Japanese Bride Marrying A Caucasian In The US Asks If She Is Wrong For Not Wanting To Wear A Western Wedding Dress

Honoring our heritage is important because it is a part of who we are. Honoring our future spouse’s heritage shows that you love them as a whole, not just some parts of them.

That’s the way most people see it, right? A Redditor going by the name u/PuzzledSurround6810 asked, “AITA for not wanting to wear a Western wedding dress at my wedding?”

She continues, “I am set to marry my fiancé in the fall of next year. My fiancé and his family are Catholic and very religious. I am Japanese, while my fiancé is white. I don't care if he wears a tux like he wants to, but I want to wear a Shiromuku for the actual wedding and change into an Iro-uchikake for the reception.”

And that’s where a problem arises. Our OP’s mother-in-law believes a traditional Japanese wedding gown is not appropriate for the occasion and that the bride will “stick out” and not “blend in.”

There are so many things wrong here. First, how can you negate someone’s heritage?

Second, how can you feel that the bride should fit in and not stand out? Take a look at this interesting story and tell us what you think:

OP asks:

Reddit

OP is Japanese and marrying a Catholic white man. She has agreed to a Catholic wedding because it is important to her future husband and his family.

Reddit

OP wants to wear a traditional Japanese wedding gown called Shiromuku for the wedding and change into an Iro-uchikake for the reception. Her mother-in-law doesn't like the idea and wants to keep everything Western-style.

Reddit

The dilemma faced by the bride in this article is a classic example of cultural negotiation, highlighting the psychological concept of 'cultural identity.' Research shows that individuals often struggle with reconciling their personal cultural identity with the expectations of their partner's culture, particularly in marriage scenarios where two distinct traditions intersect. According to Dr. J. M. Phinney at the University of California, Los Angeles, cultural identity is a dynamic process influenced by social interactions and experiences, meaning that individuals can adapt their cultural expressions over time without losing their core identity. This negotiation can lead to a deeper understanding and appreciation of both cultures, ultimately enriching the marital relationship.

Moreover, studies indicate that couples who embrace both partners' cultural backgrounds are likely to develop stronger relationship satisfaction compared to those who adhere strictly to one cultural norm. This suggests that open dialogue about cultural practices, such as wedding attire, can foster intimacy and respect in the relationship.

Cultural Integration Strategies

Integrating different cultural practices into wedding ceremonies can be a rewarding experience that honors both partners' backgrounds. Dr. Jennifer D. M. Lee, who specializes in intercultural communication, emphasizes that blending traditions can create a richer and more meaningful ceremony for both families. This approach not only respects individual identities but also promotes a sense of unity and collaboration.

For instance, the bride could consider wearing her traditional kimono for part of the ceremony and then change into a Western dress for the reception, symbolizing the merging of both cultures. Research indicates that ceremonies incorporating diverse elements tend to enhance the emotional experience for both partners and their families, fostering a sense of belonging. Engaging in this kind of cultural integration can ultimately lead to a more harmonious and fulfilling wedding experience.

OP’s fiancé asked her if it was so important to her and suggested a compromise (that’s not really a compromise)

Reddit

OP believes she is already compromising enough by having a Catholic wedding and wants her heritage to be shown too.

Reddit

The Redditors believe OP is right. After all, no church law says what a bride should wear. It only needs to be respectful.

Reddit

Psychological Perspectives on Tradition

According to social psychologists, traditions serve as social glue, reinforcing bonds within families and communities. When a bride contemplates wearing a Western wedding dress versus a traditional Japanese kimono, she isn't just choosing attire; she's navigating complex layers of identity, belonging, and expectation. Dr. Anna B. C. Lim, a cultural psychologist, explains that rituals, such as weddings, often symbolize the merging of not just two individuals but also their families and cultural histories.

Research published in the American Psychological Association journal highlights the significance of rituals in creating shared meanings and values, emphasizing how these traditions can provide a sense of security and continuity in times of change. Thus, the bride's hesitation to disregard her cultural heritage can be seen as a natural response aimed at preserving her connection to her roots while entering a new phase of life.

There are plenty of church weddings where brides don't wear traditional wedding dresses.

Reddit

And what's the logic behind 'not sticking out too much at your wedding?'

Reddit

This could be true. There is plenty of concealed racism out there...

Reddit

Conflict between personal desires and family expectations is a common psychological theme, particularly in collectivist cultures where family honor plays a crucial role. A study published in the journal Cultural Psychology found that individuals from collectivist backgrounds often experience heightened anxiety and stress when faced with decisions that may disappoint their families, such as choosing wedding attire that diverges from tradition. This phenomenon, known as 'cultural dissonance,' can lead to significant internal conflict.

To navigate this situation effectively, it's beneficial for individuals to engage in open communication with both their partner and family members. Expressing their feelings about honoring their heritage while also considering their partner's wishes can create a space for mutual understanding. Research in conflict resolution suggests that finding common ground, such as incorporating elements of both traditions into the wedding ceremony, can alleviate tension and foster a sense of unity.

These gowns are beautiful and can’t embarrass anyone. What's more, they can even contribute to the grandeur of the whole event.

Reddit

A Shiromuku style wedding dress:

mizuno-shashinkan

Iro-Uchikake Dress:

la-viephotography

The Role of Empathy in Cultural Negotiation

Empathy plays a vital role in navigating cross-cultural relationships, particularly when it comes to traditions and expectations. Dr. Brené Brown's research on vulnerability emphasizes that empathetic communication fosters deeper connections and understanding between partners. In this case, the bride could benefit from engaging her fiancé and mother-in-law in a heartfelt discussion about the significance of her traditional attire and how it represents her identity.

By sharing her feelings and encouraging her partner's family to express their own expectations, the couple can cultivate a more collaborative approach to their wedding planning. Empirical studies show that couples who practice empathy and open dialogue tend to report higher relationship satisfaction and lower levels of conflict. This approach not only honors both cultures but also strengthens the couple's bond.

One Redditor made a very good point. Some of the modern wedding dresses are anything but conservative and appropriate for the occasion.

Reddit

The fiancé here needs to be more supportive.

Reddit

His future wife needs support, not his mother.

Reddit

Research in decision-making psychology highlights the concept of 'cognitive dissonance,' which occurs when individuals hold conflicting beliefs or values. In this bride's case, she may feel torn between her desire to honor her family's traditions and the pressure to conform to her fiancé's family's expectations. This inner conflict can lead to emotional distress and indecision, as outlined in Leon Festinger's theory of cognitive dissonance.

To alleviate this discomfort, it’s essential for the bride to reflect on her values and priorities. Writing down the pros and cons of each option can provide clarity and help her articulate her feelings more clearly to her fiancé and family. According to research in behavioral science, this reflective practice can lead to more informed decisions and a greater sense of agency, allowing her to navigate her wedding plans with confidence.

Yes, it is awful to see a bride sticking out on her wedding day...

Reddit

What bride would ever want that?

Reddit

Mixed marriages and relationships are a common occurrence, and they can only work if the people in them respect their significant other.

Part of the whole respect thing is honoring their heritage (if they consider it important, of course). The fiancé in this story should be more concerned about what his future wife thinks and wants.

After all, he is marrying her, and her heritage is kind of included in the package.

Psychological Analysis

The bride's dilemma highlights how deeply intertwined cultural identity and personal values can be, especially in the context of marriage. She's caught between honoring her heritage and meeting her future mother-in-law's expectations, which can create significant internal conflict—a classic case of cognitive dissonance. This situation underscores the importance of open communication in relationships, as navigating these cultural differences can ultimately strengthen the bond between partners while honoring both their backgrounds.

Analysis generated by AI

In conclusion, the complexities of honoring cultural heritage in the context of marriage are profound and multifaceted. As highlighted by trauma specialists, the struggle between individual desires and familial expectations can evoke feelings of anxiety and conflict, which are common in cross-cultural relationships. However, with open communication, empathy, and the willingness to integrate both traditions, couples can navigate these challenges effectively. As noted in research on cultural identity and marriage, blending traditions not only honors personal heritage but also enriches the couple's shared journey, fostering stronger emotional connections and relationship satisfaction.