Criminologist Explains Why We Can’t Stop Watching Netflix’s "Monsters: The Ed Gein Story"

Since Netflix dropped 'Monsters: The Ed Gein Story' on October 3, everyone seems to be talking about it. People can’t get enough of the horrifying tale of one of America’s most infamous criminals.

The eight-part series dives into the twisted world of Ed Gein, a man from Plainfield, Wisconsin, who was convicted of killing two women in the 1950s. While he may have been suspected of more murders, no one could ever prove it.

Gein’s crimes went far beyond murder. He also dug up graves and used human skin to make clothing and furniture, earning him the nickname “The Butcher of Plainfield.”

But why are we so obsessed with watching this kind of extreme true crime? Criminologist Professor David Wilson spoke to ITV’s This Morning to explain what’s behind our fascination.

Wilson says it comes down to the extremes of human psychology. “People want to know why someone would behave in such a horrifying way,” he explained, pointing out that Gein’s crimes are so extraordinary they become almost unthinkable.

He added that part of the appeal is safety. Watching these stories allows viewers to learn about extreme behaviors and reassure themselves, thinking, this couldn’t happen to me. It’s a mix of fear, curiosity, and self-preservation.

The criminologist also notes that people often watch to reflect on their own morality. “We want to see how far someone can go and make sure we know we’re different from that,” Wilson said. True crime, in this sense, becomes a mirror to our own humanity.

Monsters doesn’t just recount Gein’s gruesome acts — it also critiques society. Wilson compared the series to Bret Easton Ellis’s American Psycho, saying it challenges viewers to ask themselves why they’re so drawn to horror.

“It’s holding a mirror up to culture,” Wilson said. “Why are you so obsessed with this kind of material?” In other words, the show isn’t just about Gein — it’s about us and our morbid curiosity.

He Also Explained the Gendered Angle of This Fascination.

Men are statistically more likely to be victims of lethal attacks, yet often feel invincible when watching these stories. Women, on the other hand, are more likely to engage with true crime to understand the psychology of perpetrators and learn how to protect themselves.

Netflix

Charlie Hunnam's Portrayal of Gein Is Mesmerizing.

Netflix

Despite the Horror, the Show Has Inspired Plenty of Discussion About Why Society Can’t Look Away.

Netflix

Psychological Insights

Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett, an emotion researcher, explains that our fascination with true crime narratives, like 'Monsters: The Ed Gein Story,' stems from a complex interplay of fear and curiosity. This genre allows viewers to confront their fears in a safe environment, providing a sense of control over the horrifying elements of human nature.

Moreover, Barrett's research highlights how engaging with such content can trigger emotional responses that enhance our understanding of morality and societal boundaries. This emotional engagement can lead to catharsis, allowing viewers to explore their own limits of empathy and horror.

Experts suggest that while consuming intense narratives, it’s essential to maintain a balance between entertainment and reality. Dr. Brené Brown, a vulnerability researcher, emphasizes the importance of processing emotions rather than merely consuming distressing content. She advocates for discussions around the impact of these stories on mental health.

To enhance your viewing experience, consider journaling your thoughts or discussing the themes with friends. This practice can foster deeper understanding and emotional processing, turning passive consumption into an active exploration of human behavior and morality.

Gein’s Crimes Later Influenced Numerous Hollywood Horror Films, Making Him a Macabre Icon in Popular Culture.

Netflix

Gein Was Technically Only Convicted of Two Murders.

So, while he may not technically be classified as a serial killer, the obsession with his story fits into a long-standing cultural fascination with killers who push the limits of human behavior.

Netflix

Wilson says the show’s popularity is a mix of curiosity, fear, and a desire to understand the darkest corners of human nature. “It’s true horror and true psychology rolled into one,” he said, “and that’s why people can’t stop watching.”

Ultimately, our obsession with Ed Gein reflects more about us than him. 'Monsters' isn’t just a show about a killer — it’s a chilling mirror that asks viewers to examine their own fascination with the macabre.

Psychological Framework & Solutions

The enduring appeal of true crime series like 'Monsters: The Ed Gein Story' offers a unique opportunity for reflection on deeper societal issues and personal fears. Experts like Dr. Dan Siegel emphasize that understanding the psychology behind these narratives can foster empathy and critical thinking. As viewers, engaging thoughtfully with this content can illuminate the complexities of human behavior while also serving as a catalyst for personal growth.

By actively processing our reactions and discussing these themes, we can transform passive viewing into a meaningful exploration of our own values and societal norms.