Woman Refuses to Help Her Half-Sister Change Her Mom's Funeral Wish, Gets Told Off

As a person approaches the end of their life, they may have many requests, wants, expectations, and challenges, both from themselves and from others they consider important in their lives. Granting the person's last request before they pass away is one of the difficulties that those left behind will have to handle.

OP's parents had her and her older brother, but their mom died when she was 9. OP's dad remarried later on to his second wife, Janet, who was a widow with three kids from her late husband.

For the first year, they had a typical marriage, and they even had OP's half-sister, Katie, at that time. However, right after Katie was born, their marriage changed, as neither of them wanted a traditional marriage.

They weren't in love with each other, as both were still devoted to their late spouses. So, they stayed married but chose to live as companions instead.

From an early point, both of them made it clear that if they were to pass away, they would want to be buried with their first spouses. Now that OP's stepmom is gone, Katie is fighting for her not to be buried with her first husband so she can be buried with her dad when he goes.

Katie told OP that she was supposed to help and support her in this, but she refused. Read the full story in OP's own words below.

OP Kicks Off Her Story

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

OP's Dad and Stepmom Would Act Like Friends More Than a Couple

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

"I'm Supposed to Help Her and Support Her in This, and I'm Refusing"

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

Navigating Family Expectations

Dr. Emily Chen, a clinical psychologist, emphasizes that family expectations can create significant stress, especially during emotionally charged times such as funerals. The decision to alter funeral plans often brings up deeper issues of familial loyalty and respect for the deceased's wishes. Research shows that these situations can lead to family rifts as differing opinions clash.

A study published in the Journal of Family Psychology found that unresolved conflicts around end-of-life decisions can negatively affect family dynamics for years.

OP Has Offered the Following Explanation for Why They Think They Might Be the AH:

I did not help my half-sister when she asked me to help her change the plans for her mom's funeral (not my mom). She's really spiraling, and I think I could have maybe done more without actively starting a fight with strangers. She feels abandoned, and I know that is hard for her. I think there is also some trauma from her childhood. I am her older half-sister, and even though I would not say we are close, clearly my response hurt her. So, this is why I question if I'm TA or not.

And the Comments from Other Redditors Roll In...

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

This Is an Extremely Crappy Situation

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

The Poor Girl Basically Has No Family of Her Own

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

From a communication perspective, it's vital for family members to express their feelings openly. The psychological concept of 'open dialogue' can help mitigate misunderstandings and foster a collaborative atmosphere. According to research in the Journal of Communication, families that practice open communication tend to have healthier relationships and better conflict resolution.

Encouraging honest discussions about funeral plans and emotional needs can lead to more cohesive family decisions.

Keep Doing What You're Doing

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

The Parents Created This Odd Situation

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

It Would Be the Right Thing to Do

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

The Psychological Impact of Grief

Grief can manifest in various ways, influencing how individuals react to family decisions. Dr. Robert Neimeyer, a leading researcher in grief psychology, explains that grief can provoke feelings of anger and frustration, particularly when individuals feel unheard. This emotional volatility can complicate family dynamics, especially during sensitive times.

Understanding these emotional responses can help family members navigate their interactions more compassionately.

All the OP Can Do Is Let Her Know

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

This Is the Time to Reach Out

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

Both Parents Should Be Buried Where They Wish to

Reddit/Big-Warning8649

To support emotional well-being, individuals are encouraged to practice self-care during grief. Engaging in mindfulness and reflection can help individuals process their emotions without judgment. According to studies published in the American Journal of Psychology, self-care practices improve emotional resilience, enabling individuals to cope better with familial conflicts during grieving periods.

Some Redditors say that deceased people don't know or care what happens to their remains, and since there are enough living family members, their desires should be honored unless the whole family agrees otherwise. So, OP's insistence on not going against it isn't bad.

Yes, Katie isn't cool with it, but that's what the parents told them they wanted, and probably everyone else as well. OP was declared not the AH, and that's a wrap!

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the emotional complexities surrounding family decisions during grief. It's essential for family members to engage in open discussions and acknowledge each other's feelings to prevent misunderstandings.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, navigating family dynamics during grief requires sensitivity and understanding. Open communication and recognition of emotional responses are crucial in mitigating potential conflicts. By fostering an environment where all voices are heard, families can navigate these challenging situations with greater compassion and understanding.