Woman Considers Evicting Husband's Cousin and His Family, Turns to the Internet for Guidance Because It Would Leave Them Homeless
"We'd have felt bad allowing her to become homeless while pregnant."
Couples, particularly those who have been together for a long time, frequently find themselves in cycles of arguments where they fight repeatedly over the same issues. Interestingly, despite the topic of the repeated dispute changing, the underlying causes and the general trajectory of the argument often remain the same.
The OP and her husband recently moved into her mother-in-law's old house after inheriting it following her passing. The husband's cousin was already living there when they moved in, despite being told he would need to vacate, as he claimed he wasn't in a position to do so yet.
They decided to allow him to stay until he got back on his feet. Upon arriving at the house, they discovered that the cousin's girlfriend was pregnant, so they felt bad about allowing her to become homeless while pregnant.
Six months later, they were still there with a newborn baby. Additionally, they were fighting constantly, and the OP didn't want her own child to have to witness that.
They were told to find somewhere else to stay, to which the cousin responded with a scoff. There is still no sign of them moving out, and the girlfriend has been canceling job interviews whenever she receives them.
They continue to fight daily, and the OP is exhausted, so she sought advice online.
The Story Kicks Off
Reddit/No_Board1919They Had Done Nothing Up to This Point to Progress Towards That
Reddit/No_Board1919OP Feels Like They've Given Them More Than Enough of a Chance to Get on Their Feet
Reddit/No_Board1919The Ethical Dimensions of Eviction
Dr. Sarah Thompson, a social psychologist, points out that the decision to evict a family member can be fraught with ethical dilemmas. Such actions often reflect the complex interplay between personal responsibility and familial obligations. Research indicates that family members frequently struggle with the balance between helping and enabling, which can lead to long-term psychological consequences for both parties.
According to studies published in the Journal of Social Issues, the emotional impact of eviction can extend beyond the immediate situation, affecting family relationships and mental health.
OP Has Offered the Following Explanation for Why They Think They Might Be the AH:
I might be the AH because if I kick out the entire family, it would make them homeless.And the Comments Roll In...
Reddit/No_Board1919Sending the Freeloader Over to Their House
Reddit/No_Board1919People Who Think They Deserve a Free Ride
Reddit/No_Board1919The psychological concept of 'familial loyalty' often complicates these decisions. Individuals may feel torn between their own needs and the obligation to support family members, especially during vulnerable times. This conflict can lead to significant stress and anxiety as individuals navigate their roles within the family system.
Experts recommend engaging in honest discussions about boundaries and responsibilities, which can clarify expectations and reduce feelings of guilt.
The OP Should Protect Her Child from That
Reddit/No_Board1919The OP Reveals This in the Comments
I've been trying to avoid putting an eviction on their records, but that might just be what they need at this point. I looked into it already when the 90 days were up and determined that it would be our only legal option, though I decided against it since having it on their records will make it even harder for them to find a place.Serving Eviction Papers
Reddit/No_Board1919It's a Messed-Up World
Reddit/No_Board1919Understanding the Impact of Homelessness
The implications of homelessness are profound and multifaceted. Research from the National Alliance to End Homelessness highlights that the psychological toll of losing one’s home can lead to increased rates of mental health issues, including anxiety and depression. This reality underscores the importance of approaching eviction decisions with compassion and understanding.
Families are encouraged to explore all available resources, such as community support services, before making irreversible decisions regarding a family member's living situation.
The OP's Not Responsible for Housing Them
Reddit/No_Board1919
The OP Can't Save the Baby
Reddit/No_Board1919
Stepping In and Helping
Reddit/No_Board1919
To navigate such complex situations, individuals can benefit from seeking guidance from mental health professionals. Therapy can provide a safe space to explore feelings of guilt and obligation while developing strategies for maintaining healthy boundaries. Studies show that individuals who engage in therapy during familial conflicts often experience better outcomes and improved relationships.
Some Redditors suggest that there might be shelters for homeless women with children where the OP resides, allowing her to leave her husband's relative on his own. The girlfriend doesn't want to work, and they won't ever leave on their own, but it's not due to the threat of homelessness; rather, it is because of their poor parenting.
Homelessness can change, but bad parents are permanent. The OP was declared not the AH, and that's a wrap.
Psychological Analysis
This situation reflects the complexities of familial obligations and the emotional struggles that arise from such decisions. It's crucial for individuals to weigh their responsibilities carefully and consider the potential long-term effects on family relationships.
Analysis generated by AI
Analysis & Alternative Approaches
In summary, the decision to evict a family member involves navigating a complex web of emotional and ethical considerations. Understanding the impact of homelessness and engaging in open communication about responsibilities can facilitate healthier family dynamics. With appropriate support and resources, families can address these challenges more compassionately.
