Husband's Silent Treatment - AITA For Snapping At Him Over Diet Advice?

Is it ever okay to go silent on your partner for weeks on end? That's the dilemma one Reddit user faced when her husband stopped talking to her for over three weeks after a seemingly innocent conversation about his diet.

The situation spiraled out of control when she expressed that she was his wife, not his mother. With three kids in the mix and her husband working away most of the week, tensions ran high.

The poster felt isolated, questioning the dynamics of their relationship and the imbalance of responsibilities. The silent treatment persisted, leading her to seek advice from the Reddit community.

Many commenters weighed in, some noting the potentially manipulative and abusive nature of the husband's behavior. Suggestions ranged from therapy ultimatums to reevaluating the relationship's happiness and functionality.

The discussion delved into broader issues of emotional manipulation, unequal distribution of labor, and the need for open communication. Other users shared personal stories and practical advice, urging the poster to prioritize her well-being and consider the future of her relationship.

As the debate unfolded, the consensus leaned toward addressing the underlying issues and seeking professional help or making tough decisions for the sake of personal growth and happiness.

Original Post

So, about three weeks ago, my husband was talking about his diet, and I mentioned that he should have more fiber in it. He asked, 'How do I get more fiber?' Mentally, I thought we both have access to Google, but I didn’t want to be rude, so I replied with the answer(s). He then said, 'You wouldn’t make meals like that for me, would you?' I responded, 'I’m your wife, not your mother.' He claimed it was an extremely rude thing to say and hasn’t spoken to me in over three weeks.

For context, we have three children, and he is only home for a day and a half each week as he works away. He would have expected me to bulk cook on the weekend for him to take with him. My response wasn’t meant maliciously, and I haven’t apologized because I genuinely meant it. We have been together for 15 years, and it genuinely made me feel resentful the way he said it. His expression was puppy-dog-like, and it made me feel as though he was manipulating me—he can never be bothered to research or implement changes for his health, even though he’s a highly intelligent and capable man.

I guess I feel frustrated that he pours everything into work (15-hour days, etc.), but on the home front, the boring day-to-day responsibilities fall entirely on me. This isn’t the first time he’s 'gone silent,' but I usually make good or apologize, and this time I haven’t.

It’s just so awkward, and the longer it goes on, the more resentful I feel about it. He’s pretty much my only solid adult interaction in person, both physically and mentally, and I feel super alone but also sorry for him because he must really be a sad and cruel person to inflict this on another person. Writing this has made me realize just how deeply unhappy I am with him, LOL. But anyway, AITA?

Edited to add: He is on a salary and very high up in his company—he earns the same for a 40 or 80-hour work week; he is not paid by the hour, and overtime isn’t a 'thing' for the role he has—he isn’t being forced to stay there by anyone but himself. I work from home for 6-8 hours a day on weekdays and a couple of hours on weekends.

Edit 2: Thank you for all your responses. I wasn’t looking for some sort of validation that I’m not the AH—I know my comment was out of line and rude regardless of my intent, but I didn’t feel it justified three weeks (going on four) of the cold shoulder.

I guess I just wanted some differing viewpoints from others because sometimes you don’t think rationally or fairly when you’re in a situation, and I was beginning to question if I should apologize regardless of him ignoring me, just to make good and make peace. For clarity, he has a chef who makes his meals Monday through Friday, and I cook for the household, of course, no questions asked on the weekend, and I don’t have an issue with this.

The responses have given me a lot to think about.

Understanding Silent Treatment Dynamics

The silent treatment is a common form of emotional manipulation in relationships, often employed as a means of control. Psychologists explain that this behavior can stem from unresolved conflict and a lack of effective communication skills.

According to research published in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence, the silent treatment can significantly impact relationship satisfaction and emotional well-being.

Comment from u/BudandCoyote

Comment from u/SadFlatworm1436

Individuals who experience the silent treatment often report feelings of confusion and frustration. This behavior can create a toxic cycle where one partner withdraws, leading the other to feel rejected and anxious, ultimately exacerbating the conflict.

Understanding this dynamic is crucial for breaking the cycle and fostering healthier communication patterns.

Comment from u/PsychoTink

Comment from u/654capybara321

The Role of Effective Communication in Relationships

Effective communication is essential for maintaining healthy relationships. Research indicates that couples who engage in open dialogues about their feelings and needs tend to have higher satisfaction levels.

Practicing 'I' statements and focusing on feelings rather than accusations can make conversations less confrontational and more productive.

Comment from u/nittah97

Comment from u/laughinglovinglivid

Emotional regulation strategies can also help couples navigate conflicts more constructively. Techniques such as taking timeouts and practicing mindfulness can reduce emotional intensity during disagreements.

Studies show that these strategies can lead to more thoughtful responses and a reduction in harmful behaviors like withdrawal or criticism.

Comment from u/Crazyandiloveit

Comment from u/secretpsychologist

Addressing Underlying Issues in Relationships

It's essential to address underlying issues that may be contributing to the silent treatment. Couples therapy can provide a safe space for partners to explore their feelings and develop healthier communication styles.

Research suggests that engaging in therapy can help couples uncover patterns of behavior that hinder relationship satisfaction and develop strategies for change.

Comment from u/Bluebells7788

Comment from u/Few_Dog7603

Establishing clear boundaries around communication can help mitigate issues related to the silent treatment. Couples should discuss their expectations for communication during conflicts to prevent misunderstandings and foster a sense of safety.

Encouraging transparency about feelings and needs can significantly improve relationship dynamics.

Comment from u/CountessLyoness

Comment from u/Low-Food2454

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Comment from u/Straight-Note-8935

Comment from u/Puzzleheaded-Okra210

Comment from u/Virtual_Yoghurt_5300

Comment from u/Popular-Parsnip8911

Comment from u/OldBroad1964

Comment from u/flyraccoon

Comment from u/_Mundog_

Comment from u/KrstNE774

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the detrimental effects of emotional manipulation in relationships. Recognizing these patterns is crucial for couples to break the cycle of withdrawal and foster healthier communication.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Addressing silent treatment dynamics requires a commitment to open communication and mutual understanding. By fostering emotional regulation and addressing underlying issues, couples can create healthier interactions.

As research emphasizes, effective communication is the cornerstone of relationship satisfaction.