Parenting Dilemma: Giving Daughter $60 a Week But Son Nothing - AITA?
AITA for giving my daughter $60 a week but not my son? Sibling tension erupts over unequal allowances - was favoritism at play or just a fair exchange?
Are you the a**hole for giving one child $60 a week and the other nothing? It's a dilemma many parents face when trying to balance fairness and individual circumstances within their family dynamic.
In this case, a mother shared her story of offering her daughter $60 a week for using her room as a work-from-home office, while her son received no financial compensation. The son expressed frustration over feeling left out and not having equal treatment.
The situation arose when the family moved due to the grandparents' declining health, leading to the mother needing a work-from-home setup in a limited space. Her daughter generously offered her room, suggesting a rent-like arrangement for compensation.
The mother agreed, recognizing the daughter's sacrifice of privacy. However, the son refused the same opportunity, leading to tensions and arguments within the family.
The Reddit thread is filled with diverse opinions on the matter. Some users empathize with the son's feelings of being uprooted and overlooked, while others commend the daughter's initiative and kindness.
Suggestions range from offering the son alternative opportunities to earn money to addressing the underlying issues of fairness and communication within the family. The debate delves into parenting styles, sibling dynamics, and the importance of considering each child's needs and emotions in such situations.
What do you think about this family's dilemma? Share your perspective on whether the mother is in the wrong for the disparate treatment of her children in this scenario.
Original Post
I (45F) have two kids, 17F and 15M. We moved earlier this year to be closer to my parents as my parents' health is declining.
My daughter was excited about the move, but my son has struggled to adjust. Due to the move, my job shifted to hybrid, and I needed a work-from-home setup.
My bedroom is too small, and the only options were the lounge or one of the kids’ rooms during school hours. I proposed this to them - my son flat-out refused ("no way in h**l"), but my daughter offered her room and half-joked about charging me rent for the space.
I thought it was fair, as I get a $20/day work-from-home allowance. I agreed to give it to her if she was okay with me setting up a small office in her room.
I work from 8:30 to 5:00, and she usually starts homework right after I finish, so it’s worked out well. Now the issue: my son is upset that his sister is getting $60.
I don’t do regular allowances, just canteen money (about $10/week) and other needs as they come up. I told him he had the same opportunity and was now out of luck.
He got angry and brought up the move, saying he never gets to see his friends. (For the record, I drive them back to visit every two weeks.) I told him I understood his feelings but said I wouldn’t tolerate being spoken to like that.
He then started an argument with his sister too - going in on her for being an opportunistic b***h, and she called him a whiny little a*****e. To cool off, I offered one of them the option to stay at their grandparents' for the night - not as a punishment but to break the tension.
My son opted to go, and while dropping him off, my mom told me I was favoring my daughter and should be paying them equally. My dad disagreed, saying my son had the chance and was out of luck.
AITA? ETA: The conversation took place over the course of the afternoon, and I didn’t immediately agree to the deal with my daughter.
I offered it to my son first, who reiterated "h**l no" and "get the f**k out of my room." I also should mention the reason I have the smallest room is due to the lack of insulation in the ceiling and flooring, making it damp, and as we’re heading into winter, I wasn’t sending either kid in there.
The room also fits a single bed and a set of drawers - with essentially no other space at all. We own the house in Auckland, NZ, and I don’t have the spare cash to get it insulated at the moment (or even fit any of my equipment to work from home in there).
Understanding Sibling Dynamics
Research from the University of Michigan highlights that sibling relationships can be profoundly affected by parental favoritism, which may lead to feelings of resentment and competition.
Dr. Julie D. Schwartz, a developmental psychologist, points out that unequal treatment can foster long-term emotional consequences, affecting both siblings' self-esteem and their relationship with each other.
This phenomenon is often rooted in perceived fairness, where children constantly compare their experiences and allowances, leading to a sense of injustice that can linger into adulthood.
Comment from u/mavenmim
Comment from u/Smarterthanuthink867
According to a study published in the Journal of Family Psychology, children who perceive favoritism are more likely to exhibit behavioral issues, including aggression and withdrawal.
The findings suggest that addressing feelings of inequality proactively can mitigate these adverse effects. Parents are encouraged to have open discussions with their children about feelings of favoritism and ensure that both siblings feel valued in their unique ways.
Comment from u/bahahahahahhhaha
Comment from u/Atlas_Hid
Psychological Concepts of Fairness
The concept of fairness is crucial in child development, often influencing how children perceive their worth within the family unit.
Research indicates that children develop a sense of justice as early as preschool age, making it vital for parents to understand how their decisions impact their children's emotional health.
Creating a balanced environment where both children feel equally loved and supported can promote healthier sibling relationships.
Comment from u/thatcoolguy60
Comment from u/alyxmorganvo
Studies suggest that parental communication plays a significant role in mitigating sibling rivalry.
When parents explicitly acknowledge each child's unique strengths and contributions, it can help foster a sense of individual value, reducing feelings of competition.
Implementing regular family meetings where each child is encouraged to share their feelings can enhance emotional bonding and understanding.
Comment from u/Exotic-Blacksmith-56
Comment from u/Crafter_2307
Long-term Implications of Favoritism
Dr. Susan McHale from Pennsylvania State University emphasizes that favoritism can lead to long-term relational issues, not just between siblings but also in their adult relationships.
Her research suggests that children who feel favored may struggle with entitlement or develop anxiety regarding their worth when not in the limelight.
Conversely, the unfavored child may carry feelings of inadequacy that manifest in various life challenges, including relationship difficulties.
Comment from u/ImpressiveOwl854
Comment from u/cyanidelemonade
It’s important for parents to reflect on their actions and consider how emotional responses can be shaped by their choices.
Utilizing principles from family systems therapy can help parents understand their dynamics and the potential ripple effects of their decisions.
Seeking family counseling could provide a platform for addressing and resolving these issues constructively.
Comment from u/SeePerspectives
Comment from u/HolyUnicornBatman
We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.
Comment from u/maloneth
Comment from u/Ok-Willow-9145
Comment from u/TofuPropaganda
Comment from u/badassmillz
Comment from u/Kebar8
Comment from u/Chen932000
Comment from u/philautos
Comment from u/DoontGiveHimTheStick
Psychological Analysis
This situation illustrates a common psychological conflict influenced by perceived favoritism, which can deeply affect sibling relationships.
It's essential to recognize that children interpret parental behavior through their unique emotional lenses, which can lead to feelings of inadequacy or entitlement. Addressing these feelings openly can help foster healthier dynamics between siblings.
Analysis generated by AI
Analysis & Alternative Approaches
In conclusion, the implications of perceived favoritism extend beyond childhood, affecting emotional health and sibling bonds into adulthood.
According to research published in the American Psychological Association, fostering open communication and equitable treatment can significantly improve family dynamics and emotional resilience.
