Jealousy Ensues: Sister Takes Over Cat You Wanted

Are you the jerk for feeling envious that your sister got the cat you longed for? Picture this: a year ago, your family moved to a pet-friendly house.

After much pleading, a family dog was adopted - mainly your mom's buddy. Fast forward, you're all set to get a cat.

You've done your research, bought all the cat essentials, and the perfect opportunity arises when your mom's friend needs to rehome her feline due to moving into a pet-free retirement home. You're ecstatic - finally, your dream of having a cat is coming true.

But hold on, plot twist! A few days later, you discover that the cat stuff you meticulously gathered has vanished from the living room.

It turns out; the cat is now officially your sister's. The frustration hits you like a ton of bricks.

You contemplate reclaiming the items you bought, but your conscience stops you. Your sister, jobless and reliant on others for cat supplies, now owns the cat you invested in emotionally and financially.

The online community weighs in on your dilemma, offering insights and varied perspectives. Many empathize with your situation, expressing that the handling of the situation by your family, especially your mom, was unfair.

Suggestions range from demanding reimbursement for the cat items to fostering a better relationship with the cat, as ultimately, the feline will choose its favorite human. As the debate unfolds, the nuances of family dynamics, responsibility, and pet ownership surface.

The discussion delves into the importance of accountability, communication, and maturity in handling such delicate situations. Your journey to navigate these complexities and find a resolution is a learning experience that resonates with many.

Original Post

AITA For background I 20(f) have a little sister 17(f). My family finally moved into a pet friendly house 1 year ago and me and my sister begged out parents to get a pet so we did we got a dog “family dog” ( mainly my moms he only listens to her) anyway so 6 months later I asked my parents “hey can I get a cat “ my parents say “ok maybe” a few months go by and I’ve been buying cat stuff cat tree, cat toys, researching half raw diets, cat beds , litter boxes and which litter is better over other brands , etc and my moms old friend is just so happens to have to re home her cat because she had to move into a retirement home and unfortunately it doesn’t allow pets.

So we adopted the cat. I got supper excited thinking I am finally getting a cat I’ve been wanting for years and she comes home and she is getting use the the environment and everything mean well I’ve given this cat all the stuff I bought for when I get a cat thinking omg she is my cat now.

Few days later I come home after work and see that all the cat stuff isnt in the living room corner anymore so I ask my mom where it all went and she goes. “ oh it’s all in your sisters room because the cat is now your sisters cat”.

I got so mad I just ran to my room and wanted to take all the stuff I bought back so I can have it for when I get a cat ( I did not take any of the stuff back it’s not fair to the cat it did nothing wrong). I also have a full time job with steady income ( not enough to afford rent by myself) but enough to pay for a vet bill.

My sister has no job and has to relay on other people to get the cat stuff. So am I the a*****e for being jealous that my sister got the cat I wanted?

Update 1 I see there is a lot of confusion going on and I'm sorry about my terrible wording, I was crying while writing this post, and I'm not very good with words. My mom and Sister are never home, my sister has the cat locked in her room most of the day because my sister doesn’t want the cat hurting the dog.

The dog is ok with the cat, he always wants to play with her, and he brings her his toys to play with him. Unfortunately, moving out is not really an option atm, I live in a capital city where rent can be 1,800 - 2,000 per month nothing included.

I do work at a job that pays me pretty good (20 bucks an hour), but still not enough to move out on my own. I have a partner that I have been dating for a while, and we have been talking a bit about us moving in together.

As for my mom, this isn’t the first time she has done this with an animal. When we lived in the place before this one, we were aloud small animals (hamster, rats , Guinea pigs ,etc) so she got herself a hamster, and she ended up giving it to me when she got bored with it.

( it passed in its sleep like 7 months ago after being 2 1/2 years old) Anyway, she isn’t home to train the dog, so I train it, but whenever my mom gets home all the training we have done goes down the drain. He play bites everyone when they come into the house.

I have tried correcting this behaviour, but my mom keeps letting him jump and bite. I, myself, have payed for obedience classes for the dog, but my mom has not taken him to them.

As for the cat, my sister my sister keeps it locked in her room most of the day, and only lets them roam at night. The litter box is not in my sister's room, it’s in the bathroom.

( when my sister isnt home I do move the litter box to her room so the cat can at least use the bathroom). I also think the cat does like me, she makes biscuits on me, gives big blinks, and follows me for attention.

Last night when I was crying she sat and watched shows with me for 3 hours, letting me pet her belly, and showing me her belly, she also does like the inbetween your legs thing that almost makes me fall flat on my face at night, so I had to get her a bell so I know she is there. ( she is a black cat) I also have taken some of your advice, and got some cat treats, and those like gogert cat treats.

( I will not be feeding her them often)

Understanding the Psychology of Jealousy

Feeling envious of your sister for getting the cat you've always wanted is a natural human emotion that many people experience at some point in their lives. Jealousy often arises when we perceive a threat to something we deeply desire, such as affection, attention, or companionship. It's important to acknowledge these feelings rather than suppress them, as they can provide insight into our desires and values.

According to research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, such feelings can be amplified by social comparisons, especially within family dynamics. When we see a sibling receiving something we long for, it can heighten our sense of inadequacy or longing. Recognizing that these emotions are common can help normalize your experience, allowing you to process your feelings in a healthier way. Embracing open communication with loved ones about such emotions can foster understanding and support.

Comment from u/Electrical_Living788

Comment from u/Puzzled-Mastodon-703

Effective communication is crucial in navigating feelings of jealousy, especially within family dynamics. Expressing your feelings to your sister and mother may foster understanding and support rather than resentment, allowing for a more harmonious relationship. By sharing your thoughts, you open the door to empathy and compassion, which can significantly alleviate the burden of jealousy.

Dr. John Gottman, a leading relationship researcher, emphasizes that open dialogue can lead to emotional intimacy and conflict resolution. He believes that discussing feelings openly can strengthen bonds and create a safe space for vulnerability. Consider scheduling a calm, private conversation with your sister about your feelings surrounding the cat. This approach not only addresses the issue at hand but also reinforces your commitment to maintaining a healthy and supportive family environment.

Comment from u/Fuzzy-Ad1993

Comment from u/Armadillo_Prudent

The Role of Preparation and Expectation

Investing effort in preparing for the cat's arrival likely heightened your anticipation and enjoyment. This phenomenon, known as the 'anticipation effect,' suggests that the buildup of excitement can intensify your emotional state, making the eventual experience even more rewarding. The act of setting up your home, selecting toys, and researching care tips contributes to a sense of involvement and connection before the new pet even arrives.

Research indicates that anticipation can lead to heightened emotional responses when the desired outcome is not achieved. This means that while waiting for something you look forward to can be thrilling, it can also set you up for a deeper sense of disappointment if things do not go as planned. Acknowledging this can help you process your disappointment more effectively, allowing you to navigate the emotional landscape with greater resilience and understanding.

Comment from u/revengeofthebiscuit

Comment from u/InternallyEndless

Understanding the psychology behind your feelings can significantly aid in managing them effectively. Emotions such as jealousy often reflect a deep-seated desire for something, rather than indicating a personal flaw or weakness. By acknowledging this, you can begin to unravel the complexities of your emotions and address the underlying issues that trigger them.

According to the American Psychological Association, engaging in self-reflection can be a valuable tool in this transformative process. One effective method is to consider journaling your thoughts; this practice allows you to explore your feelings more deeply. Through writing, you can gain clarity on what specific experiences or symbols, such as the cat, truly represent for you in your emotional landscape. This exploration can lead to greater self-awareness and ultimately help you navigate your emotions with more confidence and understanding.

Comment from u/AstraeaMoonrise

Comment from u/InfernalKaneki

Coping Mechanisms and Emotional Regulation

Developing emotional regulation skills can significantly aid in managing feelings of jealousy, which often arise in various aspects of life, including relationships and professional settings. Techniques such as mindfulness and cognitive restructuring are effective tools that can help you respond to these emotions more appropriately and constructively.

Practicing mindfulness, as suggested by researchers at Harvard University, allows you to observe your feelings without judgment, creating space for more constructive emotions to emerge. By tuning into the present moment, you can better understand the triggers of your jealousy and explore the underlying thoughts that contribute to these feelings.

Additionally, cognitive restructuring involves identifying negative thought patterns and replacing them with more positive, rational ones. This dual approach not only helps in managing jealousy but also enhances overall emotional well-being, leading to healthier relationships with yourself and others.

Comment from u/Patient-Status9143

Comment from u/symbionica

It's essential to remember that feeling envious is a natural response in situations like this. Emotions such as envy can often arise when we see others enjoying something we desire. Instead of beating yourself up over these feelings, consider using this as a valuable learning opportunity to explore your own desires and attachments.

Reflecting on why you wanted the cat can lead to significant personal growth and better self-understanding. Developmental psychologists emphasize the value of self-awareness, suggesting that by examining our emotions, we can gain insights into what truly matters to us. This process not only helps in understanding our current feelings but also in recognizing patterns that may influence future decisions.

Ultimately, embracing these emotions rather than suppressing them can pave the way for deeper introspection and a more fulfilling life. Recognizing the root of your envy can transform it into motivation for positive change.

Comment from u/CalicoStaff

Comment from u/LifeCanBeAboxOfSh-

Importance of Family Dynamics

To prevent similar feelings of jealousy in the future, consider implementing a comprehensive three-step approach: Immediate (today), Short-term (1–2 weeks), and Longer-term (1–3 months). Start by practicing gratitude for what you have, which can be a powerful tool in shifting your mindset. Focus on the positive aspects of your relationship with your sister, reminding yourself of the unique bond that you share.

In the short term, engage in shared activities with your sister that involve the cat, such as playing together or taking turns caring for it. This not only helps to build a sense of camaraderie but also fosters positive interactions that can strengthen your relationship. Over the longer term, work on establishing your own space for companionship, like volunteering at a local animal shelter, where you can connect with animals in need and meet new people, fulfilling your desire for connection and reducing feelings of jealousy.

Comment from u/Special-Solution5555

Comment from u/caramac2

What are your thoughts on this situation? Share your perspective in the comments below.

Comment from u/pwolf1111

Comment from u/WhereWeretheAdults

Comment from u/ffopel

Comment from u/Heavy-Macaron2004

Psychological Analysis

Feeling jealous in this situation is completely natural; it often stems from a perceived loss or threat to something we deeply desire. In this case, the cat represents not just a pet but also a sense of fulfillment and ownership that you’ve worked hard for. It’s important to acknowledge these feelings and consider open communication with your family, which can help navigate the emotional complexity and perhaps lead to a more supportive environment.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, the feelings of jealousy you're experiencing are a normal part of human emotions. Understanding the psychology behind these emotions can help you manage them effectively. As Dr. Dan Siegel, psychiatrist and author, states, "Emotions are a vital part of our experience, and learning to navigate them is crucial for our well-being" (Dr. Dan Siegel). Remember, communication is key in resolving such issues. Don't hesitate to express your feelings to your family, and use this as an opportunity to strengthen your emotional regulation skills. Additionally, Dr. Tara Brach, a meditation teacher, emphasizes, "Awareness and compassion are essential in transforming our emotional responses" (Dr. Tara Brach).