How to Convince Stubborn FIL to Prepare for Aging Parents?

Are you struggling to get your father-in-law to face reality? The original poster shared a heartfelt story about their elderly in-laws and the challenges they face in accepting the need for change.

With the mother-in-law's health scare and the father-in-law's reluctance to downsize or prepare for caregiving, the family is at a crossroads. The burden of care falls on the shoulders of the son and daughter-in-law, who are understandably overwhelmed.

The conflicting desires of the elderly couple versus the practical needs of the family create a complex situation that many can relate to. The top comments on the post provide various perspectives and advice on navigating similar situations.

Some suggest setting boundaries, preparing backup plans, and discussing options with the elderly parents. Others share personal stories of dealing with stubborn parents or in-laws who resist change until a crisis forces their hand.

The emotional toll, logistical challenges, and tough decisions involved in caring for aging family members are common themes in these responses. As you read through the diverse experiences and insights shared in the comments, you might find solace in knowing that you're not alone in facing these difficult family dynamics.

Whether you're seeking practical advice, empathy, or simply a place to vent, this thread offers a supportive community of individuals who understand the complexities of elder care and familial responsibilities. Share your story, ask for guidance, or offer your own perspective in this space where understanding and compassion abound.

Original Post

My father-in-law is 90, and my mother-in-law is 85. They are in fairly decent health mentally, alongside the expected issues like hearing loss and mild mobility challenges. Last year, my mother-in-law was hospitalized for a pacemaker; however, an error occurred that led to her needing open-heart surgery and spending time in the ICU.

My husband and I, being the only family in town (he has a brother in another city, but he’s unhelpful), had to do everything at that point. Eventually, we became exhausted and hired a full-time in-home caregiving service for the month it took her to recover, as my father-in-law is basically useless in terms of keeping the home or cooking, etc. My father-in-law even makes my mother-in-law get him a glass of milk; he does nothing for himself.

After this incident, we realized that if either of them ever has an accident, we are completely unprepared. They have a huge house on 2 acres that they refuse to downsize and also refuse to renovate in case they ever require live-in caregiving.

The house is big but isn’t set up for guests. After what happened, we do not think we are equipped to provide that level of care (bathing, grooming); it was exhausting.

While my mother-in-law is on board with renovations, my father-in-law won’t budge, and he won’t even really give any reason why. From what we can gather, he doesn’t want strangers living in his house (he disliked them when they were there for my mother-in-law). But where does this leave us then?!

We have children and can’t be expected to drop everything if one of them breaks a hip. My husband is stressed thinking of their future (and so am I), but how on earth can you change their minds to prepare for the inevitable?

Edit: Supportive living is definitely out of the question for them; they’ve said they wish to remain in their giant home.

Understanding Resistance to Change

Dr. Susan David, a renowned psychologist and author, emphasizes that the resistance to change often stems from fear and uncertainty. In her work, she explains that people grapple with emotional agility, making it challenging to adapt to new realities. This is especially true for aging parents who might feel a loss of independence at the thought of needing care.

David's research underlines the importance of addressing these emotions openly. Engaging in empathetic conversations about their fears can pave the way for constructive dialogue and future planning.

Comment from u/petitenurse

Comment from u/lsp2005

Comment from u/Slightlysanemomof5

Financial planners frequently underscore the necessity of having open discussions about finances and caregiving. For instance, financial expert Suze Orman suggests creating a comprehensive plan that includes budgeting for health care and potential long-term care needs.

She advises families to approach these conversations with compassion and practical information, which can help alleviate some of the anxiety associated with aging. Making informed decisions together can reduce feelings of dread and empower everyone involved.

Comment from u/BeneficialSelf4255

Comment from u/Ok_Bonus_7768

Comment from u/__golf

Building a Supportive Environment

Dr. John Gray, a prominent relationship expert, highlights the need for a supportive environment in family dynamics, especially when dealing with aging parents. He states that the emotional climate within the family can significantly impact how open parents are to discussing care needs.

Creating a nurturing space where all family members feel heard can lead to more productive conversations. Dr. Gray emphasizes that patience and empathy are crucial in shifting perspectives, helping parents feel less overwhelmed and more willing to accept necessary changes.

Comment from u/Tak1335

Comment from u/Often_Red

Comment from u/loop2loop13

Psychologists often recommend proactive communication strategies. For example, Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship therapist, advocates for 'I' statements when expressing concerns. This technique allows family members to voice their feelings without triggering defensiveness.

By framing discussions around personal feelings rather than blaming, families can foster openness. Solomon emphasizes the importance of timing and setting as well; choosing a calm moment can lead to more productive outcomes when discussing sensitive topics like care planning.

Comment from u/Just-Lab-1842

Comment from u/Illustrious-Shirt569

Comment from u/Criseyde2112

Engaging Professional Help

Involving a neutral third-party, like a geriatric care manager, can be invaluable in these situations. Dr. Atul Gawande, a surgeon and author, suggests that professionals can offer an objective perspective that family members might struggle to provide.

These experts can facilitate discussions about care options, helping families navigate difficult decisions with less emotional strain. Gawande's insights into healthcare planning highlight the importance of addressing these matters proactively to ensure that aging parents receive the care they need.

Comment from u/beansblog23

Comment from u/McGee_McMeowPants

Comment from u/morbidfae

Therapists often observe that addressing underlying emotions can ease resistance in aging parents. Dr. Laurie Santos, a psychology professor, notes that feelings of control and autonomy are crucial for older adults. Providing them with choices in their care can foster a sense of empowerment.

Encouraging parents to express their wishes and preferences can transform the conversation from one of obligation to one of collaboration. This shift can significantly reduce anxiety about aging and the associated care needs.

Comment from u/Alostcord

Comment from u/funambullla

Comment from u/harmlessgrey

Creating a Care Plan Together

Developing a care plan collaboratively is vital for fostering cooperation. Dr. Michael Thompson, a child psychologist, emphasizes that involving aging parents in the planning process can help them feel valued and respected.

He suggests initiating discussions by asking open-ended questions about their preferences and concerns. Creating a visual representation of the care plan can also make the process more engaging. This collaborative approach not only strengthens family bonds but also ensures that the plan reflects the parents' needs and desires.

Comment from u/Minimalist2theMax

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

Expert Opinion

It sounds like the father-in-law’s resistance to change might stem from a deep-rooted need for control and familiarity, which is common in older adults facing significant life transitions. People often cling to their current living situations as a way to maintain a sense of stability, especially when health issues arise. This dynamic can create immense stress for family members, who feel the weight of responsibility while trying to navigate their in-laws' reluctance to adapt.

Psychological Insights & Implications

Ultimately, navigating the complexities of aging parents requires a blend of empathy, patience, and strategic communication. As highlighted by experts like Dr. Susan David and Suze Orman, addressing the emotional and practical aspects of care planning is crucial. By fostering open dialogue and involving professional guidance, families can create a supportive environment that empowers aging parents to engage in their care decisions.

These proactive steps not only ease familial tension but also establish a foundation for more meaningful connections during this challenging phase of life.