a crucial role in shaping cultural narratives, providing insight into human psychology and societal values.

Research from the University of Chicago reveals that myths often serve as a mirror reflecting our collective fears, desires, and moral lessons.

The Sirens of Greek mythology, for instance, symbolize temptation and the dangers of succumbing to desire.

Shadows TV

Reddit

What we do in the shadows

Reddit

Energy vampires

Reddit

Myths can shape our behaviors and cultural understandings, often serving as cautionary tales. According to studies in cultural psychology, these narratives can influence how we perceive risk and safety in our lives.

For example, the Sirens’ call could symbolize the allure of danger and the importance of discernment in navigating relationships.

Understanding these themes can provide valuable insights into contemporary issues surrounding attraction and risk.

Understanding the historical context of myths can enhance our appreciation for their complexity and depth.

Studies in cultural psychology highlight how myths are often adapted to address contemporary issues, making them relevant across generations.

This adaptability illustrates the timeless nature of human experience and the ongoing search for meaning.

Witcher 3

Reddit

Being at sea for months

Reddit

Red Dwarf

Reddit

Cultural Narratives and Their Impact

Cultural narratives play a significant role in shaping our perceptions of reality. Research shows that the stories we tell influence our beliefs, behaviors, and even our emotional responses.

These narratives can create stereotypes and perpetuate biases, impacting how we interact with others.

By critically examining these myths, we can challenge harmful stereotypes and promote more inclusive understandings of diverse experiences.

The Psychological Appeal of Danger

The Sirens' allure can also be understood through the lens of risk-taking behavior, which is a common theme in human psychology.

Research from Stanford University suggests that individuals are often drawn to experiences that challenge their boundaries, even when they entail potential harm.

This fascination with danger can provide a sense of thrill and excitement, highlighting the duality of attraction and risk.

These creatures were capable of luring ships completely off course and abandoning unfortunate sailors to perish in the flower-filled meadows they flew over, thanks to their irresistible voices drifting across the waves. Unfazed, Odysseus instructs his men to wax their ears and bind him tightly to the mast of the ship so he won't have to dive into the perilous seas when they encounter the creatures.

???

Reddit

The Odyssey Women

Reddit

Being at sea for long

Reddit

The adaptation of myths over time reflects societal changes. For instance, as cultural perceptions of gender and power shift, so too do the narratives surrounding figures like Sirens.

Research indicates that reinterpreting these myths can empower marginalized voices, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of history.

This process can encourage societies to reflect on their values and the implications of their beliefs.

Moreover, the concept of the Sirens can symbolize the internal struggles we face when confronted with choices that seem appealing but carry significant consequences.

Psychological research indicates that individuals often grapple with impulse control, navigating the tension between immediate gratification and long-term outcomes.

Understanding this dynamic can foster greater self-awareness and decision-making skills.

What this Redditor has learned

Reddit

Melodic voices began to call Odysseus with tales of the Trojan War as they got closer to the island. He yells, raves, and yanks at the ropes as he is enchanted by their song, but the ship keeps sailing until they have passed the perilous coast.

Some legends claim that the Sirens plunged themselves into the gloomy waters of the Aegean Sea to die because Odysseus was able to withstand their song.

He got what he deserved

Reddit

Percy Jackson series

Reddit

Myths as Tools for Learning

Myths can also serve as educational tools, offering lessons about human behavior and societal norms. According to educational psychologists, integrating these narratives into teaching can enhance critical thinking skills.

By analyzing the motivations and consequences of mythological figures, students can engage in meaningful discussions about ethics, morality, and decision-making.

This approach can foster a deeper understanding of both historical and contemporary social dynamics.

Lessons from Mythological Interpretations

Examining myths like that of the Sirens offers valuable lessons in self-regulation and the importance of discernment.

Studies in cognitive behavioral therapy emphasize that recognizing and managing temptations can lead to improved emotional resilience and decision-making.

Developing strategies for resisting immediate urges can significantly enhance one's ability to navigate life's challenges.

A quote

Reddit

It's much less tempting

Reddit

The only sentient being

Reddit

Moreover, exploring myths can also lead to greater self-awareness. Psychological research indicates that engaging with cultural narratives can prompt individuals to reflect on their values and beliefs.

This self-reflection can facilitate personal growth and understanding, allowing individuals to connect their experiences with broader cultural themes.

Encouraging this kind of exploration can enhance empathy and emotional intelligence in individuals.

Additionally, mythological stories can serve as powerful teaching tools, helping individuals explore complex emotions and moral dilemmas.

Research in educational psychology reveals that narratives can facilitate understanding and retention of complex concepts, making them effective in teaching life lessons.

Encouraging discussions around these themes can foster critical thinking and ethical reasoning.

Really?

Reddit

A Brazilian Folk

Reddit

Back to Odysseus

Reddit

Cultural Significance of Myths

Myths often reflect cultural values and beliefs, providing insight into societal norms and collective identity.

According to research from Cambridge University, understanding the cultural implications of myths can deepen our appreciation for their role in shaping human experience.

Engaging with these narratives can promote empathy and cross-cultural understanding.

A reference

Reddit

Homer's Odyssey, which was written toward the end of the eighth century BCE, contains the most well-known representation of the Sirens in classical mythology. In this first literary account, the renowned poet describes how Circe, the goddess of magic, warns Odysseus and his crew about the Sirens, who live on a small island close to Scylla and Charybdis.

Drop your thoughts about this post in the comments below.

Moreover, myths can serve as a source of inspiration, motivating individuals to confront their fears and challenges.

Studies in positive psychology suggest that narratives of overcoming obstacles can inspire resilience and personal growth.

By exploring the lessons embedded in myths, individuals can cultivate a greater sense of purpose and agency in their lives.

Psychological Analysis

This exploration of Sirens highlights the complexities of temptation and desire in human experience. Myths serve as a lens through which we can examine our own impulses and the consequences of our choices, making them relevant to contemporary life.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Myths, like that of the Sirens, offer profound insights into human psychology and cultural values.

Research underscores the importance of understanding these narratives as they provide a framework for exploring complex emotions and moral dilemmas.

Ultimately, engaging with myths can foster greater self-awareness, resilience, and empathy.

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, understanding the psychological underpinnings of myths can enhance our appreciation for cultural narratives. Research consistently shows that these stories shape our beliefs and behaviors, often reflecting deeper societal values. By critically engaging with these narratives, we can foster a more inclusive and empathetic understanding of diverse human experiences.