logo

Sister Calls Her Greedy for Wanting Dad’s Condo Instead of Splitting It

A grieving daughter asks for stability, and her sister sees selfishness.

Sister Calls Her Greedy for Wanting Dad’s Condo Instead of Splitting It

Grief has a way of surfacing old tensions at the worst possible time. When a parent passes, families often assume they’ll pull together, share memories, and lean on one another. Instead, money, property, and unspoken resentments can quietly slip into the room and take a seat at the table.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

What begins as mourning can quickly turn into a negotiation no one feels prepared for. Inheritance is rarely just about numbers on paper. It represents security, fairness, childhood dynamics, and sometimes decades of comparison between siblings.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Who got more help growing up? Who was seen as the responsible one? Who struggled quietly. Who is “doing fine” now?

Even a modest asset can carry emotional weight far beyond its market value. To one person, it might symbolize stability after years of hardship. To another, it might represent a final act of equal love that should not be altered.

Housing in particular hits differently right now. Rent prices have climbed so high that a basic apartment can consume nearly an entire paycheck. For someone living close to the edge, the chance to assume a manageable mortgage can feel life-changing.

It can mean privacy, custody arrangements, and a sense of control over the future. For someone who is financially secure, splitting everything evenly can feel like the only fair and principled approach.

When emotions run high, “fair” and “necessary” do not always align. One sister saw a chance at stability. The other saw a boundary being crossed. What followed was not a quiet exchange, but a flood of anger that left both sides feeling unheard.

She opens with the question that started it all, unsure if asking for more than half makes her selfish or just desperate.

She opens with the question that started it all, unsure if asking for more than half makes her selfish or just desperate.Reddit
[ADVERTISEMENT]

The inheritance is not cash or savings. It is a small condo that suddenly feels like her only shot at stability.

The inheritance is not cash or savings. It is a small condo that suddenly feels like her only shot at stability.Reddit
[ADVERTISEMENT]

A 650 square foot condo might sound modest, but to her it feels like a lifeline.

A 650 square foot condo might sound modest, but to her it feels like a lifeline.Reddit

With rent doubling and her income staying the same, the math simply does not work.

With rent doubling and her income staying the same, the math simply does not work.Reddit

When you earn just under 2000 and rent starts at 1500, there is barely room to breathe.

When you earn just under 2000 and rent starts at 1500, there is barely room to breathe.Reddit

She thought taking over the mortgage was a practical solution. Her sister heard something very different.

She thought taking over the mortgage was a practical solution. Her sister heard something very different.Reddit

She reminds her sister that this is about custody, her child, and staying close, not about grabbing more than her share.

She reminds her sister that this is about custody, her child, and staying close, not about grabbing more than her share.Reddit

This is not just about property. It is about being able to parent under her own roof.

This is not just about property. It is about being able to parent under her own roof.Reddit

What she hoped would be a discussion became a stream of angry messages and labels.

What she hoped would be a discussion became a stream of angry messages and labels.Reddit

Fairness sounds simple until real life starts pressing in from all sides.

Fairness sounds simple until real life starts pressing in from all sides.Reddit

Not greedy for asking, but still not entitled to more. That is a hard middle ground to sit with.

Not greedy for asking, but still not entitled to more. That is a hard middle ground to sit with.Reddit

Half the condo also means half the responsibility. Selling it feels clean on paper, even if it hurts in practice.

Half the condo also means half the responsibility. Selling it feels clean on paper, even if it hurts in practice.Reddit

When one person is secure and the other is scrambling, equal shares can feel unequal in spirit.

When one person is secure and the other is scrambling, equal shares can feel unequal in spirit.Reddit

Some would rather see her take the cash and cut emotional ties altogether.

Some would rather see her take the cash and cut emotional ties altogether.Reddit

For some, the rule is simple. Two children means two equal shares, no exceptions.

For some, the rule is simple. Two children means two equal shares, no exceptions.Reddit

A tough reminder that her hardship does not automatically shift responsibility onto her sister.

A tough reminder that her hardship does not automatically shift responsibility onto her sister.Reddit

When the choice feels like rent or groceries, asking for help can look a lot less selfish.

When the choice feels like rent or groceries, asking for help can look a lot less selfish.Reddit

A small side note that shifts attention to the ex, who at least seems cooperative through all of this.

A small side note that shifts attention to the ex, who at least seems cooperative through all of this.Reddit

When one person has abundance, asking for half can look less like fairness and more like excess.

When one person has abundance, asking for half can look less like fairness and more like excess.Reddit

Compassion for her situation, tempered with the sense that the condo may still slip away.

Compassion for her situation, tempered with the sense that the condo may still slip away.Reddit

When family tension runs high, walking away can sound like the cleanest option.

When family tension runs high, walking away can sound like the cleanest option.Reddit

At the center of this conflict is a painful question about what inheritance is meant to do. Is it a symbol of equal love that must be divided down the middle, or a final gift that could change one child’s entire trajectory? One sister is facing housing insecurity and the possibility of shared custody with her son if she has a stable home. The other believes fairness means splitting everything evenly, no exceptions.

So what would you do? Would you ask for the condo, or insist on dividing it? Share this with someone who has strong feelings about family and money.

More articles you might like