Redditor Calls Out Brother for Locking Up His Dogs in Cages All Day and Not Allowing Anyone to Access Them

House dogs are often seen as members of the family, and as such, they should be treated well. This includes ensuring they have plenty of space to run around and play, as well as access to food and water.

With the love and joy these cute critters bring to our lives, it's hard to imagine why anyone would want to mistreat them. It's only proper that we treat them with the same respect and love that they show us.

There's nothing better than watching a dog run around and play with genuine happiness. They make us laugh, comfort us when we're feeling down, and are always there for a good cuddle.

Sadly, not everyone shares this view of dogs. Some people see them as nothing more than property or animals that have no feelings.

It's important to remember that dogs are living creatures that can feel pain, happiness, and fear, just like we can. They have emotions and can even become depressed.

This is why it's so important to ensure they're well cared for and not neglected by a person who is supposed to love them.

Redditor u/MTVoss recently shared a story on the "Am I the A**hole?" subreddit that categorizes his brother as a neglectful dog parent.

OP explains that he and his girlfriend have been taking care of his brother's two dogs since he works late and just leaves them locked up in cages all day. This includes taking them out for walks and feeding them.

However, his brother has now put a stop to this by saying they need permission before they can go into his room to take out the dogs. This came off as very insensitive to OP, who saw it as a way for his brother to neglect his dogs even more.

Unfortunately, both brothers got into a heated argument that has now put the dogs in a precarious situation. Check out the full story below:

This Redditor has brought a possible case of animal cruelty to the community for deliberation

MTVoss / reddit.com

OP and his girlfriend have been taking care of his brother's dogs. But after his brother demanded that they ask for permission first, they decided to take a hands-off approach. Unfortunately, the poor dogs are the ones that will suffer for this decision.

MTVoss / reddit.com

We gathered some reactions from the Reddit community:

"Either tell your brother to stuff it and keep taking care of the dogs, or call animal control and report the abuse of these animals."

MTVoss / reddit.com

Animal Welfare and Emotional Responsibility

Research in animal behavior and welfare emphasizes that neglecting pets can have significant psychological ramifications, both for the animals and the owners.

Dr. John Bradshaw, an expert in anthrozoology, suggests that the social isolation experienced by caged dogs can lead to behavioral issues, reflecting a lack of emotional understanding from their owners.

This neglect is not just a moral issue; it can also indicate a deeper disconnect in the owner's ability to empathize with the needs of their pets.

"You are taking care of his dogs and meeting their needs. He should be grateful."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"Your parents need to get involved because the dogs will be suffering. They are not birds. If he is never home, then why does he have dogs anyway?"

MTVoss / reddit.com

"Keeping dogs in cages all day is animal cruelty. I know he's your brother, but please talk to the animal welfare people where you live, at least for advice on whether it's okay and needs to be reported."

MTVoss / reddit.com

Understanding the psychological underpinnings of pet ownership can reveal a lot about human behavior, particularly in terms of empathy and responsibility.

Studies have shown that individuals who understand the emotional needs of their pets often have higher levels of emotional intelligence.

This disconnect in recognizing a pet's needs may indicate underlying issues in the owner's emotional awareness, which could benefit from therapeutic exploration.

"Call animal welfare, as this is cruelty."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"Dogs shouldn’t be in their cage or crate the entire day. If you need to call an animal protection service, do it."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"You need to get your parents involved now, and the dogs need to go to a home where they can be cared for and not locked in a cage for their whole lives."

MTVoss / reddit.com

The Importance of Advocacy in Animal Care

Animal advocates often highlight the psychological effects of confinement on pets, linking it to issues like anxiety and aggression.

Research shows that providing environments that allow for natural behaviors can significantly improve a pet's mental health and overall well-being.

Encouraging responsible pet ownership and advocating for better conditions can help foster healthier relationships between humans and their pets.

"Honestly, if I were your parents, I'd be ashamed that this was happening in my house and would force the dogs to be treated better."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"NTA. They’re his dogs, and at the end of the day, they’re his responsibility."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"You and your girlfriend were attempting to help him out, but if he wants to be an AH, then do not concern yourself with his dogs."

MTVoss / reddit.com

From a behavioral perspective, it’s essential to understand how neglect can reflect broader patterns of avoidance in relationships.

Individuals who struggle to connect with their pets might also face challenges in their human relationships, often avoiding emotional investments that feel overwhelming.

Encouraging open discussions about feelings and responsibilities can help owners confront these issues and foster more fulfilling connections.

"I understand where you are coming from, but if he's that upset about you taking his dogs for a walk when he's busy, then just leave them be and wait for him to ask you."

MTVoss / reddit.com

"YTA if you make the dogs suffer because your brother is an AH."

MTVoss / reddit.com

It's sad to see dogs being neglected, and even worse to see siblings fighting over it. The dogs are the ones who suffer the most in this situation.

We hope that the brothers can resolve their differences and come to a solution that is best for the dogs. They deserve to be loved and cared for, not left to survive by chance.

Do you think OP did the right thing by calling out his brother? Or do you believe that getting permission is necessary in this case?

Let us know your thoughts in the comments!

Practical Steps for Better Pet Care

For individuals looking to improve their pet care practices, starting with education is vital.

Resources like local animal shelters or veterinary behaviorists can provide valuable insights into the needs of pets and how to meet them effectively.

Additionally, creating a structured routine for pets that includes exercise, play, and social interaction can significantly improve their emotional well-being and the owner's relationship with them.

Psychological Analysis

The behavior exhibited by the brother reflects a troubling pattern of neglect that speaks to broader emotional issues surrounding empathy and connection.

Many individuals who fail to recognize the needs of their pets often struggle with emotional awareness in their interpersonal relationships as well.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

These insights resonate with established research on pet care and emotional responsibility, underscoring the need for thoughtful engagement in pet ownership.

Studies show that enhancing our understanding of animal behavior can lead to healthier interactions and a more profound sense of responsibility among pet owners.