Redditor Feels Guilty About Hiding Wealth From Struggling Family, But Feels It's Necessary Due to Their Poor Spending Habits

Should you reveal how much money you have to your family? It really depends on your situation.

However, if you're in this Redditor's shoes, you'd be better off not discussing it openly. Let's take a look at his story.

The original poster (OP) tells the "Am I The A**hole?" (AITA) community that he is the oldest among his five siblings. He has a wife and child, and he keeps his finances separate from his wife's.

Although she knows he has savings, she likely doesn’t realize the extent of them. The OP’s family, including his siblings, parents, and in-laws, are all financially irresponsible, often buying new vehicles, spending on unnecessary items, and taking vacations they can’t afford.

Recently, OP’s sister revealed she was three months behind on her car payments and was relying on their parents for help. His parents have maxed out their credit cards, his in-laws are four months behind on their mortgage, and his brother has defaulted on a predatory loan.

The OP feels guilty because he has $82k in savings and $250k in his 401(k), and his finances are secure. He’s been saving for a Boxster but feels conflicted about buying it while his family is struggling.

While OP criticizes their spending habits, he also acknowledges more pressing issues, such as a broken furnace and medical expenses for his nieces and nephews. He doesn’t want anyone to become homeless or move in with him, and his past experience of living in his car during a harsh winter contributes to his guilt.

Ultimately, he is torn between helping his family and achieving his personal financial goals.

The OP's question:

Reddit

This is how the OP and his wife handle their finances.

Reddit

Navigating Family Financial Dynamics

Dr. Michael Thompson, a financial psychologist at the University of Virginia, explains that family dynamics often influence financial decisions.

His research shows that feelings of obligation can lead individuals to conceal their financial situations from family members, particularly when those relatives exhibit poor financial habits.

This can create a complex web of guilt and anxiety.

He tells the community that his family and in-laws are poor with money.

Reddit

He describes how his family is financially struggling.

Reddit

Psychological theories suggest that financial discussions within families can trigger feelings of inadequacy, particularly when wealth disparities are present.

According to research in the Journal of Economic Psychology, individuals may fear being judged or pressured into providing financial assistance, leading to emotional distress.

Understanding these dynamics is crucial for fostering healthier financial conversations.

He wants to help, but he fears that his family would take advantage of him.

Reddit

He believes that his family members are also at fault for their financial struggles.

Reddit

The Importance of Open Communication

Open communication about finances is key to reducing tension and fostering understanding.

Dr. Rebecca Hunter, a communication expert, emphasizes that discussing financial situations openly can help alleviate anxiety and build trust among family members.

Her research indicates that families who communicate about finances are more resilient and better equipped to navigate economic challenges.

On the other hand, the OP's finances are in good shape.

Reddit

He feels he would be an a-hole if he spends money on his dream car when he should be helping his family.

Reddit

For individuals feeling guilty about their financial status, practical solutions include setting boundaries around financial discussions.

Encouraging family members to express their feelings and concerns can help promote understanding while reducing feelings of obligation.

Research shows that families who engage in transparent financial conversations are more supportive and understanding of each other's situations.

Redditors are generally on the OP's side about hiding how much he has.

Reddit

Because of the family's financial struggles, they can't even pay for some of the basic needs.

Reddit

It won't make the OP an a-hole to withhold financial information from his family, especially given their spending habits. In fact, it might be necessary.

If they were to discover the extent of his savings, as he fears they might, he could easily be taken advantage of. There are other ways to offer help.

He doesn't need to jeopardize his own financial stability to assist them.

His sister is struggling to pay for the car, but she can't just lose it.

Reddit

The OP then shares his experiences of being homeless.

Reddit

He doesn't want family members to go through what he did.

Reddit

The OP explains how he became financially stable.

Reddit

He doesn't have to worry about money that much.

Reddit

He plans to get a Boxster.

Reddit

The reason why he and his wife keep finances separate:

Reddit

He has enough money to cover everything his family needs.

Reddit

He's torn between helping his family and using the money for himself.

Reddit

Needless luxuries are the reason why they're struggling financially.

If he helps these people, his predictions will come true.

Reddit

Redditors are also giving the OP a reality check. His money isn't enough to be considered "wealthy."

Reddit

Even with the amount of money the OP has, he'd still struggle if he gets laid off.

So it's better to just save it for rainy days.

Reddit

Psychological Analysis

This situation reflects the emotional turmoil that can arise when wealth and family obligations intersect.

Recognizing feelings of guilt and obligation can help individuals approach financial conversations with empathy and clarity.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Family financial dynamics can be complex, especially when wealth disparities are present.

As Liz Weston, a financial columnist, states, "Open discussions about money can foster understanding and reduce conflict within families." By encouraging transparency around finances, families can navigate these complexities with greater empathy and support.