Is it Wrong to Resell Free Items from Neighbors?

Are you a fan of neighborhood Facebook groups and the drama that sometimes unfolds within them? Well, brace yourself for a juicy story that's got the internet buzzing.

Picture this: a woman, let's call her a savvy mom (28F), scoops up freebies from the local online community, only to flip them for a few bucks later on. Sounds harmless, right?

Well, her neighbor thinks otherwise. The plot thickens when the neighbor catches wind of the resale and calls out our protagonist for not following the unwritten rules of neighborly conduct.

The debate rages on Reddit as users weigh in on the moral dilemma—Is it ethical to resell items originally obtained for free? Some argue that it's a clear case of being in the wrong (YTA), while others see it as more of a gray area.

The comments section is ablaze with opinions, with some dubbing the mom a "selfish asshole" and others urging her to consider the community's values of sharing and giving back. As the discussion unfolds, tensions rise, and judgments are passed.

Is our mom in the wrong for cashing in on her neighbors' generosity, or is she simply exercising her right to do as she pleases with her possessions? Join the debate and share your thoughts on this neighborhood drama that has everyone talking.

Original Post

I (28F) live in a very large neighborhood. We have a neighborhood Facebook group where people sell and give away items very frequently.

I have two small children who grow out of things quickly, so I’ve grabbed a few bags of free clothes, shoes, and toys. Once my kids grow out of those, I sometimes sell them on FB Marketplace.

Recently, a neighbor saw my listing and reached out to ask if this was the item she had given to me for free. I said yes, and she told me I should have posted the item in our neighborhood group for free first before trying to sell it.

She called me a scammer and said what I was doing wasn’t very neighborly. I told her that I had used the item for several months and wasn’t scamming anyone.

I didn’t see anything wrong with making a few dollars here and there. I have given away several things to our neighbors that I didn’t want to go through the effort of selling, and I honestly don’t care what they do with them.

I understand that it may be the "neighborly" thing to do to try and find someone who can use them first before selling, but I don’t think I’m an a***hole. In my opinion (which may be wrong, and that’s why I’m posting this), if someone gives away something for free, it’s out of their hands once someone picks it up.

So, AITA for selling items that were given to me for free? Edit to add: The Facebook group isn’t specifically a "buy nothing" group.

It’s a neighborhood group where people post about what’s going on, sell/give away items, etc. I only picked up items I actually had a need for at the time.

I never picked anything up with the intention of selling. Most of the time, the post will just say "free bag of clothes on curb" with the address.

Anyone could pick it up.

Navigating Neighborhood Ethics

When it comes to reselling free items, ethical considerations are paramount. Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship expert, emphasizes that neighborly interactions often hinge on trust and shared values. In her experience, the act of reselling may not only strain relationships but can also lead to feelings of betrayal within the community.

According to Dr. Solomon, open dialogue is essential. She suggests discussing intentions with neighbors before engaging in resale practices, which can foster understanding and minimize conflict.

Comment from u/_mmiggs_

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/Ok_Refuse4444

From a financial perspective, reselling items can be seen as a savvy business decision. Financial author David Bach notes that utilizing free resources can help individuals improve their financial situation.

He recommends that consumers assess the value of items before reselling, ensuring transparency with neighbors about the intentions behind the resale. This approach could create a more supportive environment, where everyone benefits from the transaction.

Comment from u/ArtShapiro

Comment from u/StAlvis

Comment from u/NeuroSpicyBerry

The Psychology of Reselling

Psychological factors play a significant role in how individuals perceive the act of reselling. Dr. Susan David, an emotional agility expert, explains that people often react negatively when they feel their generosity is exploited. This emotional response can lead to accusations of being 'unneighborly.'

To mitigate this, Dr. David suggests that the person reselling should express gratitude for the original gift, acknowledging the neighbor's kindness. By framing the transaction positively, it may reduce feelings of resentment.

Comment from u/SoImaRedditUserNow

Comment from u/zzWoWzz

Comment from u/hface84

Experts in community dynamics like Dr. Robert Cialdini emphasize the importance of perceived fairness in social transactions. He notes that when items are given freely, a social contract is often assumed, which can be violated by reselling.

To avoid misunderstandings, individuals should consider establishing clear boundaries regarding what constitutes acceptable behavior in neighborhood exchanges. This could include agreements on resale practices, fostering a cooperative community spirit.

Comment from u/SeamStressed1

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/TimeRecognition7932

Practical Steps for Better Communication

To navigate the complexities of reselling, effective communication is key. Relationship therapists recommend a proactive approach: discussing resale intentions with neighbors before making transactions.

Dr. Pat Love suggests that establishing mutual agreements can help maintain healthy relationships. She encourages individuals to create a community charter outlining acceptable practices for sharing and reselling, ensuring everyone is on the same page.

Comment from u/LA_chupa_CA_bruh

Comment from u/Interesting-Light220

Comment from u/Scary-Sherbet-4977

Understanding community norms can prevent potential conflicts over reselling. A community expert highlights that shared values often dictate acceptable behavior. Neighborhood groups should engage in regular discussions about these norms, enabling members to voice concerns and establish guidelines.

Creating a space for these conversations not only strengthens community bonds but also fosters an atmosphere of collaboration, where members feel heard and respected.

Comment from u/lorainnesmith

Comment from u/Ill-Ad-1081

Comment from u/True-Improvement-191

Building Trust in Community Exchanges

Building trust is essential in neighborhood exchanges, particularly when it comes to reselling. Experts like Dr. John Gray emphasize the importance of empathy in maintaining relationships. He suggests actively listening to neighbors' feelings about resale practices can lead to greater understanding.

Dr. Gray also recommends that individuals clarify their intentions when acquiring free items, reassuring neighbors that the resale is not a reflection of their generosity, but rather a personal choice for financial gain.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/lemonlimon22

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

Expert Opinion

This situation highlights a fascinating clash of values: individualism versus community norms. The mom's actions reflect a motivation to be resourceful, especially as a parent needing to manage costs, while the neighbor's reaction underscores the importance many people place on social responsibility and the unwritten rules of neighborliness. This tension can often arise in community settings where expectations about sharing and generosity can vary widely, leading to conflict and moral dilemmas.

Ultimately, the question of whether it's wrong to resell free items from neighbors taps into deeper issues of trust and community ethics. Encouraging open communication and establishing clear guidelines can help mitigate potential conflicts. As experts like Dr. Alexandra Solomon and David Bach suggest, fostering transparency and mutual respect will create a more harmonious environment for everyone involved.

By addressing concerns openly and collaboratively, community members can navigate the complexities of such transactions while reinforcing the bonds of neighborly support. It's essential to remember that maintaining positive relationships often outweighs the financial gains from reselling.