Is Using Professional Language in an Email for Your Husband's New Job Considered Overkill?

Are you the jerk for using professional language in an email on behalf of your husband? The scenario unfolds with a wife aiding her husband in sending a consent form for a job background check.

The wife drafted an email with formal language, including "Attached hereto, please find the executed Consent Form for (my husband). Thank you, (My name)." The husband's reaction was unexpected as he expressed embarrassment and even mentioned wanting to retire due to the email's language.

Many Reddit users weighed in, with some siding with the husband, criticizing the overly formal language, while others defended the wife's professionalism. Some commenters found the husband's reaction to be extreme, questioning his behavior and communication style.

The discussion delves into the nuances of professional email etiquette, the dynamics of spousal support, and the boundaries within relationships. Whether the wife's language was appropriate or excessive becomes a focal point in the debate, revealing differing perspectives on workplace communication and personal interactions.

Original Post

My (30F) husband (43M) accepted a new job, and as part of that job, he needed to sign a consent form to send to his new employer so they could complete some type of background check or related process. He tried to send this email a few times, but it would not go through.

He asked me if I would send it, and I said I would. So I drafted the following email: “Attached hereto, please find the executed Consent Form for (my husband).

Thank you, (My name)” I CC’d my husband on the email because he asked me to. Thirty minutes went by, and I received a text from him, “Omg.

What kind of overkill email was that? 🤦” This was yesterday, so today I am at work, and I received another series of texts from him where he essentially said that he is completely embarrassed by me.

He stated that my email was inappropriate to send to his new employer. He said that he wants to retire from this job and that my language sounded like something out of a Tom Clancy book from colonial times.

He claimed I overcomplicated it tenfold and that this is why he never asks me for help. He said every time I am involved, I try to sabotage him, and he regrets it.

UPDATE: When he asked me to send the PDF, we were on the phone, and I read to him what I was typing and asked if it sounded okay, and he said yes. He claims I’m the a*****e for how I sent the email.

Am I the a*****e for the language I used in my email?

Understanding the Psychology Behind Communication Styles

When we consider the use of language, it's not just about the words we use but also the context in which they are used. The reaction from the husband might be rooted in what psychologists refer to as 'Communication Accommodation Theory' (CAT). This principle suggests that individuals adjust their speech, vocal patterns, and gestures to accommodate others in communication, fostering social approval or disapproval. As noted by Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship expert, "The way we communicate can either build bridges or create barriers in our relationships." In this instance, the husband may have felt the language was not accommodating to the context and thus reacted negatively.

Comment from u/xX_WarHeart_Xx

Comment from u/starry_nite99

Understanding the husband's reaction through the lens of Dr. Paul Bloom, psychology professor, can provide valuable insights into human behavior and interpersonal dynamics. Dr. Bloom states, "Our emotions are shaped by the way we communicate, and this can deeply affect our self-perception." This theory posits that individuals have an inherent drive to maintain a positive self-image, which can be significantly influenced by the language and tone others use when communicating about them. In this particular scenario, the husband's feelings of embarrassment may arise from a perceived disconnect between his self-identity and the formal tone of the email he received.

This misalignment not only affects his emotional response but could also lead him to feel uncomfortable in the professional environment. As noted by Dr. Amy Cuddy, social psychologist, "When we feel disconnected from our environment, it can undermine our confidence and sense of belonging." Such feelings may reduce his sense of belonging and acceptance within that context. This situation underscores the critical importance of being mindful of language and communication styles, as they play a pivotal role in shaping personal identity and influencing social interactions.

Comment from u/pudah_et

Comment from u/dosgatitas

Implications of Expectation Violation Theory

Another perspective to consider is the Expectation Violation Theory, which posits that individuals possess specific expectations regarding social interactions and communication styles. This theory suggests that when these expectations are not met, it can lead to unexpected outcomes and reactions. In the scenario where the wife employed formal language, it may have violated her husband's expectation for a more casual and relaxed approach to their conversation. His subsequent reaction indicates that he anticipated a different tone, one that perhaps felt more personal, warm, and less intimidating.

Such violations of social norms can create discomfort and tension in interpersonal relationships, highlighting the importance of being attuned to the expectations of those we engage with. Understanding these nuances can foster better communication and strengthen connections, ensuring that interactions are both effective and comfortable for all parties involved.

Comment from u/SalaudChaud

Comment from u/tidderor

To improve communication in similar situations, enhancing Emotional Intelligence is essential. This involves being aware of both your own emotional responses and those of others around you. Developing this awareness can significantly enhance interpersonal relationships and foster a more empathetic environment. One practical approach to cultivating Emotional Intelligence is to engage in active listening, which ensures you fully understand the feelings and expectations of the person you’re communicating with.

For instance, taking a moment to ask your husband how he feels about the email's tone before sending it can create a collaborative atmosphere and alleviate any potential discomfort. This simple act not only demonstrates your consideration for his perspective but also encourages open dialogue. By prioritizing emotional awareness and fostering collaboration, you can enhance your communication skills and build stronger connections with those around you.

Comment from u/nunyabuziness1

Comment from u/HorseygirlWH

The Role of Emotional Intelligence in Communication

Different individuals have varying comfort levels with formality in communication. Some may see formality as a sign of professionalism, while others may view it as overly stiff or unapproachable. This dichotomy can lead to challenges in conveying messages effectively, as the intended tone may not be received as such by all parties involved. Dr. John Gottman, a renowned marriage researcher, states, "The key to successful communication is understanding the emotional context of the conversation" on his website gottman.com. Adapting our communication style to match the preferences of our audience can significantly enhance relational dynamics and promote positive interactions.

Additionally, being aware of these differences allows us to tailor our communication approach more effectively, reducing the potential for misinterpretations. Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist, emphasizes that "understanding the nuances of communication can help prevent misunderstandings and foster a more supportive environment" on her site helenfisher.com. Ultimately, embracing flexibility in our communication styles can lead to stronger connections and more productive dialogues.

Comment from u/AdvertisingKey1675

Comment from u/ScarletNotThatOne

To prevent similar issues in the future, it is essential to consider implementing a structured approach to communication that works for both partners. Immediate steps can include discussing preferred communication styles with your partner today, ensuring that both of you feel heard and understood. In the short term, spend 1-2 weeks experimenting with different tones in your emails and soliciting feedback from each other to gauge effectiveness and comfort levels.

Over the next 1-3 months, set aside dedicated time to reflect on these experiences together, discussing how different styles impacted your interactions and overall relationship dynamics. This ongoing dialogue can foster a stronger partnership and enhance your collective communication skills, allowing you both to navigate challenges with greater ease. Embracing this proactive approach will not only improve your current communication but also build a solid foundation for future discussions.

Comment from u/LostWithAngeles

Comment from u/Hansm84

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/gymngdoll

Comment from u/keesouth

Comment from u/LazyAd622

Comment from u/missfloralprincess

Comment from u/ariesgirlb78

Comment from u/Oodietheoderoni

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights how communication styles can clash, especially in personal relationships where expectations differ. The husband's reaction may stem from a mix of embarrassment and a feeling that the formal language didn't match the context, which can trigger discomfort or anxiety—this is where Expectation Violation Theory comes into play. It's also a reminder that understanding our partner's emotional landscape and preferences can significantly improve communication dynamics.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

So, is using professional language in an email for your husband's new job considered overkill? The answer might depend on various factors, including mutual expectations, social norms, and emotional intelligence. Understanding these psychological theories can help us navigate the complex landscape of communication and potentially avoid misunderstandings or negative reactions in the future. Remember, communication is not just about the message, but also about the context, the receiver, and their potential interpretation.