Elon Musk’s Troubles Are Starting to Hurt Tesla’s Bottom Line

Electric vehicles have become synonymous with California. The state’s roads are famously populated with Teslas, supported by a strong eco-conscious community and generous incentives to encourage greener driving.

However, recent figures suggest that Californians might be falling out of love with their once-beloved Tesla. Tesla's sales in California dropped significantly in the early months of 2025, highlighting challenges that seem linked not only to market competition but also to public reactions against the company's controversial CEO, Elon Musk.

According to data from the California New Car Dealers Association, registrations of Tesla’s electric vehicles dropped sharply by 15.1% in the first quarter of the year. This slump marks a noticeable decline, pushing Tesla's share of California's electric vehicle market down from 55.5% last year to 43.9%. In contrast, overall electric vehicle sales from rival brands grew by 35% during the same period.

Industry analysts suggest a couple of reasons for this shift. "An aging product lineup and backlash against Elon Musk’s political initiatives are likely key factors contributing to the decline in Tesla's BEV market share," stated the quarterly industry report.

This statement aligns with the reality that Tesla’s flagship Model Y, although still the best-selling electric car in California, experienced a dramatic 30 percent drop in sales compared to the previous year.

Tesla’s dealership in Corte Madera, California.

Further complicating matters, Tesla confirmed that it experienced several weeks of lost production due to retooling factories for an updated version of its Model Y, slowing down delivery and potentially turning off prospective buyers who might not want to wait.

However, production hiccups alone don’t fully explain Tesla’s current struggles. Influenced by Elon Musk's increasingly controversial public persona and political moves, public sentiment appears to be playing a crucial role.

Musk’s prominent role in the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) and his aggressive strategies to reduce federal workforce numbers have sparked widespread outrage. Protests targeting Tesla vehicles and dealerships have increased as part of broader demonstrations against these political actions.

Getty

President Trump with Elon Musk

President Donald Trump’s unusual move to publicly back Musk and Tesla—using a photo-op outside the White House—seems to have done little to bolster the brand's image in California.

Trump's provocative threat to deport Tesla vandals to El Salvador further highlighted the escalating tension but failed to mitigate the decline in sales.

nytimes

This sales drop in California is particularly notable given the state’s historical enthusiasm for electric vehicles and its central role in pushing EV adoption across the country. Over two million electric vehicles currently cruise California roads, supported by state initiatives like the Clean Vehicle Assistance Program, which makes buying an electric car significantly more affordable.

Yet, despite these favorable conditions, the recent shift towards competing electric vehicle brands hints at an important turning point. Drivers in California, once loyal to Tesla's vision and product, are now increasingly attracted to alternative offerings from rival automakers.

Dr. Dan Ariely, a behavioral economist at Duke University, emphasizes that consumer behavior often reflects deeper emotional connections rather than mere financial incentives. He argues that Tesla's recent challenges may stem from shifting consumer perceptions and loyalty, which can be deeply affected by leadership decisions and public relations issues.

As Ariely suggests, consumers are more likely to stay loyal to brands that resonate emotionally with them. Therefore, Tesla could benefit from enhancing its community engagement and transparency to rebuild trust among its customer base.

In the face of heightened competition and complex public relations challenges, Tesla’s dominance in the Golden State seems less certain than before. For a company that once defined electric transportation in California, this sales downturn raises critical questions about Tesla’s future—questions that Elon Musk will need to address quickly if he hopes to regain the brand’s iconic status.

Simon Sinek, renowned leadership expert, highlights the importance of strong leadership in maintaining a company's reputation. He notes that when leaders face personal controversies, it can create uncertainty for consumers, potentially impacting their purchasing decisions.

To mitigate this, Sinek recommends that Tesla refocus on its core mission—advancing sustainable energy—and communicate this effectively to its audience. By emphasizing its commitment to innovation and customer satisfaction, Tesla can regain market share while reassuring consumers of its long-term vision.

As Tesla navigates these turbulent waters, it’s crucial to recognize that brand loyalty is often tied to the emotional narratives surrounding a company. Dr. Jonathan Haidt, social psychologist, explains that consumers resonate with brands that align with their values and beliefs.

For Tesla to recover its standing in the market, it must not only address its leadership challenges but also actively engage with its community. By fostering an environment of open dialogue and reaffirming its commitment to sustainability, Tesla can rebuild trust and enhance its brand appeal moving forward.